Citation network
Dooley Vs. United States
Cites for this judgment
- US Supreme Court
- Dec 02, 1901
Citation network · 7-day free trial
Brief every cited case in minutes
Open an 18-section AI Brief on any citation below, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial - no card required.
- 18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
- Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
- Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
- Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases
No card required · credentials emailed · Log in if you already have an account
-
Dooley v. UnitedSearch
-
States - 183 U.S. 151 (1901) U.S. Supreme Court Dooley v. UnitedSearch
-
States, 183 U.S. 151 (1901) Dooley v. UnitedSearch
-
to a foreign country, and has no application to Porto Rico, which, in the case of De Lima Page 183 U. S. 152 v. BidwellSearch
-
to the complaint for insufficiency was sustained, and the petition dismissed. The case was argued with De Lima v. BidwellSearch
-
and Armstrong v. UnitedSearch
-
was held in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
Defendants relied largely upon a dictum in Brown v. MarylandSearch
-
was afterwards approved in Brown v. HoustonSearch
-
U. S. 623 . See also Fairbank v. UnitedSearch
-
States, 181 U. S. 283 . It follows, and is the logical sequence of the case of Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
should be given a correlative meaning, and applied only to goods exported to a foreign country. Muller v. BaldwinSearch
-
Brief any citation in this list with AI Studio
-
Porto Rico be no longer a foreign country under the Dingley Act, as was held by a majority of this Court in De Lima v. BidwellSearch
-
U. S. 1 , and Dooley v. UnitedSearch
-
significance. The manner in which and the place at which the tax is levied are of minor consequence. Thus, in Brown v. MarylandSearch
-
without the consent of Congress, lay any impost or duty on imports or exports, and in the recent case of Fairbank v. UnitedSearch
-
the limits of that port. From this moment, the duties became payable as upon imported merchandise. United States v. HowellSearch
-
Arnold v. UnitedSearch
-
Meredith v. UnitedSearch
-
a separate fund for the government and benefit of Porto Rico. The action is really correlative to that of Downes v. BidwellSearch
-
the opinion embodies as it is by me understood. In my judgment, the opinion of the court in the cases of De Lima v. BidwellSearch
-
in the case of The Diamond Rings, as well as the opinions of the majority of the members of the Court in Downes v. BidwellSearch
-
if it is not, affirmance is required. In Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
In the course of the opinion, an intimation of Mr. Chief Justice Marshall, in Brown v. MarylandSearch
-
in the cause, and not therefore decided. So also, the attention of the Court was directed to the case of Almy v. CaliforniaSearch
-
exports, and hence was void, because an export tax within the meaning of the Constitution. In the opinion in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
it was expressly decided that, although the conclusion in Almy v. CaliforniaSearch
-
the movement of goods between the states, and not exclusively to foreign commerce. To the extent, therefore, that Almy v. CaliforniaSearch
-
the meaning of the Constitution embraced anything but foreign commerce, it was expressly overruled. In Brown v. HoustonSearch
-
U. S. 622 , decided in 1884, fourteen years after the decision in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
It was decided by this Court in the case of Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
Page 183 U. S. 161 The opinion, after stating the facts which were presented in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
as having been conclusively determined by Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
a foreign country, or had been, as it was claimed, in part actually exported to such country. Again, in Fairbank v. UnitedSearch
-
country was a tax on exports. In the course of the opinion, in considering the question, the Court referred to Almy v. CaliforniaSearch
-
It is true that, thereafter, in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
A consideration of the opinions in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
and Page 183 U. S. 162 Brown v. HoustonSearch
-
so recently in effect approved by this Court in the case of Fairbank v. UnitedSearch
-
of the United States. And, by implication, in a number of cases decided by this Court since the decision in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
on the states to impose any direct, but also any indirect, burden, and therefore, under the doctrine of Brown v. MarylandSearch
-
foreign commerce and co-related with the clause as to exports, it would follow, as was clearly pointed out in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
is, then, the issue. In De Lima v. BidwellSearch
-
U. S. 164 under its sovereignty and subject, as a possession, to the legislative power of Congress. In Downes v. BidwellSearch
-
This contention, however, is but a restatement of the proposition which the Court held to be unsound in Downes v. BidwellSearch
-
the contention is unfounded, and really but amounts to an indirect attack upon the doctrines announced in Woodruff v. ParhamSearch
-
U.S. Supreme Court Dooley v. UnitedSearch
AI Brief on cited cases - 7-day free trial