Logically - Judgment Search Results

A.K. Gopalan Vs. the State of Madras

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1950SC27; 1950CriLJ1383; (1950)IIMLJ42(SC); [1950]1SCR88

..... learned judges construed article 19 as covering cases of deprivation of personal liberty and held logically enough that inasmuch as the impugned act by authorising preventive detention infringed the right to ..... the others the learned judges of the allahabad high court realised this and were perfectly logical in holding that the constitutional validity of a law providing for deprivation of personal .....

Commissioner of Income-tax Vs. Proprietors of The Hindu

Court: Chennai

Reported in: AIR1950Mad671; [1950]18ITR237(Mad)

..... to choose between two competing constructions the probability of an equitable logical and rational purpose underlying the enacted words may turn the ..... we were reminded by learned counsel for the assessee that logic and income tax were strangers and the construction of section ..... i find that section 25 4 properly construed admits of a logical and just interpretation in the manner above indicated 24 i .....

State of Bombay Vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and anr.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1951SC69; (1951)53BOMLR402; [1951]2SCR51

..... legislature by entry 1 of list ii the special powers being the logical consequence or concomitant of the power of the two legislatures to ..... is not the same original statute it is a new act and logically speaking it amounts to enacting a new law 46 i have ..... jurisdiction and power of the court established by it 55 the argument logically analysed comes to this that such a statute will contain the .....

Avarenkal Kunhayadru and ors. Vs. Olankara Ali Kutty

Court: Chennai

Reported in: AIR1950Mad559

..... 2 the learned counsel for the petitioner urged that it was against logic and common sense to hold that a usufructuary mortgagee in possession ..... the land and becomes an intermediary i see nothing contrary to logic and commonsense in this an alien living here may not be ..... for some years etc and besides law need not always conform to logic and commonsense petition dismissed no order as to costs in the .....

Oppenheim Vs. Tobacco Securities Trust Company Limited and Others

Court: House of Lords

..... 426 that the law of charity has been built up not logically but empirically it is this empirical development which has so often ..... his employees and other circumstances 1 am unable to find any logical principle in these submissions if there is no public element to ..... in this branch of the law which only compelling authority or logical necessity would induce me to accept it may be conceded that .....

Darr Vs. Burford

Court: US Supreme Court

..... requirement of eliciting a denial of a petition for certiorari in habeas corpus cases to its logical conclusion by giving such denial conclusive effect on the merits schechtman v foster 172 f ..... 2d 339 342 343 that is the logical conclusion of such a requirement but it is the logic of unreality for it flies in the face of the .....

Sakarchand Satidas and ors. Vs. Narayan Savla Vani and ors.

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: AIR1951Bom10; (1950)52BOMLR888; ILR1951Bom217

..... date of the alienation mr joshi says that this is not a logical approach to the question possibly he is right but we must ..... in taking a contrary view even if the contrary view be more logical we would be upsetting a series of decisions spread over a ..... which is always more important and more to be respected than any logical doctrine resulting from a particular view as to the strict law therefore .....

Fpc Vs. East Ohio Gas Co.

Court: US Supreme Court

..... community supply systems which they service indeed as respondents admitted upon oral argument here the logical consequence of such a principle would be that even a pipeline stretching from texas ..... in interstate commerce to which the provisions of the act apply for instance it would logically enough give to the federal power commission under the above transportation clause exclusive jurisdiction over .....

Fram Nusservanji Balsara Vs. State of Bombay and anr.

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: AIR1951Bom210; (1950)52BOMLR799; ILR1951Bom17

..... would facilitate subterfuges and frauds and fetter the enforcement of the law a contrary conclusion logically pressed would save the nominal power while preventing its effective exercise the statute establishes its ..... persons found on cargo boats etc as such prima facie there appears to be no logic or reason behind the pro vision there is little in common between cargo boats on .....

Govind Prasad Srivastava and anr. Vs. the State of Bhopal

Court: Madhya Pradesh

Reported in: 1952CriLJ660

..... particular provision may be open to more than one construction but it is only the logical one and the one that naturally flows from it which has to be accepted for ..... was reasonably applied in framing the detention order and whether para five can be the logical consequence of tie activities of the detenues as stated in the preceding para graphs in .....