Debatable - Judgment Search Results

Supreme Court Advocates-On-Record Association and Anr. Vs. Union of In ...

Court: Supreme Court of India

..... goal of establishing an independent judiciary however justice verma categorically declared 438 the debate on primacy is intended to determine who amongst the constitutional functionaries involved in ..... be admissible and has referred to the historical background including the pre confederation debates for the purpose of interpreting provisions of the canadian constitution although it attaches .....

U.S. Term Limits, Inc. Vs. Thornton

Court: US Supreme Court

..... statement that the states cannot supplement the constitutional qualifications while ratification was being debated the existing rule in america was that the states could prescribe eligibility ..... requirement the following day apparently with more assemblymen in attendance mter a sophisticated debate on the constitutional question with some assemblymen arguing that the district residency requirement .....

Arkansas Ed. Television Comm'n Vs. Forbes

Court: US Supreme Court

..... 1998 petitioner arkansas educational television commission aetc a stateowned public television broadcaster sponsored a debate between the major party candidates for the 1992 election in arkansas third congressional ..... that motivated our decisions in cases like shuttlesworth command that access to political debates explains that a designated public forum is not created when the government allows .....

Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru and ors.Vs. State of Kerala and anr ...

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1973SC1461; (1973)4SCC225; [1973]SuppSCR1

..... enactments which made specific statutory provisions for ensuring the exercise of the right of public debate and public discussion implicit in all such legislation is the right of candidates for ..... the provisions of the constitution had the effect of amendment of the constitution caused considerable debate during the controversy it was strongly urged that the power of constitutional amendment was not .....

United States Vs. Brewster

Court: US Supreme Court

..... that these political matters however appropriate have the protection afforded by the speech or debate clause careful examination of the decided cases reveals that the court has regarded the ..... authorization of congress that intent is not reflected in the language of the speech or debate clause or contemporary understanding of legislative privilege history certainly shows that the framers feared .....

Jindal Stainless Ltd. and Anr. Vs. State of Haryana and Ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

..... even in the constituent assembly as is evident from the following passages from the debates constitution assembly debates vol ix page 1131 dr p s deshmukh if we analyse the new ..... and word restriction used therein includes tax legislation e legislative history and constituent assembly debates relating to article304a and article304b f interpretation scope and ambit of article304a and article304b .....

Hutchinson Vs. Proxmire

Court: US Supreme Court

..... standing the district court granted summary judgment for respondents holding that the speech or debate clause afforded absolute immunity for investigating the funding of petitioner s research for the ..... proxmire s newsletters and press releases fall outside the protection of the speech or debate immunity in my view public criticism by legislators of unnecessary governmental expenditures whatever its .....

Common Cause (A Regd. Society) Vs. Union of India

Court: Supreme Court of India

..... natural death which has already commenced and thereafter the constitution bench stated that the debate with regard to physician assisted suicide remains inconclusive the larger bench has reiterated that ..... that at various instances gandhiji had touched upon the issues of the present day debates on voluntary euthanasia non voluntary euthanasia involuntary euthanasia as well as passive euthanasia active .....

Kalpana Mehta and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

..... correct their speeches for publication in hansard or the public journals and in every debate reports of former speeches contained therein are constantly referred to collectively as well as ..... anglo american jurisprudence unlike other systems has generally frowned upon the use of parliamentary debates and press discussions as throwing light upon the meaning of statutory provisions justie krishna .....

Sita Soren Vs. Union Of India

Court: Supreme Court of India

..... have resulted in substantial modification and even the withdrawal of the proposals under consideration debate and expression of different points of view thus serve an essential and healthy ..... attracted parliamentary privileges the us supreme court by majority held that the speech and debate clause prevented prosecutors from introducing evidence that the member of congress actually performed some .....