Citation network
The Harrisburg
Cites for this judgment
- US Supreme Court
- Nov 15, 1886
Citation network · 7-day free trial
Brief every cited case in minutes
Open an 18-section AI Brief on any citation below, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial - no card required.
- 18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
- Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
- Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
- Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases
No card required · credentials emailed · Log in if you already have an account
-
It was held by this Court, on full consideration, in Insurance Co. v. BrameSearch
-
Dennick v. RailroadSearch
-
by the House of Lords in 1884. Many of the cases bearing on this question are cited in the opinion in Insurance Co. v. BrameSearch
-
Others will be found referred to in an elaborate note to Carey v. BerkshireSearch
-
The only American cases in the common law courts against the rule to which our attention has been called are Cross v. GutherySearch
-
Ford Page 119 U. S. 205 v. MonroeSearch
-
James v. ChristySearch
-
Mo. 162, and Sullivan v. UnionSearch
-
Pacific Railroad, 3 Dillon 334. Cross v. GutherySearch
-
a Connecticut case, was decided in 1794, and cannot be reconciled with Goodsell v. HartfordSearch
-
Ford v. MonroeSearch
-
a New York case, was substantially overruled by the Court of Appeals of that state in Green v. HudsonSearch
-
River Railroad, 41 N.Y. 294, and Sullivan v. UnionSearch
-
by the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Nebraska, is directly in conflict with Insurance Co. v. BrameSearch
-
administered in the courts of the United States, a contrary rule has been or ought to be established. In Plummer v. WebbSearch
-
Brief any citation in this list with AI Studio
-
maritime in its nature. We find no other reported case in which this subject was at all discussed until Cutting v. SeaburySearch
-
if, in a proper case, a recovery could be had. The same eminent judge had, however, held as early as 1849, in Crapo v. AllenSearch
-
In his opinion, he refers to the leading English case of Baker v. BoltonSearch
-
Camp. 493, where the common law rule was recognized and followed by Lord Ellenborough in 1808, and to Carey v. BerkshireSearch
-
For this he cites as authority Ford v. MonroeSearch
-
supra, decided in 1838, but which, as we have seen, had been overruled by Green v. HudsonSearch
-
River Railroad in 1866, only a short time before the opinion of the Chief Justice was delivered, and James v. ChristySearch
-
Circuit Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania in 1877, and before the judgment of this Court in Insurance Co. v. BrameSearch
-
Justice Chase in The Sea Gull was approved, and the same authorities were cited, with the addition of Sullivan v. UnionSearch
-
of a plea to the jurisdiction, the judge, after quoting a remark of Mr. Justice Clifford in Steamboat Co. v. ChaseSearch
-
Our decision in Insurance Co. v. BrameSearch
-
been generally distributed when his opinion was filed. It thus appears that prior to the decision in Insurance Co. v. BrameSearch
-
in this Court, he yielded to the authority of the circuit court decision in his own district. The case of Holmes v. OregonSearch
-
a case, and the death occurred within the jurisdiction of the state. Judge Sawyer had previously decide, in Armstrong v. BeadleSearch
-
Cutting v. SeaburySearch
-
In Monaghan v. HornSearch
-
Cadell v. BlackSearch
-
Weems v. MathiesonSearch
-
Rolland v. GosseSearch
-
It is said also that such was the civil law, but this is denied by the Supreme Court of Louisiana in Hubgh v. NewSearch
-
the subject in an elaborate opinion after full argument. A reargument of the same question was allowed in Hermann v. NewSearch
-
Insurance Co. v. BrameSearch
-
Dennick v. RailroadSearch
-
Carey v. BerkshireSearch
-
Cross v. GutherySearch
-
and Sullivan v. UnionSearch
-
Goodsell v. HartfordSearch
-
Green v. HudsonSearch
-
In Plummer v. WebbSearch
-
Crapo v. AllenSearch
-
of Baker v. BoltonSearch
-
and James v. ChristySearch
-
of Sullivan v. UnionSearch
-
Steamboat Co. v. ChaseSearch
-
of Holmes v. OregonSearch
AI Brief on cited cases - 7-day free trial