United States Vs. Rimer

United States vs Rimer

Type Court Judgment Court US Supreme Court Decided May-15-1911

~3 min read

https://sooperkanoon.com/case/91060

For advocates & juniors · 7-day free trial

Brief this judgment before chambers

Stop skimming 50 pages - get an 18-section AI Brief on this case, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial, no card required.

18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases

Citation: sooperkanoon.com/91060
Court: US Supreme Court
Decided On: May-15-1911
Case Number: 220 U.S. 547
Subject: Miscellaneous

Case Summary

AI-generated summary - not the official court judgment text.

Miscellaneous

Key legal issue: Miscellaneous

Parties & Advocates

Appellant / Petitioner

United States

Respondent

Rimer

Excerpt

.....or have such effect, and that the action of the court below was not, either as to its character or importance, within the scope of the grant of power given by the judiciary act of 1891 to review by certiorari, the writ will be dismissed. the facts, which involve t he jurisdiction of this copurt in regard to the scope of the grant of power under the judiciary act of 1891 to review judgments of the circuit courts of appeal, are stated in the opinion. mr. chief justice white, after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the court. the petition presented by the united states in this case for the allowance of a writ of certiorari, which was not opposed, proceeded upon the basis that the decision below involved a principle concerning the collection of internal revenue taxes of far-reaching importance, and which, if thereafter applied in accordance with what it was urged was the rule established by the lower court, would overthrow page 220 u. s. 548 practices prevailing as to the collection of internal revenue taxes for a long period of time, founded upon a well settled administrative construction, and thus produce at least great confusion. as the record at least prima facie tended to sustain these contentions of the government, the writ of certiorari was granted. with candor, in the argument at bar, while perspicuously discussing the legal propositions which it was deemed were involved when the certiorari was petitioned for, the government conceded that a closer scrutiny of the record made it exceedingly doubtful whether the action of the court below, when accurately tested, dealt with the principle which it was deemed rendered the granting of the writ necessary. coming to consider the record, we conclude that it establishes that the doubt suggested by the government is well founded, and therefore, if we were to consider and decide the case, we would but review the action of the court below in regard to a question as.....

Full Judgment

United States v. Rimer - 220 U.S. 547 (1911)
U.S. Supreme Court United States v. Rimer, 220 U.S. 547 (1911)

United States v. Rimer

No. 963

Argued April 26, 1911

Decided May 15, 1911

220 U.S. 547

CERTIORARI TO THE COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT

SYLLABUS

When certiorari is granted on the basis that the decision below involved principles of far-reaching effect and overthrew settled administrative construction, and it appeals on the argument that the decision does not deal with such principles or have such effect, and that the action of the court below was not, either as to its character or importance, within the scope of the grant of power given by the Judiciary Act of 1891 to review by certiorari, the writ will be dismissed.

The facts, which involve t he jurisdiction of this Copurt in regard to the scope of the grant of power under the Judiciary Act of 1891 to review judgments of the Circuit Courts of Appeal, are stated in the opinion.

MR. CHIEF JUSTICE WHITE, after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the Court.

The petition presented by the United States in this case for the allowance of a writ of certiorari, which was not opposed, proceeded upon the basis that the decision below involved a principle concerning the collection of internal revenue taxes of far-reaching importance, and which, if thereafter applied in accordance with what it was urged was the rule established by the lower court, would overthrow

Page 220 U. S. 548

practices prevailing as to the collection of internal revenue taxes for a long period of time, founded upon a well settled administrative construction, and thus produce at least great confusion.

As the record at least prima facie tended to sustain these contentions of the government, the writ of certiorari was granted. With candor, in the argument at bar, while perspicuously discussing the legal propositions which it was deemed were involved when the certiorari was petitioned for, the government conceded that a closer scrutiny of the record made it exceedingly doubtful whether the action of the court below, when accurately tested, dealt with the principle which it was deemed rendered the granting of the writ necessary. Coming to consider the record, we conclude that it establishes that the doubt suggested by the government is well founded, and therefore, if we were to consider and decide the case, we would but review the action of the court below in regard to a question as to which, under the Judiciary Act of 1891, the action of the court was final, and which, neither from its character nor importance, was within the scope of the grant of power to review by certiorari.

After giving the matter most careful consideration because of the precedent as to future cases which must arise from the action we take in this, we have concluded that, under the conditions which we have stated, our duty is not to pass upon the merits of the case, but to dismiss the writ of certiorari. Our order will therefore be

Writ of certiorari dismissed.

Same Parties United States vs Rimer Same Subject Miscellaneous