Rational Basis - Judgment Search Results

B. Archana Reddy and ors. Vs. State of A.P., Rep. by Its Secretary, La ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2005(6)ALD582; 2005(6)ALT364

..... that the muslims are a backward class this conclusion is based on no legal and rational basis and the conclusions as to educational and economic backwardness are also not supported by reliable ..... circumstances the occupation and or the means test provides neither a legal nor a rational and logical basis for the conclusion that all muslims are socially backward because some or many of .....

United States Vs. Sioux Nation of Indians

Court: US Supreme Court

..... been relaxed in recent years to allow review under the fifth amendment rational basis test brief for united states 55 n 46 the government relies ..... u s 535 417 u s 555 1974 as establishing a rational basis test for determining whether congress in a given instance confiscated indian ..... nation 295 u s 103 295 u s 111 1935 the rational basis test proffered by the government would be ill suited for use .....

United States. R. Retirement Bd. Vs. Fritz

Court: US Supreme Court

..... the finding that t hese quantitative and qualitative distinctions expressly recognize by congress form a rational basis for congress classification emphasis added see also califano v goldfarb 430 u s 199 430 ..... purpose c the third way in which the court has deviated from the principles of rational basis scrutiny is its failure to analyze page 449 u s 194 whether the challenged classification .....

Cleburne Vs. Cleburne Living Ctr.

Court: US Supreme Court

..... its imprecise classifications it must be pursuant to more powerful scrutiny than the minimal rational basis test used to review classifications affecting only economic and commercial matters the same imprecision ..... of modern equal protection cases striking down legislation under what purports to be a rational basis standard these cases must be and generally have been viewed as intermediate review .....

Nordlinger Vs. Hahn

Court: US Supreme Court

..... fundamental rights judicial scrutiny under the equal protection clause demands only a conceivable rational basis for the challenged state distinction see fritz supra kassel v consolidated freight 28 ..... ago this court unanimously invalidated webster county west virginia s assessment scheme under rational basis scrutiny webster county employed a de facto proposition 13 assessment system the county .....

Heller Vs. Doe

Court: US Supreme Court

..... ill violated the equal protection clause s prohibition of distinctions that lack a rational basis and that participation by family members and guardians violated the due process clause ..... that the distinctions wrought by the kentucky scheme cannot survive even that rational basis scrutiny requiring a rational relationship for such discrimination against insanity acquittees who are no longer mentally .....

Lawrence Vs. Texas

Court: US Supreme Court

..... that homosexual activity is not a fundamental right in rejecting on the basis of the rational basis standard an equalprotection challenge to the defense department s policy of conducting ..... 1996 nordlinger laws such as economic or tax legislation that are scrutinized under rational basis review normally pass constitutional muster since the constitution presumes that even improvident decisions .....

Vbc Ferro Alloys Limited Vs. Andhra Pradesh State Electricity Board an ...

Court: Andhra Pradesh

Reported in: 2000(5)ALD626; 2000(5)ALT340

..... petitioner s company automatically comes under the ht category iii 15 there is a rational basis for making such categorisation and classifying the petitioner company into ht category iii several ..... manufactured by the manufacturers is discriminatory in its nature there is no reason or rational basis in discriminating of charging higher tariffs from the ferro silicon manufacturers from other industrial .....

The State Of Punjab Vs. Davinder Singh

Court: Supreme Court of India

..... the two components are a the purpose and b the rational basis or principle for the differentiation this court has previously held ..... takes us to the next question what must be the rational basis for sub classification within the beneficiary classes since the purpose ..... would be open to the state to provide on a rational basis the preferential treatment by fixing reasonable quota out of reserved .....

Armour Vs. Indianapolis

Court: US Supreme Court

..... not be considered here since the city s administrative concerns are sufficient to show a rational basis for its distinction petitioners propose other forgiveness systems that they argue are superior to ..... this argument however for the administrative considerations we have mentioned are sufficient to show a rational basis for the city s distinction the indiana supreme court wrote that the city s .....