Arbitrary - Judgment Search Results

Motor Veh. Mfrs. Ass'n Vs. State Farm Ins.

Court: US Supreme Court

..... action held nhtsa s rescission of the passive restraint requirement in modified standard 208 was arbitrary and capricious the agency failed to present an adequate basis and explanation for rescinding ..... a rule in the first place a standard petitioner believes considerably narrower than the traditional arbitrary and capricious test we reject this view the act expressly equates orders revoking and .....

Barclay Vs. Florida

Court: US Supreme Court

..... to several statutory aggravating factors footnote 7 the judge s discussion is neither irrational nor arbitrary in particular the comparison between this case and the nazi concentration camps does not offend ..... some undefined point at which a sentence crosses over into the nether world of wholly arbitrary decisionmaking i see no way to reconcile this standard with the requirements of the constitution .....

Zant Vs. Stephens

Court: US Supreme Court

..... the record of every death penalty proceeding to determine whether the sentence was arbitrary or disproportionate the narrowing function of statutory aggravating circumstances was properly achieved in ..... the record of every death penalty proceeding to determine whether the sentence was arbitrary or disproportionate these elements the opinion concluded adequately protected against the wanton and .....

D.K.V. Prasada Rao and ors. Vs. Government of Andhra Pradesh

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: AIR1984AP75

..... what of any material placed before us to consider their correctness though the contention of arbitrariness in procedure violating article 14 of the constitution was raised in the pleadings it is ..... different classes if it is shown that fixation of rates of admission is unreasonable unrealistic arbitrary or relevant factors were not considered or violates the principles of natural justice in such .....

West Bengal Board of Examination for Admission to Engineering, Medical ...

Court: Kolkata

Reported in: AIR1984Cal52,87CWN1050

..... entire result of the successful candidates was wholly illegal and had been stained with arbitrariness unreasonableness and discrimination 15 upon the above findings the learned judge made the rule ..... sheets were produced it would be evident that there had been gross injustice unfairness arbitrary discrimination undue favouritism and sacrificing of laws and procedures of a fair examination system .....

Kashmir Motor Drivers Association and anr. Vs. Union of India (Uoi) an ...

Court: Jammu and Kashmir

Reported in: AIR1983J& K100

..... it has to satisfy the requirements ofreason and relevance it should neither bediscriminatory nor arbitrary or unreasonable but should be justifiable on someprinciple a provision of law that ..... for theauthority entrusted with the task of subordinate legislation any such legislationwhich is either arbitrary or unreasonable based upon irrelevant or extraneous considerations is liable to be struck down .....

Baltimore G. and E. Co. Vs. Nrdc

Court: US Supreme Court

..... it found that the assumption represents a self evident error in judgment and is thus arbitrary and capricious as the evidence in the record reveals and the commission itself acknowledged the ..... insufficient to affect any individual licensing decision in assessing whether the commission s decision is arbitrary and capricious it is crucial to place the zero release assumption in context three factors .....

Jitendra Nath Banerjee and ors. Vs. West Bengal Board of Examination f ...

Court: Kolkata

Reported in: AIR1983Cal275

..... are produced before this hon ble court that there has been gross injustice unfairness arbitrary discrimination undue favouritism sacrificing all norms and procedures of fair examination system to ..... group for engineering stream should have been separately examined for avoiding all sorts of arbitrary selectionotherwise difficulties would crop up andfor various other reasons as suggestedin the present .....

S.C. Dogra and Etc. Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and ors.

Court: Himachal Pradesh

Reported in: AIR1984HP29

..... be in conformity with standard or norm which is not arbitrary irrational or irrelevant the power or discretion of the government ..... the director cannot be said to be unfair or unreasonable or arbitrary 25 the learned counsel for the petitioners relied upon dwarka ..... fixing prices of coal and imposing conditions on traders and these arbitrary powers could not be delegated by the concerned officers at .....

United States Vs. Villamonte-marquez

Court: US Supreme Court

..... of an automobile is a substantial invasion of privacy to protect that privacy from official arbitrariness the court has always regarded probable cause as the minimum requirement for a lawful ..... instance the occupant would quite reasonably suppose that he was entitled to remain undisturbed by arbitrary government authority the court however sweeps this expectation aside without a thought footnote 2 9 .....