Shailendra Kumar Vs. Chief General Manager, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. and ors. - Court Judgment

Excerpt:

service - eligibility for appointment - article 226 of constitution of india - petitioner prayed for directing respondent to accept his candidature as an eligible candidate - petitioner was selected but not given appointment letter because he submitted his mark sheet only - unable to submit his degree before due date - after examination mark sheet issued earlier but degree issued subsequently - held, it will suffice to submit mark sheet on or prior to due date. - - it is well known that after the examination, often mark-sheet is issued at an early date but the degree is often issued several months subsequently.orderm.katju and prakash krishna, jj. 1. heard learned counsel for the petitioner.2. the petitioner has prayed for a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to accept his candidature as an eligible candidate and give him appointment on the post of junior telecom officer.3. the petitioner has passed his b.e. examination. he applied against the advertisement for selection to the post of junior telecom officer. a copy of the said advertisement is enclosed as annexure-1 to the writ petition. it was mentioned therein that only those candidates who have been declared passed and who have been issued provisional degree/mark-sheet on or prior to 31.7.2002 could apply. the petitioner submitted his mark-sheet of b.e. examination on 29.7.2002 with the relevant mark-sheet but the degree was submitted after 31.7.2002 because the degree was not available on or before 31.7.2002. however, although the petitioner was selected he was not given letter of appointment because he did not submit his degree prior to 31.7.2002, as it was not issued prior to 31.7.2002.4. in our opinion, the respondents have taken an over-technical view of the matter. it is well known that after the examination, often.....