Debatable - Judgment Search Results

District of Columbia Vs. Heller

Court: US Supreme Court

..... any insight into the intent of the framers and all were made during pitched political debates so that they are better characterized as advocacy than good faith attempts at constitutional ..... civilians primarily soldiers on occasion the signification attributed to the term militia appears from the debates in the convention the history and legislation of colonies and states and the writings of .....

Chamber of Commerce of United States Vs. Brown

Court: US Supreme Court

..... they regulate employer speech about union organizing under circumstances in which congress intended free debate the ninth circuit reversed concluding that congress did not intend to preclude states from ..... labor related activity was consistent not inconsistent with the policy of encourag ing free debate embedded in its labor statutes finally the law normally gives legislatures broad authority to .....

Ashoka Kumar Thakur Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors. (Obc Judgment)

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: 2008(56)BLJR1292; 2008(3)CTC97; [2008(3)JCR176(SC)]; JT2008(5)SC1; (2008)3MLJ1105(SC); 2008(5)SCALE1; (2008)6SCC1; 2008AIRSCW2899; 2008(3)Supreme331; 2008(2)LH(SC)1534

..... not formal equality 59 it was also submitted that the speeches in the parliament constitutional debates text books of authors and views expressed in articles do not normally constitute evidence ..... 5 anglo american jurisprudence unlike other systems has generally frowned upon the use of parliamentary debates and press discussions as throwing light upon the meaning of statutory provisions willes j in .....

R (on the Application of Animal Defenders International) (Appellants) ...

Court: House of Lords

..... of bbc party political broadcasts or the including in programmes of properly balanced discussions or debates where the persons taking part expressed opinions and put forward arguments of a political ..... controlled to prevent wealthier parties or groups exerting undue influence on the course of political debate but similar considerations applied outside election periods para 96 and para 98 no sensible .....

Lotus Gums and Chemicals Vs. Income Tax Officer

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Jodhpur

Reported in: (2008)116TTJ(Jodh.)542

..... the same was bad in law and the issue was highly debatable which could not have been rectified consequent to processing of return ..... purpose of section 80hhc of the act and as such the debatable issue do not give jurisdiction to the assessing authority to ..... uncontroverted findings reached by the authorities below there being thus no debate as canvassed by the assessee appellant we find it difficult to .....

Baze Vs. Rees

Court: US Supreme Court

..... 17 23 justice stevens concluded that instead of ending the controversy this case will generate debate not only about the constitutionality of the three drug protocol and specifically about the justification ..... record instead of ending the controversy i am now convinced that this case will generate debate not only about the constitutionality of the three drug protocol and specifically about the .....

Marlborough Polychem Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax

Court: Rajasthan

Reported in: (2009)221CTR(Raj)771

..... to deduction under sections 80hh and 80 1 which involved a debatable question on which the difference of opinion exist 2 whether ..... of filing of the return the question was very much a debatable question and therefore the assessee had claimed deductions which deduction ..... admissibility of deduction under sections 80hh and 80 i was a debatable question in view of conflicting judgments of the other high .....

R (on the Application of Bancoult) (Respondent) Vs. Secretary of State ...

Court: House of Lords

..... legislation enacted by the executive through her majesty in council and legislation subject to democratic debate in parliament in the present case the process adopted affected basic common law rights ..... ordinance with a number of known representatives not only was there no opportunity for democratic debate outside or within parliament but the process of parliamentary scrutiny of orders in council .....

In Re P and Others (Ap) (Appellants) (Northern Ireland)

Court: House of Lords

..... possible and indeed a proposal to this effect was made during the debates on the draft legislation however parliament chose instead to lay down ..... in structure to the bill which had been published in 1996 the debate about unmarried adopters 94 the bill and all the preceding reviews ..... were passed at the report stage in the commons hansard hc debates 16 may 2002 vol 385 cols 967 1006 97 the arguments .....

Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. Kartar Singh and Co.

Court: Punjab and Haryana

Reported in: (2008)218CTR(P& H)197; [2008]302ITR66(P& H)

..... such claim of deduction has specifically been allowed by the tribunal or not was highly debatable issue as per the provisions of section 154 the authority concerned is competent to rectify ..... facts which are apparent from the record and all those issues which are debatable and involve prolonged arguments debate where two conceivable views are possible fall outside the scope of the provisions .....