Reasonable Classification - Judgment Search Results

Amar Singh and ors. Etc. Etc. Vs. the State of Bihar and ors. Etc. Etc ...

Court: Patna

..... application to other persons 19 what article 14 prohibits is class legislation and not reasonable classification for the purpose of legislation the proposition of law on this score is very ..... the constitution prohibits discriminatory confiscatory and arbitrary legislative power no doubt it does not prohibit reasonable classification and for this purpose even one person or group of persons can be a .....

Shri Dattatraya G. Wankar, Sub-divisional Engineer, Road Project Sub D ...

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: 2008(1)ALLMR4; 2007(6)BomCR813

..... made in the year 1970 and could be said to be a reasonable classification based on the pay scale responsibilities and duties has lost its distinction by efflux of ..... class ii and sub divisional engineer has lost its basis of classification it therefore cannot be said that there is a reasonable classification having nexus to the object sought to be achieved by .....

Dr. Krishna Kumar Lal Vs. the State of Jharkhand and ors.

Court: Jharkhand

Reported in: [2008(3)JCR221(Jhr)]

..... on the ground that it has no application to other persons vii while reasonable classification is permissible such classification must be based upon some real and substantial distinction bearing a ..... preclude the legislature from making a reasonable classification for the purpose of legislation the said classification has to pass two tests namely i the classification must be founded on an intelligible .....

Union of India (Uoi) Vs. Chaffeurs (Class-iii) Association

Court: Delhi

Reported in: 2008(2)SLJ272(Delhi)

..... it is settled that though article 14 forbids class legislation it does not forbid reasonable classification for the purpose of legislation when any impugned rule or statutory provision is ..... prescribing two different scales for the two classes of employees without there being any reasonable classification for the same if the aggrieved employees fail to demonstrate discrimination the principle of .....

Sony India Ltd. Vs. Commercial Tax Officer and ors.

Court: Chennai

Reported in: (2008)18VST49(Mad)

..... power includes a power to levy tax on the goods based on intelligible differentia and reasonable classification he would also submit that so far as the contentions as to the infringement of ..... for imported goods is on intelligible differentia and on the basis of reasonable classification and therefore we do not find any reason to hold that either the impugned act is violative of article .....

R. Veeraragavan Vs. the State of Tamil Nadu Rep. by the Secretary to G ...

Court: Chennai

Reported in: 2007(4)KLT19

..... constitution of india though the aforesaid article prohibits any class legislation reasonable classification has been permitted but such a classification introduced by way of legislation shall never be arbitrary the ..... imposes only a reasonable restriction therefore they pray for dismissal of the writ petitions 5 learned senior counsel for the petitioners would submit that the classification as such .....

Sony India Ltd. Vs. the Commercial Tax Officer,

Court: Chennai

Reported in: (2007)5MLJ881

..... power includes a power to levy tax on the goods based on intelligible differentia and reasonable classification he would also submit that so far as the contentions as to the infringement of ..... for imported goods is on intelligible differentia and on the basis of reasonable classification and therefore we do not find any reason to hold that either the impugned act is violative of article .....

Laishram Ibomcha Singh Vs. State of Manipur and anr.

Court: Guwahati

..... rules discharging the same duties and performing the same work inasmuch as there is no reasonable classification of the senior accountant for the purpose of revision of pay scale by the rop ..... grade which may be either academic qualifications or experience based on length of service reasonably sustain the classification of the officers into two grades with different scales of pay the principle of .....

A.P. Sarpanches Association and ors. Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: AIR2007AP273; 2007(4)ALD783; 2007(5)ALT707

..... has resolved the contradictory demands of legislative specialization and constitutional generality by a doctrine of reasonable classification this doctrine recognizes that the legislature may classify for the purpose of legislation but requires .....

Govt. of A.P. and anr. Vs. G. Jaya Prasad Rao and ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR2007SC1503; 2007(3)ALD42(SC); (2007)4MLJ1039(SC); 2007(4)SCALE630

..... class the high court held that the amendment did not satisfy the test of reasonable classification and it further observed that fortuitous circumstance cannot be made a basis for ..... treated dissimilarly i e equals are treated unequally therefore this classification according to the high court is not reasonable classification and it is not founded on intelligible differentia which distinguishes .....