Debatable - Judgment Search Results

Asstt. C.i.T., Spl. Range Vs. Hughes Services (Fe) Pte. Ltd. as

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Delhi

Reported in: (2005)93ITD77(Delhi)

..... said to have retrospective operation in the sense that although a debate doubt or conflict of judicial opinion is resolved and settled by ..... under section 154 the matter was not free from argument or debate therefore it could not be said that a patent and self ..... was no question of carrying any rectification at any rate highly debatable question was involved on which more than one view was possible .....

J.C.i.T., Spl. Range-14 Vs. National Agriculture

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Delhi

Reported in: (2005)92ITD35(Delhi)

..... whether the amending act applied to the completed assessment is a debatable question we do no understand the rationale of the learned counsel ..... the supreme court were in existence will not make the issue debatable under such enactment there is a marked difference between the ..... to the decision of the supreme court setting at rest such debate or doubt or conflict 18 having considered the issue at .....

Aop of Sanjaybhai R. Patel and 11 ors. Vs. Assessing Officer

Court: Gujarat

Reported in: (2004)187CTR(Guj)583

..... the supreme court decision was that whether such power was there or not was debatable and hence such debatable issue cannot be made the subject matter of proceedings under section 154 of ..... the firm would be business income in the hands of the partners was a highly debatable question on which there might conceivably be two opinions and therefore even if any mistake .....

East West Rescue Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Dy. Cit, Spl. Range 14

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Delhi

Reported in: (2004)89ITD259(Delhi)

..... on which there may be conceivably two opinions a decision on a debatable point of law cannot be a mistake apparent from the record ..... court the tribunal was therefore clearly in error in holding that no debatable issue was involved in this decision also reliance was placed on ..... 1960 air 1960 sc 137 and held that the decision on a debatable point of law or fact etc etc which remained to be investigated .....

Ranga Reddy District Sarpanches' Association and Ors. Vs. Government o ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2004(2)ALD1; 2004(1)ALT659

..... the problems in decentralisation and devolution had stated with a view to generating a debate and eliciting public opinion before examining the problems and suggesting remedial measures the ..... the petitioners and sri s niranjan reddy learned counsel for the intervenors illumined the debate with their brilliance scholarship industry and precision 6 the ranga reddy district sarpanches association .....

Aop of Sanjaybhai R. Patel and 11 ors. Vs. Assessing Officer - Asstt. ...

Court: Gujarat

Reported in: [2004]267ITR129(Guj)

..... the supreme court decision was that whether such power was there or not was debatable and hence such debatable issue cannot be made the subject matter of proceedings under section 154 of ..... the firm would be business income in the hands of the partners was a highly debatable question on which there might conceivably be two opinions and therefore even if any mistake .....

Ramchandra Ram Reddy Vs. the State of Maharashtra

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: 2004BomCR(Cri)657

..... in the minds of the constitution makers when they debated these articles the debate on these articles took place in the constituent assembly ..... the cr p c in our opinion therefore the constituent assembly debated the grant of protection to an accused from being compelled ..... to be a witness against himself the entire debates discloses that what the framers of the constitution had in .....

Three Rivers District Council and Others (Respondents) Vs. Governor an ...

Court: House of Lords

..... the confidential communication or document in question there has been some debate as to whether this right is a procedural right or ..... between lawyers and their clients employees 46 one of the matters debated at the court of appeal hearing that led to the ..... there expressed should be accepted and applied in this jurisdiction is debatable third whatever views your lordships may express and with whatever .....

Smriti Properties Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Settlement Commission (it and Wt) and ...

Court: Kolkata

Reported in: (2005)199CTR(Cal)261,2005(191)ELT128(Cal),[2005]278ITR274(Cal)

..... of the aforesaid section one has to see whether without any debate or argument of extraneous matter the correction is possible the scope ..... is interpreted by the supreme court only when there is a debate or doubt on the interpretation of any provision of a statute ..... to the decision of the supreme court setting at rest such debate or doubt or conflict 35 according to me retrospective operation of .....

Regina Vs. Connor and Another (Appellants) (on Appeal from the Court o ...

Court: House of Lords

..... confidentiality promotes candour and the kind of full and frank debate that is essential to this type of collegial decision making ..... confidentiality promotes candour and the kind of full and frank debate that is essential to this type of collegial decision making ..... reasons of individual jurors became known and could subsequently be debated when at one time that looked like happening parliament enacted .....