Debatable - Judgment Search Results

City of Boerne Vs. Flores

Court: US Supreme Court

..... overridden only when necessary to secure important government purposes the virginia legislature may have debated the issue most fully in may 1776 the virginia constitutional convention wrote a constitution ..... controversy surrounding virginia s general assessment bill of 1784 are particularly illuminating virginia s debate over religious issues did not end with its adoption of a constitutional free .....

Bharat Mining and Engg. Co. Vs. Deputy Commissioner of

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Mumbai

Reported in: (1998)229ITR60(Mum.)

..... interest income constituted a business income or otherwise was also highly debatable question but it was to be considered with reference to ..... by the assessee s counsel that the matter is highly debatable these observations were made by the commissioner in the context ..... from the remarks of the cit extracted herein before highly debatable he has accordingly set aside the assessment with a direction .....

Mcdowell and Co. Ltd. Vs. Assistant Commissioner of

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT

Reported in: (1997)62ITD276(Bang.)

..... the argument of the learned departmental representative itself the point is a debatable one hence if the ao has any doubt the point has to ..... been invoked hence it is argued that without making an inquiry a debatable issue on which the claim rests cannot be disallowed u s 143 ..... the return as filed and only when there is no doubt or debate in such circumstances the order becomes final in the sense that it .....

Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Rampur Distillery and Chemical C ...

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Delhi

Reported in: (1998)64ITD279(Delhi)

..... to prove that such additions and disallowances were of a debatable nature he further invited our attention towards the instructions issued ..... the view that the disallowance of travelling expenses was a debatable item and such a disallowance could not have been made ..... out that the allowability of such expenses and deductions are debatable and require further investigations and hence those are beyond the .....

Washington Vs. Glucksberg

Court: US Supreme Court

..... proposals between 1991 1994 to legalize assisted suicide 16 other countries are embroiled in similar debates the supreme court of canada recently rejected a claim that the canadian charter of ..... important observation that our holding today is fully consistent with a continuation of the vigorous debate about the morality legality and practicality of physician assisted suicide in a democratic society .....

Samatha Vs. State of A.P. and ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1997SC3297; JT1997(6)SC449; 1997(4)SCALE746; (1997)8SCC191; [1997]Supp2SCR305

..... of the directive principles article 31c protected the law from needless undering nbsp and rancorous debate on the question whether nbsp the law contravened article 14 sconcept of the equality before ..... 131 it would also be open to the appropriate legislature preferably after a thorough nbsp debate conference of all the chief ministers ministers holding the concerned ministry and the nbsp prime .....

V.S. Mukthar and anr. Vs. Principal Secretary to Govt., Municipal Admi ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 1998(1)ALD153; 1998(1)ALT467

..... section 46 commands that there is an automatic termination of the debate on the expiration of two hours from the time appointed for ..... motion is required to be put to vote immediately after the debate 15 there is no specific provision as rightly contended by the ..... prevented respondents 3 and 4 to express their view during the debate in the meeting and nothing in law prevents them from exercising .....

Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. Schlumberger Sea Co. Inc.

Court: Kolkata

Reported in: [2003]264ITR331(Cal)

..... under section 154 could be used is itself a matter of debate or dispute we should finally settle it after the questions are ..... under section 154 was originally used in a matter which is debatable or disputable or not then the original matter itself is thereby ..... immediately branded as one on which there can be debate or dispute the rule in regard to the first question therefore .....

Camps Newfound/Owatonna, Inc. Vs. Town of Harrison

Court: US Supreme Court

..... imported into the country and that though imperfectly preserved the debates in the congress are full of the subject of ..... barriers of course there are passages in the available convention debates which indicate that interstate trade barriers remained a concern ..... my speculation is at least consistent with the recorded convention debates roger sherman proposed the requirement that any revenues raised by .....

Pradeep Kumar Har Saran Lal Vs. Assessing Officer

Court: Allahabad

Reported in: (1997)141CTR(All)37; [1998]229ITR46(All); [1997]94TAXMAN124(All)

..... and make minor adjustments consistent with the information given in the return without touching upon debatable and controversial issues 16 in connection with this new provision the central board of directtaxes ..... in the assessing officer under section 154 for making obvious corrections as no item of debatable nature can be corrected under section 154 of the act similarly the assessing officer cannot .....