Rational Basis - Judgment Search Results

Vbc Ferro Alloys Limited Vs. Andhra Pradesh State Electricity Board an ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2000(5)ALD626; 2000(5)ALT340

..... petitioner s company automatically comes under the ht category iii 15 there is a rational basis for making such categorisation and classifying the petitioner company into ht category iii several ..... manufactured by the manufacturers is discriminatory in its nature there is no reason or rational basis in discriminating of charging higher tariffs from the ferro silicon manufacturers from other industrial .....

United States Vs. Morrison

Court: US Supreme Court

..... effects test or its application through the aggregation of individual conduct but by supplanting rational basis scrutiny with a new criterion of review kennedy and souter the judicial conference of ..... further examination by this court but where we find that the legislators have a rational basis for finding a chosen regulatory scheme necessary to the protection of commerce our investigation .....

K.R. Lakshman and ors. Vs. Karnataka Electricity Board and ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: JT2001(1)SC196; 2000(8)SCALE230; [2000]Supp5SCR535

..... on the ground that it is highly discriminatory and arbitrary and that there is no rational basis for providing a ratio between technically qualified and technically unqualified people for promotion to the ..... were being shown favoritism by providing a channel of promotion to them but without any rational basis for providing a ratio and putting the unqualified people at more advantageous position must .....

Pennar Delta Ayacutdars Association and Others Vs. Government of Andhr ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2000(3)ALD715

..... in a legal sense to indicate that the findings are without rational basis or that the evidence to support the findings is non ..... adequate determining principle not founded in nature of things non rational not done or acting according to reason or judgment depending ..... a ground of judicial review is primarily concerned with the rationality and reasonableness of the decision in this case the learned .....

E.i.D. Parry (India) Limited and Vs. Assistant Commissioner of

Court: Sales Tax Tribunal STT Tamil Nadu

Reported in: (2000)118STC436Tribunal

..... placed assessee this is a case of failure to classify on rational basis or lack of classification and the following observations in 1995 96 ..... persons would be condemned as discriminatory if there is absence of rational relation to the object intended to be achieved by the ..... by the state to fix the purchase tax rate is rational and reasonable in such circumstances there is no violation of article .....

Sharma Metal Rolling Mills and ors.

Court: Gujarat

Reported in: (2000)4GLR2815

..... be accepted 21 learned counsel submitted that there must be rational basis for classification if the material is converted into another form ..... group and the characteristic or intelligible differentia must have a rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved by the ..... uniform tax discrimination may result for refusal to make a rational classification may itself in some cases operate as denial of .....

A. Thirumalai Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Madras

..... benefit of enhancement of the age of superannuation without any rational basis the tribunal has accepted the challenge made by the respondents ..... age of superannuation it is stated to be without any rational basis therefore the contention of the applicants therein is that the ..... some others like them also and that there is no rational basis for the said proviso originally the tribunal struck down the .....

Remidex Pharmaceuticals Private Limited, Bangalore and Another Vs. Uni ...

Court: Karnataka

Reported in: AIR2000Kant288; ILR2000KAR2197; 2000(5)KarLJ189

..... matters is exhausted when there is found to be a rational basis for the conclusions reached by the concerned authorities as stated ..... function is exhausted when there is found to be a rational basis for the conclusions approved by the administrative body 9 the ..... the judicial function is completed when they establish there exists rational basis for the conclusion arrived at by the administrative body 10 .....

Karmasad Medical Association Vs. State of Gujarat

Court: Gujarat

Reported in: (2000)2GLR1684

..... of course such classification is not arbitrary and has a rational basis and a reasonable connection with the object of the rules ..... an unreasonable classification which is neither intelligible nor has a rational nexus with the object of the rules it was submitted ..... seats is not discriminatory because it is based on a rational principle according to the supreme court there is nothing unreasonable .....

Sunil Bhattacharya Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and anr.

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Kolkata

..... to come to the conclusion that it has any scientific and rational basis to impose this ground of restriction we are of the view ..... posts fall within the purview of acc the rule must be rational and scientific deprieving promotion and status of a post at a ..... we would like to make some observations there should be some rational in fixing the minimum period of service before retirement for the .....