Fallacy - Judgment Search Results

D.D. Sharma Vs. Union of India and ors.

Court: Delhi

Reported in: 1992(24)DRJ117

..... promotions as brigadier 8 this argument in my view suffers form inherent fallacy because even in the case of a post where promotion is ..... nothing more i an constrained to say this again is a fallacious approach all that this means is that this 23 years s ..... of permanent commissioned officers never covered full span of two years the fallacy in the argument arises when it is urged that for determining .....

indra Sawhney Etc. Etc Vs. Union of India and Others, Etc. Etc.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1993SC477; [1992]Supp2SCR454; 1992DGLS(soft)768:1992Supp(3)SCC217

..... advanced classes at the inception but in course of time they would it would be fallacious to presume that nature has endowed intelligence only to the members of the forward classes ..... social backwardness caste should be considered only at the end point is a misnomer and fallacious because after identifying and classifying a group of persons belonging to a particular caste by .....

Republic Nat. Bank of Miami Vs. United States

Court: US Supreme Court

..... appellate in rem jurisdiction i am surprised that the government would take such a transparently fallacious position the case is not moot and a ruling by the court of appeals would ..... in his separate opinion i am surprised that the government would make such a transparently fallacious argument in support of its unconscionable position in this case see ante at 96 justice .....

Escorts Limited and ors. Vs. Union of India and Others

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1993SC1325; (1992)108CTR(SC)275; [1993]199ITR43(SC); 1992(2)SCALE867; (1993)1SCC249; [1992]Supp2SCR153

..... from scientific research to assessee s business purposes the explanation does not stand scrutiny the fallacy in the explanation can be demonstrated by taking the very same illustration where the asset ..... what they do according to their reasoning this 40 too should qualify for depreciation the fallacy in their argument would become clearer if the diversion is at the end of the .....

Indian Petrochemicals Ltd. Vs. Collector of Central Excise

Court: Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal CESTAT Delhi

Reported in: (1992)(61)ELT138TriDel

..... to these submissions we are afraid the stand of the revenue suffers from certain basic fallacies besides being wholly technical in kedarnath s case the question for consideration was whether the ..... no adjustment was permissible whatever be the other remedies of the appellant there is a fallacy in the emphasis of this argument the consequence which shri narasimhamurthy suggests should flow from .....

Lalbavta Hotel and Bakery Mazdoor Union and anr. Vs. Bharat Petroleum ...

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: 1993(2)BomCR111; (1993)IILLJ1179Bom

..... out that the central board chose not to make any recommendations and merely on the fallacious ground that the committee s report was not unanimous it left the entire matter to ..... a majority report to the central board recommending abolition of contract labour but on the fallacious ground that there was a dissent in the sub committee the central board chose to .....

Pandian Automobiles Private Ltd. Vs. Tirunelveli Sivakasi Hindu Nadar ...

Court: Chennai

Reported in: (1992)2MLJ185

..... under the provisions of the act as i have already stated above this reasoning is fallacious and incorrect if it may repeat only because a tenant has denied the title of ..... within the actual words of the third category in the definition but there is a fallacy in the argument when a person who continues to be in possession after termination of .....

Philip Jeyasingh Vs. the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies and ...

Court: Chennai

Reported in: (1992)2MLJ309

..... and special officers were appointed by the government to manage the societies the argument is fallacious in paragraph 11 of its judgment the full bench referred expressly to the reliance placed ..... it should be noted that the judgment of the division bench suffers from a fundamental fallacy in that it equates the supersession of the board of management of a society to .....

SamsuddIn Rowther and anr. Vs. Avvammal and ors.

Court: Chennai

Reported in: (1992)2MLJ252

..... is no plea or evidence of ouster among co sharers i do not find any fallacy or infirmity in the discussion of the evidence in paragraph 12 of the judgment of ..... difference between the act and the tamil nadu act 26 of 1948 there is a fallacy in the argument it is not as if i decided the earlier case on the .....

Banka Das, Vs. State of Orissa

Court: Orissa

Reported in: 1993CriLJ442; 1992(II)OLR395

..... has snot referred those questions with great respect 1 would hold she reasoning to be fallacious if a full bench cannot consider the questions since the division bench has not referred ..... a containt as only made to say the lease the submission is both taken and fallacious to be fair the submission is based upon observations made in air 1983 sc 439 .....