Fallacy - Judgment Search Results

international Airports Authority Employees Union Vs. International Air ...

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: 2002(5)BomCR43; (2002)IIILLJ277Bom

..... not on the question of determining who the employer is the fallacy of this submission arises from extracting a single observation from ..... the judgment is therefore per incuriam is rejected further the fallacy of this submission is a consequence of extracting a particular ..... not been challenged if viewed in the broader perspective the fallacy of the submission is apparent for instance there could be .....

Paharpur Cooling Towers Ltd. Vs. Dy. Cit

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Kolkata

Reported in: (2003)85ITD745(Kol.)

..... can be applied however the very basis of this proposition is fallacious because as we have observed earlier in this order in view ..... 2 of the act however this proposition also proceeds on a fallacy i e that the definition under section 43 5 and definition ..... be unsustainable in law we see no substance in ingenious but fallacious arguments of the assessee we may also mention that honble jurisdictional .....

Paharpur Cooling Towers Ltd. Vs. Deputy Commissioner of

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Kolkata

..... can be applied however the very basis of this proposition is fallacious because as we have observed earlier in this order in view ..... explanation 2 of the act however this proposition also proceeds on a fallacy i e that the definition under section 43 5 and definition ..... to be unsustainable in law we see no substance in ingenious but fallacious arguments of the assessee 14 we may also mention that hon .....

R.P.C. Industries Ltd. Vs. Asstt. Cit

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Kolkata

Reported in: (2003)85ITD105(Kol.)

..... can be applied however the very basis of this proposition is fallacious because as i have observed earlier in this order in ..... explanation 2 of the act however this proposition proceeds on the fallacy that the definition under section 43 5 and definition under explanation ..... be unsustainable in law i see no substance in ingenious but fallacious arguments of the assessee i may also mention that honble .....

Pandurang Kalu Patil and anr. Vs. State of Maharashtra

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR2002SC733; (2002)2BOMLR347; 2002CriLJ1007; 2002(1)Crimes270(SC); (2002)3GLR2380; JT2002(1)SC229; 2002(1)SCALE290; (2002)2SCC490; [2002]1SCR338; 2002(1)UJ532(SC)

..... act the observation of the privy council that it is fallacious to treat the fact discovered within the section as equivalent ..... maharashtra v damu this court followed pulikuri kottaya with approval the fallacy committed by the division bench as per the impugned judgment ..... sir john beaumont said in pulikuri kottaya that it is fallacious to treat the fact discovered in the section as equivalent .....

Subhash Chandra Dixit and anr. Vs. U.P. Public Service Commission and ...

Court: Allahabad

Reported in: 2003(2)AWC1403; (2003)1UPLBEC528

..... basis and therefore cannot be permitted in any manner 14 another fallacy which lies in the process of scaling is that the same ..... i have pointed out this fact in order to demonstrate the fallacy of the scaling technique which the commission has adopted 17 the ..... few words even where there are several optional papers it is a fallacy to think that the intellectual capacity of all the candidates opting .....

Dominic Dias Margaao Vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Panji

Reported in: (2003)87ITD1Panji

..... short the reasons for rejection can be summarised as under 1 there is a basic fallacy in the valuation report inasmuch as he has valued this land as residential property as ..... cost index we agree with the learned counsel for the assessee that this method is fallacious and wholly unwarranted in face of valuation reports of experts available on record besides there .....

ibrahimkhan Pirkhan Pathan Vs. State of Maharashtra

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: 2003BomCR(Cri)866; 2003CriLJ1802

..... does not contain such recital is put to him as contradiction the procedure involves two fallacies one is it enables the accused to elicit by a process of cross examination what ..... this procedure therefore contravenes the express provision of section 162 of the code the second fallacy is that there is no self contradiction of the primary statement made in the witness .....

Harvinder Singh, Process Server Vs. State of Punjab and ors.

Court: Punjab and Haryana

Reported in: (2003)ILLJ1098P& H; (2003)133PLR150

..... no legal evidence to prove the charge against the petitioner even this contention is wholly fallacious this aspect of the matter has been thoroughly examined by the disciplinary and the appellate ..... presence of a lady in the darkness of the night even this contention is wholly fallacious the witness has given the description of the lady he has even mentioned the colour .....

Mr. G. Krishnakumar Vs. the State of Tamil Nadu Rep. by Secretary Muni ...

Court: Chennai

Reported in: 2003(2)ARBLR297(Madras)

..... driver to cause the accident and therefore no compensation is payable this submission is equally fallacious negligence is failure to take care as required of a man of ordinary prudence if ..... the road and thereby invite the accident this submission is not only insensitive but also fallacious it cannot be said that no child below 12 years should be allowed to ride .....