Ravinder Kaur Vs. Hitinder Singh

- [a.s. anand, c.j. and; r.c. lahoti, j.] -- law - appointment - selection - examination - provision in rules that a candidate taking the examination must resign from his existing service - appellant taking the examination without complying with the said provision and being selected - circumstances warranting benefit of the examination despite such omission -- the appellant was appointed to the indian revenue service on the basis of the civil services examination held in the year 1989. while in service he took the indian civil services examination again in the year 1991. since the appellant did not resign from the indian revenue service before taking the indian civil services examination, 1991 the respondents, taking shelter behind rule 4 of the rules, are not permitting the appellant to join the indian administrative service to which he has been selected......1986 (the rules) provides that a candidate, taking the examination, must resign from the service to which he is already appointed. the vires of this rule has been upheld by this court in mohan kumar singhania v. union of india1. since the appellant did not resign from the indian revenue service before taking the indian civil services examination, 1991 the respondents, taking shelter behind rule 4 of the rules, are not permitting the appellant to join the indian administrative service to which he has been selected. technically no fault can be found with the stand taken by the respondents. we are, however, of the view that keeping in view the facts and circumstances of this case specially that the appellant sat in the 1991 examination under the directions of this court he should be given the benefit of the said examination. it is not disputed before us that several candidates similarly situated who sat in the indian civil services examinations during the period 1986-90 without resigning their jobs were given the benefit of their selection. it would be travesty of justice if the appellant is denied the fruit of his selection to the indian administrative service.4. we set aside the impugned judgment of the central administrative tribunal and direct the respondents to declare the result and consequent merit of the appellant in respect of the indian civil services examination, 1991. he shall be entitled to the appointment to the indian administrative service in the year 1991 batch as a result of the above-said examination. the appeal is allowed in the above terms. no costs.