Debatable - Judgment Search Results

Novartis AG represented by It's Power of Attorney Ranjna Mehta Dutt Vs ...

Court: Chennai

Reported in: (2007)4MLJ1153

..... under attack is definitely referable only to the pharmacology field namely drugs since parliamentary debates have been relied upon by the learned senior counsels for the petitioners to argue ..... to the statute next from the statement of objects and reasons thereafter from parliamentary debates reports of committees and commissions which preceded the legislation and finally from all legitimate .....

Office of Sen. Mark Dayton Vs. Hanson

Court: US Supreme Court

..... against hanson s allegations would necessarily contravene the speech or debate clause nor that court s leaving open the possibility ..... suits that would otherwise be prohibited under the speech or debate clause consequently a court s determination that jurisdiction attaches ..... any other circuit on the application of the speech or debate clause to suits challenging the personnel decisions of members .....

Freightship Consultants (P) Ltd. Vs. Ito

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Delhi

Reported in: (2008)110ITD377(Delhi)

..... means that for the first time the issue regarding the debatability of deduction under section 80 o and charging of interest ..... instant case the charging of interest under section 234b was debatable irrespective of the deduction claimed by the assessee under section ..... the proposition that charging of interest under section 234b was debatable because the charging of interest under section 234b was not .....

Federal Election Comm’n Vs. WisconsIn Right to Life, Inc.

Court: US Supreme Court

..... whether speech is protected c orporations and other associations like individuals contribute to the discussion debate and the dissemination of information and ideas that the first amendment seeks to foster indeed ..... should be grounds to vote against him given these facts it is beyond all reasonable debate that the ads are constitutionally subject to regulation under mcconnell there we noted that bcra .....

R (on the Application of Countryside Alliance and Others (Appellants) ...

Court: House of Lords

..... address the ethical aspects of the subject informed the subsequent debate the court of appeal included excerpts of the report 8217 ..... for the ban imposed by the act but after intense debate a majority of the country 8217 s democratically elected representatives ..... the country 8217 s democratically elected representatives reached after intense debate i am unpersuaded however that this is 8220 pre eminently .....

Shree Satyanarayan Investment Vs. Ito

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Mumbai

..... a mistake apparent from record can be rectified and not a debatable issue he further submitted that section 112 1 provides that long ..... rectification is not permissible in a case where the issue was debatable he relied upon the following decisions cit v godrej amp boyce ..... section 115ja therefore it cannot be said that the issue is debatable in any way when non application of the correct provision of .....

Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. Faizan Shoes P. Ltd.

Court: Chennai

Reported in: [2008]304ITR156(Mad)

..... proceedings can be initiated in the case of a debatable issue a debatable issue could be considered only under regular assessment and ..... from the audit certificate produced by the assessee is a debatable issue not permissible under section 154 2 whether on the ..... both the sides and finally hold that the issue is debatable hence the assessing officer has exceeded his jurisdiction while acting .....

Belfast City Council (Appellants) Vs. Miss Behavin' Limited (Responden ...

Court: House of Lords

..... ministers or other members different members may well have different reasons not expressed in debates for approving particular statutory provisions they may have different perceptions of the desirability or ..... lack clarity or be misdirected lack of cogent justification in the course of parliamentary debate is not a matter which counts against the legislation on issues of proportionality the .....

Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. Y.K. Shoji Stone Indo (P) Ltd.

Court: Chennai

Reported in: [2008]304ITR390(Mad)

..... the book profit was not erroneous as not being on a debatable issue ii whether the adjustment to any deduction claimed by the ..... 2006 the tribunal allowed the appeal on the ground that the debatable issue cannot be a subject matter for rectification under section 154 ..... rectify the erroneous order or revise it as per law a debatable point cannot be a reason for rectification under section 154 further .....

The Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. A.G. Granites (P) Ltd.

Court: Chennai

Reported in: [2009]311ITR170(Mad)

..... no 1154 2005 the tribunal allowed the appeal by holding that the debatable issues should not be rectified under section 154 of the income ..... on which there may be conceivably two opinions a decision on a debatable point of law is not a mistake apparent from the record ..... head under which the interest income has to be assessed is a debatable issue the above said decision of the punjab and haryana high .....