Skip to content
How to use Judgment tools
  1. Click Tools to open PDF, Print, Tag, Note, Favourite, and CiteSignal.
  2. Use Brief & Ask in the toolbar for the AI Brief and case chat.
  3. Jump to sections with the pills below the help bar.

Samuel Soren and anr. Vs. State of Jharkhand and ors.

Samuel Soren and anr. vs State of Jharkhand and ors.

Disposition Petition disposed of Court Jharkhand Decided Jun 18, 2001
~3 min read
https://sooperkanoon.com/case/517086

For advocates & juniors · 7-day free trial

Brief this judgment before chambers

Stop skimming 50 pages - get an 18-section AI Brief on this case, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial, no card required.

  • 18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
  • Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
  • Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
  • Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases

No card required · credentials emailed · Log in if you already have an account

Citation
Court
Jharkhand High Court
Judge
Decided On
Case Number
CWJC No. 1495 of 2001
Subject
Service
Disposition
Petition disposed of

Case Summary

AI-generated summary - not the official court judgment text.

Service law - Family pension--Withholding of--A unmarried daughter, being Government Servant died in harness--Her parent being dependent on her awarded provisional family pension--Same was withheld on the ground that father was not entitled for family pension--However, Finance Department of Bihar Government decided ...

Key legal issue
Service
Outcome / disposition
Petition disposed of
Acts & sections
Service Law

Parties & Advocates

Appellant / Petitioner

Samuel Soren and anr.

Advocate Rajiv Ranjan Mishra, Adv.

Respondent

State of Jharkhand and ors.

Advocate R.N. Sahay, SC-I and; Rabindra Prasad, JC to SC-I

Legal References

Acts
Service Law
Reported In
2002(50)BLJR2114

Excerpt

service law - family pension--withholding of--a unmarried daughter, being government servant died in harness--her parent being dependent on her awarded provisional family pension--same was withheld on the ground that father was not entitled for family pension--however, finance department of bihar government decided to pay family pension to the dependant, including the surviving parents whose annual income not exceeding rs. 25507--direction issued to decided the family pension within six months. - motor vehicles act, 1988[c.a.no.59/1988] section 166; [a.k. patnaik, cj, a.k. gohil & s. samvatsar, jj] application for compensation for personal injury death of injured claimant subsequently for some other reasons held, claim for personal injury will abate on the death of claimant. claim will not survive to his legal representative except as regards claim for pecuniary loss to estate of claimant......of education (respondent no. 2) in his counter affidavit, has accepted that the government of bihar, from its finance department, issued letter no. 11656 dated 22nd december, 1999, wherein, under paragraph no. 5 (iv)(5) it was decided to pay family pension to the dependent, including the surviving parents, whose annual income does not exceed rs. 2550/-. the said letter has been given effect from 1.1.1996 i.e. from a date, prior to the death of sushanna soren.5. having regard to the facts and circumstances, as the letter no. 847 dated 29th december, 1998 was issued prior to resolution dated 22nd december, 1999, in view ofthe subsequent decision dated 22nd december, 1999, the matter requires reconsideration.6. the respondent district superinten-dent of education, dumkam and the accountant general, bihar and jharkhand, patna are accordingly, directed to recalculate the family pension of the petitioners taking into consideration the revised scale of pay, to which their daughter late sushanna soren was entitled with effect from 1.1.1996 and pay the family pension within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order.7. the authorities will also calculate the gratuity and leave encashment amount, if any, in the revised scale, as allowed with effect from 1.1.1996 and pay the difference, if any, within the aforesaid period of six weeks.8. the district superintendent of education. dumka (respondent no. 2) will pay the cost of rs. 500/- to the petitioners, in terms of the court's order dated 30th may, 2001, within a week from the date of receipt/ production of a copy of this order.9. the writ petition stands disposed of with the aforesaid observations and directions.10. petition disposed of.

Full Judgment

ORDER

S.J. Mukhopadhaya, J.

1. This application has been preferred by the parents of late Sushanna Soren, for payment of family pension.

2. According to the petitioners, their daughter late Sushanna Soren was in ser-vices of Government and died in harness on 20th February, 1996, while working as Teacher in Government Primary School, Lat-bedha, Anchan-Shikaripara. The daughter being unmarried and the parents being de-pendent on her, were provided with gratuity and provisional family pension at the rate of Rs. 634/- per month, but since December, 1998 even the provisional family pension was withheld, in pursuance of the letter dated 24th December, 1998.

3. The letter numbering 847 dated 24th December, 1998 seems to have been issued by the Senior Accounts Officer, A.G. Bihar, Patna, to the District Superintendent of Education, Dumka giving a reference to the Finance Department's resolution dated 3rd October, 1964, stating that the father, in terms of such resolution is not entitled for family pension on the death of daughter and the provisional family pension, at the rate of Rs. 634/- per month, paid since 21st February, 1996, is not in accordance with law and, as such, It is recoverable from the gratuity, wherein, only Rs. 1000/- is left to be paid.

4. The District Superintendent of Education (respondent No. 2) in his counter affidavit, has accepted that the Government of Bihar, from its Finance Department, issued letter No. 11656 dated 22nd December, 1999, wherein, under paragraph No. 5 (iv)(5) it was decided to pay family pension to the dependent, including the surviving parents, whose annual income does not exceed Rs. 2550/-. The said letter has been given effect from 1.1.1996 i.e. from a date, prior to the death of Sushanna Soren.

5. Having regard to the facts and circumstances, as the letter No. 847 dated 29th December, 1998 was issued prior to resolution dated 22nd December, 1999, in view ofthe subsequent decision dated 22nd December, 1999, the matter requires reconsideration.

6. The respondent District Superinten-dent of Education, Dumkam and the Accountant General, Bihar and Jharkhand, Patna are accordingly, directed to recalculate the family pension of the petitioners taking into consideration the revised scale of pay, to which their daughter late Sushanna Soren was entitled with effect from 1.1.1996 and pay the family pension within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order.

7. The authorities will also calculate the gratuity and leave encashment amount, if any, in the revised scale, as allowed with effect from 1.1.1996 and pay the difference, if any, within the aforesaid period of six weeks.

8. The District Superintendent of Education. Dumka (respondent No. 2) will pay the cost of Rs. 500/- to the petitioners, in terms of the Court's order dated 30th May, 2001, within a week from the date of receipt/ production of a copy of this order.

9. The writ petition stands disposed of with the aforesaid observations and directions.

10. Petition disposed of.

Continue Your Research


AI Briefs · Semantic Search · Save & annotate judgments

Start your 7-day free trial