Herhold Vs. Upton

herhold v. upton - 154 u.s. 624 (1876) u.s. supreme court herhold v. upton, 154 u.s. 624 (1876) herhold v. upton no. 125 submitted november 29, 1876 decided december 4, 1876 154 u.s. 624 error to the circuit court of the united states for the northern district of illinois syllabus upton v. tribilcock, 91 u. s. 45 ; sanger v. upton, 91 u. s. 56 , and webster v. upton, 91 u. s. 65 , followed. mr. chief justice waite delivered the opinion of the court. the principles decided in upton v. tribilcock, 91 u. s. 45 ; sanger v. upton, 91 u. s. 56 , and webster v. upton, 91 u. s. 65 , are conclusive of this case. the judgment of the circuit court is therefore affirmed upon the authority of those cases. if the stock held by herhold is part of the increased capital, he is estopped by his acceptance of the certificate from denying the regularity of the proceedings under which the increase was effected. if it is part of the original stock, his liability exists whether the increase was made or not. in either event, the testimony offered to show that he did not sign the assent to the increase of the capital stock, filed with the auditor of public accounts, was immaterial and properly excluded. affirmed.