Logically - Judgment Search Results

Mrs. Maneka Gandhi Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and anr.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1978SC597; (1978)1SCC248; [1978]2SCR621

..... implicit in it that it is unequal both according to political logic and constitutional law and is therefore violative of article 14 ..... applicable to quasi judicial inquiry and not to administrative inquiry it must logically apply to both on what principle can distinction be made ..... but it must be functional not fatuous 121 this line of logic alone will make the two clauses of article 21 concordant .....

M.K. Janardan and ors. Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Gujarat

Reported in: (1978)19GLR879

..... scheduled castes and scheduled tribes has been taken the necessary and logical corollary of that decision is to provide a roster so ..... and not with posts is meant to give effect to the logic underlying the reservation rule 7 miss shah relied upon the ..... overlooked the basic principle underlying the reservation of posts and the logical corollary which follows from that principle of reservation of posts .....

Fulman Vs. United States

Court: US Supreme Court

..... valuation with respect to distributees this is not to deny the logical force of petitioners argument that since the purpose of the personal ..... mr justice powell in dissent i do not see the ineluctable logical need to equate the amount of income received by the shareholder ..... statute to accord with its manifest purpose a regulation that defies logic as well as the statutory purpose merits little weight i .....

Rakas Vs. Illinois

Court: US Supreme Court

..... we think the decision of this issue will rest on sounder logical footing c here petitioners who were passengers occupying a car ..... purposes of the analysis set out in jones iii the logic of fourth amendment jurisprudence compels the result reached by the ..... applicability of the exclusionary rule somewhere anywhere the court ignores precedent logic and common sense to exclude the rule s operation from .....

Monell Vs. Department of Soc. Svcs.

Court: US Supreme Court

..... announced in dennison and day are not so well defined in logic but are clear as a matter of history it must be ..... and as bingham s remarks confirm 1 of the bill would logically be the vehicle by which congress provided redress for takings since ..... status of corporations under the fourteenth amendment had concluded with impeccable logic that a corporation was neither a citizen nor a person insurance .....

Duke Power Co. Vs. Carolina Env. Study Group

Court: US Supreme Court

..... has two aspects to it first the taxpayer must establish a logical link between that status and the type of legislative enactment ..... was for the express purpose of determining whether there is a logical nexus between the taxpayer status asserted and the claim sought ..... to which appellees object would simply not come into play that logical connection however does not amount to an allegation that the .....

City of Lafayette Vs. Louisiana Pandl; Co.

Court: US Supreme Court

..... 5 following the path outlined above should lead us to a logical destination petitioners should be treated for purposes of applying the federal ..... 428 u s at 428 u s 595 there is no logical inconsistency between requiring such a firm to meet regulatory criteria ..... the plurality today blurs if indeed it does not erase this logical distinction between private and governmental action in goldfarb and in .....

Tennessee Valley Auth. Vs. Hill

Court: US Supreme Court

..... remain to be authorized or funded second the dissent s position logically means that an agency would be obligated to comply with ..... circumspection id at 760 observing that respondents argument carried to its logical extreme would require a court to enjoin the impoundment of ..... enforcement of the act requires that it be taken to its logical extreme ibid it remanded with instructions to issue a permanent .....

United States Vs. Board of Comm'rs of Sheffield

Court: US Supreme Court

..... play in securing the promise of 4 a it is wholly logical to interpret state with respect to which 4 a is in ..... areas and the textual interrelationship between 4 a and 5 it logically follows that where a political subdivision has been separately designated for coverage ..... the page 435 u s 145 legislative history provides a perfectly logical explanation of why congress deliberately limited the reach of 5 as well .....

Addl. Commissioner of Income-tax, Mysore Vs. C.V. Bagalkoti and Sons

Court: Karnataka

Reported in: ILR1979KAR127; [1978]115ITR131(KAR); [1978]115ITR131(Karn); 1979(1)KarLJ34

..... since the penalty imposable under the income tax law is merely and additional tax the logical conclusion should be that whenever penalty is levied it should be done in accordance with ..... entirely deny that it can be coated for a proposition that may seem to follow logically from it such a mode of reasoning assumes that the law is necessarily a .....