Arbitrary - Judgment Search Results

H.A. Vaishnav and ors. Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Ahmedabad

..... the pay commission the same cannot be considered to be arbitrary or discriminatory according to the respondents the 5th pay commission ..... the commission as well as accepted by the government were arbitrary and without any rational referring to the reason of prospectivity ..... the 5th pay commission with regard to the gratuity were arbitrary and unreasonable it therefore cannot be held that the orders .....

R. Sivakumar, Ias Vs. Union Public Service Commission

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Madras

..... the above regulation to favour some officers which action also suffers from the vice of arbitrariness discrimination and amounts to colourable exercise of power additional legal discussion by the hon ble ..... tribunal has got every right to set right the injustice done when there has been arbitrariness extraneous consideration by the selection committee which has been established beyond doubt in these .....

State of A.P. and Another Vs. Crag MartIn Distillery Pvt. Ltd., Goa an ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2000(5)ALD213; 2000(5)ALT34

..... functioning within the state is not justified and therefore the impugned government order is arbitrary and violative of principles of equality he contends that when the state permits trade ..... cabinet sub committee therefore we are unable to identify any element of irrationality perversity arbitrariness consideration of irrelevant factors or eschewing of relevant factors in the formulation of the .....

M/S. Thiru Muruga Finance Rep. by Its Partner Sri V. Thirunavukkarasu, ...

Court: Chennai

Reported in: 2000(2)CTC609

..... a judicial formula for determining whether the legislative or executive action in question is arbitrary and therefore constituting denial of equality if the classification is not reasonable and does ..... two conditions referred to above the impugned legislative or executive action would plainly be arbitrary and the guarantee of equality under article 14 would be breached wherever therefore there .....

Optel Telecommunications Ltd. Vs. Union of India and Others

Court: Madhya Pradesh

Reported in: AIR2001MP161; 2001(2)MPHT393; 2001(2)MPLJ277

..... process instead of a fewmonopolising the supplies worth crores of rupees allegations of victimisation arbitrariness and lack of bona fides have been denied it was also contendedthat the ..... review wouldapply to the exercise of contractual powers by government bodiesin order to prevent arbitrariness or favouritism however it mustbe clearly stated that there arc inherent limitations in exercise .....

Pulakeshi Power Company Private Limited, Bangalore Vs. State of Karnat ...

Court: Karnataka

Reported in: AIR2000Kant256; ILR2000KAR1232; 2000(2)KarLJ314

..... project the basis on which fuel had been allocated to several power companies is wholly arbitrary whimsical and without reason such allocation has brought about serious discrimination in the matter of ..... of this order the files and records of the government unequivocally establish the fact of arbitrary unreasonable unfair and inequitable allotment of naphtha in favour of the petitioner and others and .....

Venkatarajaiah and Another Vs. Osmania University, Hyd. and Another

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2000(4)ALD558; 2000(4)ALT513

..... judicial review a decision denying or negativing legitimate expectation cannot be justified if it is arbitrary unreasonable and not taken in public interest a change of policy denying legitimate expectation ..... of rs 150 towards establishment charges from the students during the summer vacation is arbitrary in any event this matter requires reconsideration by the vice chancellor and chief warden .....

Vbc Ferro Alloys Limited Vs. Andhra Pradesh State Electricity Board an ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2000(5)ALD626; 2000(5)ALT340

..... continuing the said re categorisation on the ground that the re categorisation is arbitrary unreasonable and not based on any acceptable valid and reasonable classification according to ..... circumstances the tariff fixation can be declared unconstitutional only if it is patently arbitrary irrational discriminatory or demonstrably irrelevant the court in exercise of itsjudicial review jurisdiction .....

Association of Victims of Uphaar Tragedy Vs. Union of India and ors.

Court: Delhi

Reported in: 2000IVAD(Delhi)342; 86(2000)DLT246

..... the officer discharges his duty honestly and bona fide but when it arises due to arbitrary or capricious behavior then it loses its individual character and assumes social significance harassment of ..... the officer discharges his duty honestly and bona fide but when it arises due to arbitrary or capricious behavior then it loses its individual character and assumes social significance harassment of .....

Skanska International Civil Engineering Ab and anr. Vs. West Bengal St ...

Court: Kolkata

Reported in: (2001)2CALLT133(HC)

..... such a process which is absolutely unknown alien to the published norms this is an arbitrary decision one should reasonably expect the decision taking authority would decide by himself or ..... the decision making process and interfere if it is found vitiated by malafies unreasonableness and arbitrariness the state its corporations instrumentalities and agencies have the public duty to be fair to .....