Arbitrary - Year 2006 - Judgments

Feb 21 2006 (HC)

Coal India Ltd Vs. Indian Explosive Ltd. and ors.

Court: Kolkata

Decided on: Feb-21-2006

Reported in: 2006(3)CHN433

..... element involved in the matter particularly where the state is acting in an unreasonable arbitrary and capricious manner by unilaterally introducing a supplementary clause 10 sri banerjee arguing on ..... was introduced by the coal india would that by itself raise the question of arbitrariness unreasonableness or unfairness is a question which cannot be answered particularly because everything would .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

Jan 23 2006 (TRI)

Tom Joseph Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Ernakulam

Decided on: Jan-23-2006

Reported in: (2006)(3)SLJ274CAT

..... the request of the applicant for change of accommodation was arbitrary illegal and contrary to rule 13 of the allotment rules ..... discernible principle which is reasonable may itself attract the vice of arbitrariness every state action must be informed by reason and it ..... in such matters it has been emphasized time and again that arbitrariness is anathema to state action in every sphere and wherever .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

Feb 06 2006 (TRI)

Vishwas Jayavantrao Bhosale Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Mumbai

Decided on: Feb-06-2006

Reported in: (2006)(3)SLJ219CAT

..... safeguards existed at different stages absence of reasons for selection cannot be termed as arbitrary and further in the absence of statutory provisions administrative authorities are under no obligation ..... liable to be abused with less difficulty but that does not justify presumption regarding arbitrary exercise of power the machinery designed for preparation of select list under the regulations .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

Sep 20 2006 (HC)

Progressive Constructions Co. and ors. Vs. South Central Railway and o ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Decided on: Sep-20-2006

Reported in: 2006(6)ALD570

..... demanding payment of seigniorage fee prescribed as per rule 10 of apmmc rules 1966 as arbitrary illegal and unconstitutional and consequently direct the respondents to assess and collect seigniorage fee ..... instead of the seigniorage fee prescribed as per rule 10 of apmmc rules 1966 as arbitrary illegal and unconstitutional and consequently direct the respondents to assess and collect seigniorage fee .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

May 26 2006 (HC)

Trishul Industries Vs. the State of Haryana and anr.

Court: Punjab and Haryana

Decided on: May-26-2006

Reported in: (2006)144PLR222

..... action of the respondents is vitiated by the vice of arbitrariness the land of the petitioner falls within the controlled area ..... levy conversion charges the amounts claimed are unconscionable and therefore arbitrary 19 a careful perusal of the provisions of the 1963 ..... pipes limited 2003 3scr691 while accepting a challenge to an arbitrary award under the provisions of the arbitration and conciliation act .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

Aug 23 2006 (TRI)

Pratap Singh (Pensioner) Vs. Director, Subsidiary

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

Decided on: Aug-23-2006

Reported in: (2007)(2)SLJ185CAT

..... observed as under from a positivistic point of view equality is antithetic to arbitrariness in fact equality and arbitrariness are sworn enemies one belongs to the rule of law in a republic ..... quality equalitarian in its soul and allergic to discriminatory diktats equality is the antithesis of arbitrariness and ex cathedra ipse dixit is the ally of demagogic authoritarianism only knight errants of .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

Jan 13 2006 (TRI)

Arvee International Vs. Additional Commissioner of

Court: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ITAT Mumbai

Decided on: Jan-13-2006

Reported in: (2006)101ITD495(Mum.)

..... principles of natural justice or without application of mind 15 in our humble view arbitrariness in decision making would always need correction regardless of whether it causes prejudice to ..... can also be corrected by invoking revisional jurisdiction of the commissioner under section 263 arbitrariness in decision making causing prejudice to either party cannot therefore be allowed to stand .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

Feb 23 2006 (HC)

Sarvajanik Shri Ganeshotsav Mandal and Sanjay Sawant, President of Sar ...

Court: Mumbai

Decided on: Feb-23-2006

Reported in: 2006(4)ALLMR707; 2006(2)BomCR757; 2006(4)MhLj207

..... the respondent state in executing lease deed with the respondent no 5 was unreasonable illegal arbitrary or actuated by extraneous consideration 31 the circumstances many a time are louder and eloquent ..... reserved for playground and also the agreement with the respondent no 3 is absolutely illegal arbitrary ultra vires unconstitutional and does not meet the test of reasonableness and public interest .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

May 11 2006 (HC)

Ram Chander Vs. State of Haryana and ors.

Court: Punjab and Haryana

Decided on: May-11-2006

Reported in: (2006)144PLR392

..... in public interest it is well settled that if decision making process is vitiated by arbitrariness unfairness illegality or irrationality this court could strike down the same as well as ..... 1977 3scr249 but the court changed its opinion in subsequent decisions and held that even arbitrary and unreasonable decisions of the government authorities while acting in pursuance of a contract would .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

May 11 2006 (SC)

Satya NaraIn Shukla Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Decided on: May-11-2006

Reported in: AIR2006SC2511; [2006(110)FLR233]; 2006(5)SCALE627; (2006)9SCC69; 2006(3)SLJ301(SC)

..... was declined by the tribunal the tribunal also dismissed the allegations of mala fides and arbitrariness in not considering the appellant for empanelment and dismissed his petition 4 the high court ..... for selection as adopted by the government is unconstitutional or otherwise illegal or vitiated by arbitrariness and mala fides 19 after careful application of mind to all the contentions urged before .....

Tag this Judgment! Ask ChatGPT

Arbitrary - Judgment Search Results