Union of India and Another Vs. M.S. Sachdeva

arbitration - special appeal - chapter 9 rule 10 of allahabad high court rules, 1952, section 11 (6) of arbitration and reconciliation act, 1996 and article 136 of constitution of india - order appointing arbitrator passed under section 11 (6) is administrative order - special appeal against such order under article 136 is not maintainable-appeal dismissed. - - supreme court held that 'it is now well-settled that petition under article 136 can be for challenging a judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any court or tribunal in the territory of india. supreme court, the special appeals fail on merits and are accordingly dismissed.shyamal kumar sen, c.j. 1. weare of the view that the order appointing arbitrator under section 11(6) of the arbitration and conciliation act, 1996, is not a judicial function. it is an administrative one. being designated by the hon. the chief justice, the hon'blc judge passed an order appointing an arbitrator. we are of the view that no special appeal lies against the appointment of an arbitrator. this position has now been settled by the hon. supreme court in ador samia pvt. ltd. v. peekay holdings ltd. and others, 1999 14) ccc 67 (sc), wherein the hon. supreme court held that 'it is now well-settled that petition under article 136 can be for challenging a judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any court or tribunal in the territory of india.as the learned chief justice or his designate under section 11(6) of the act acts in administrative capacity as held by this court in the aforesaid decision, it is obvious that this order is not passed by any court exercising any judicial function nor it is a tribunal having trappings of a 'judicial authority. orders passed by the learned chief justice under section 11(6) of the arbitration and conciliation act being of an administrative nature cannot be subjected to any challenge directly under article 136 of the constitution of india.2. in view of dictum of hon. supreme court, the special appeals fail on merits and are accordingly dismissed.3. interim orders, if any standsvacated.