Skip to content
Back to judgment

Citation network

Mccullough Vs. Virginia

Cites for this judgment

  • US Supreme Court
  • Dec 05, 1898

Citation network · 7-day free trial

Brief every cited case in minutes

Open an 18-section AI Brief on any citation below, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial - no card required.

  • 18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
  • Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
  • Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
  • Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases

No card required · credentials emailed · Log in if you already have an account

71 entries 12 linked 59 unlinked
Show
  1. Antoni Vs. Greenhow US Supreme Court · Mar 05, 1883
  2. Carter Vs. Greenhow US Supreme Court · Apr 20, 1885
  3. Moore Vs. Greenhow US Supreme Court · May 04, 1885
  4. Marye Vs. Parsons US Supreme Court · Apr 20, 1885
  5. Barry Vs. Edmunds US Supreme Court · Feb 07, 1886
  6. Sands Vs. Edmunds US Supreme Court · Feb 01, 1886
  7. Mcgahey Vs. Virginia US Supreme Court · May 19, 1890
  8. Wright Vs. Nagle US Supreme Court · Jan 01, 1879
  9. Central Land Co. Vs. Laidley US Supreme Court · Jun 03, 1895
    Relied / Followed
  10. Hartman Vs. Greenhow US Supreme Court · Jan 01, 1880
  11. Huntington Vs. Attrill US Supreme Court · Dec 12, 1892
  12. Lehigh Water Co. Vs. Easton US Supreme Court · Apr 18, 1887
    Relied / Followed
  13. U.S. 102 (1898) U.S. Supreme Court McCullough v. Virginia
    Search
  14. U.S. 102 (1898) McCullough v. Virginia
    Search
  15. where the writ would lie according to the principles of the common law, and in Page 172 U. S. 104 Antoni v. Wright
    Search
  16. from the treasurer a return of the money paid. The various features of this act are specifically pointed out in Antoni v. Greenhow
    Search
  17. prolific of many cases, both in the state and federal courts, not a few of which finally came to this Court. Hartman v. Greenhow
    Search
  18. Stewart v. Virginia
    Search
  19. the passage of the Act of March 7, 1872, which in terms required all taxes to be paid in cash, the case of Antoni v. Wright
    Search
  20. embraced in the coupon provision of the act of 1871. This decision was reaffirmed in Page 172 U. S. 107 Wise v. Rogers
    Search
  21. Clark v. Tyler
    Search
  22. Gratt. 135, decided April 4, 1878, and again in Williamson v. Massey
    Search
  23. Gratt. 237, decided April 29, 1880. In Greenhow v. Vashon
    Search
  24. of the validity of the act of 1871. There has been no dissonance in the declarations from the first case, Hartman v. Greenhow
    Search
  25. to McGahey v. Virginia
    Search
  26. to use them in payment of state taxes and public dues. Page 172 U. S. 108 This was determined in Hartman v. Greenhow
    Search
  27. in Antoni v. Greenhow
    Search
  28. Since the decision of the Court of Appeals of Virginia in Antoni v. Wright
    Search
  29. reference may be had to the opinion of Mr. Justice Bradley in the several cases reported under the title of McGahey v. Virginia
    Search
  30. ourselves with reiterating that which was said by Mr. Justice Bradley, speaking for the entire Court, in McGahey v. Virginia
    Search
  31. and that in reference to the matter of contracts alleged to have been impaired. This was distinctly affirmed in Bank v. Skelly
    Search
  32. The doctrine thus announced has been uniformly followed. Bridge Proprietors v. Hoboken
    Search
  33. Douglas v. Kentucky
    Search
  34. U. S. 501 , and cases cited therein. 3. It is urged that our last decision -- that in McGahey v. Virginia
    Search
  35. But the court overlooks that which was in fact decided in the eight cases reported under the title of McGahey v. Virginia
    Search
  36. its operation. Indeed, the Court of Appeals does not follow what it calls the logic of the decision in McGahey v. Virginia
    Search
  37. U. S. 114 because the whole consideration is the basis of the whole promise. The parts are inseparable. Widoe v. Webb
    Search
  38. To like effect are the decisions of this Court. In United States v. Bradley
    Search
  39. So, in Gelpcke v. City
    Search
  40. of that act, and adjudges it void. In support of this proposition, the rule laid down in New Orleans Water Works Co. v. Louisiana
    Search
  41. Sugar Refining Co., 125 U. S. 18 , 125 U. S. 38 , reaffirmed in Huntington v. Attrill
    Search
  42. U. S. 657 , 146 U. S. 684 , and Bacon v. Texas
    Search
  43. by some subsequent statute of the state which has been upheld or effect given it by the state court. Lehigh Water Co. v. Easton
    Search
  44. New Orleans Water Works Co. v. Louisiana
    Search
  45. prevent a state from nullifying by its legislation a contract which it has made, or authorized to be made. In Hickie v. Starke
    Search
  46. And in Willson v. Blackbird
    Search
  47. discussed and decided. . . . This Court has repeatedly decided in favor of its jurisdiction in such a case. Martin v. Hunter's
    Search
  48. Lessee, 1 Wheat. 304, Miller v. Nichols
    Search
  49. U.S. Supreme Court McCullough v. Virginia
    Search
  50. Antoni v. Wright
    Search

AI Briefs · Semantic Search · Save & annotate judgments

Start your 7-day free trial