Fallacy - Judgment Search Results

Pritam Singh Gill Vs. State of Punjab and ors.

Court: Punjab and Haryana

Reported in: AIR1982P& H228

..... the ingenuity of the learned counsel but the same is patently fallacious 27 reliance for this radical proposition was first placed by mr ..... writs as if they were identical or synonyms is therefore basically fallacious this is evident from the fact that it was not seriously ..... from this it does not follow and indeed it would be fallacious to presume that the writ of certiorari would therefore be invariably .....

S.P. Gupta Vs. President of India and ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1982SC149; 1981Supp(1)SCC87; [1982]2SCR365

..... supra at p 433 by referring to it as the old fallacy that any official in the government service would be inhibited ..... the majority judgment the argument of mr seervai appears to be fallacious because this analogy cannot be applied to a judge who ..... of non appointment consultation is not obligatory there is an apparent fallacy in this submission this argument proceeds on the erroneous assumption that .....

Shah Babulal Khimji Vs. Jayaben D. Kania and anr.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1981SC1786; 1981(3)SCALE1169; (1981)4SCC8; [1982]1SCR187

..... analysis of this decision would reveal that the judges followed a fallacious process of reasoning according to their opinion the appeals under the ..... patent alone and not by the code appears to be legally fallacious we have already pointed out that a large number of decisions ..... of the high court sitting singly on the original side is fallacious and untenable an appeal under clause 15 of the letters .....

Mian Bashir Ahmad and Etc. Vs. State of J. and K. and ors.

Court: Jammu and Kashmir

..... operative society and then again as under at pp 710 711 there is also another fallacy in their argument and it lies in ignoring that no cane grower is prevented from ..... sugarcane to a factory the supreme court repelled the argument as fallacious the court observed at p 709 the whole fallacy in the argument urged on behalf of the petitioners lies in .....

Svadeshi Mills Company Ltd. Vs. Union of India and Others

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: 1982(10)ELT237(Bom)

..... the same commodity by way of excise duty while providing for the excise tariff the fallacy of the departmental reasoning lies in the fact that the raw material from which the ..... far as excise duty payable for windscreen was concerned to our mind this contention is fallacious we will presently point out that if at all there arose a question as to .....

Shaukatali Isimdar Vs. Smt. Nargesh Dhanjishaw Jassoomani

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: (1982)84BOMLR238; 1982MhLJ305

..... deemed abatement of a suit was not sacrosanct and once this position was realised the fallacy underlying the calcutta and orissa views stands revealed the other judge constituting the division bench ..... in taking the narrower view of the provisions contained in sub rule 4 and the fallacies underlying their approach have been succinctly brought out by natesan j in velappan pillai s .....

Gunvantlal Keshavlal Vs. Controller of Estate Duty, Gujarat

Court: Gujarat

Reported in: (1982)27CTR(Guj)95; [1982]134ITR533(Guj)

..... two need not be mixed up lest fusion should result in confusion and a resultantly fallacious conclusion while s 33 1 n aims at the exclusion of residential house valued at ..... under s 34 1 c the line of argument adopted by the accountable person is fallacious and proceeds on a misconception and a misreading of the aforesaid two provisions of the .....

Commissioner of Income-tax, Gujarat-i Vs. Kartikey V. Sarabhai

Court: Gujarat

Reported in: (1981)24CTR(Guj)184; [1981]131ITR42(Guj)

..... be no transfer so as to attract exigibility to tax 10 these arguments are wholly fallacious in the first place it cannot be posited that a partner has interest in the ..... gain to the assessee it is therefore evident that the argument has an in built fallacy were it not so all that an assessee who wants to sell his capital asset .....

V. Veeran and ors. Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Kerala

Reported in: 1981(8)ELT515(Ker)

..... is in conflict with the charging section 3 1 and so it is unconstitutional the fallacy in this argument is in the assumption that a power is given to the government ..... per sq metre which is almost twice the actual figures 24 there is a fundamental fallacy in the petitioners contention for the basic difference between section 3 2 and section 4 .....

Thakur Shipping Co. Ltd., Bombay and anr. Vs. Food Corporation of Indi ...

Court: Chennai

Reported in: AIR1983Mad105

..... care for and discharge the goods carried the argument of mr menon contains a twofold fallacy in the first place his argument overlooks the fact that art 6 of the said ..... with the statutory provisions provided the stipulations are not contrary to public policy the second fallacy is that mr menon assumes that there had been want of diligence or negligence on .....