Durga Prasad Vs. Shivnarain

Durga Prasad vs Shivnarain

Type Court Judgment Court Madhya Pradesh Decided Jan 06, 1956

~2 min read

https://sooperkanoon.com/case/497947

For advocates & juniors · 7-day free trial

Brief this judgment before chambers

Stop skimming 50 pages - get an 18-section AI Brief on this case, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial, no card required.

18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases

Citation: sooperkanoon.com/497947
Court: Madhya Pradesh High Court
Judge: Dixit, J.
Decided On: Jan 06, 1956
Subject: Criminal

Case Summary

AI-generated summary - not the official court judgment text.

- - Here the principal court of ordinary original civil jurisdiction is clearly the Court of District Judge Gwalior. It is clearly incompetent and is accordingly rejected.

Key legal issue: Criminal

Parties & Advocates

Appellant / Petitioner

Durga Prasad

Respondent

Shivnarain

Advocate Mr. Ramroop Tiwari

Legal References

Reported In: 1957CriLJ198

Excerpt

- - here the principal court of ordinary original civil jurisdiction is clearly the court of district judge gwalior. it is clearly incompetent and is accordingly rejected......appeal under section 476-b cr. p. c.2. mr. ramroop tiwari learned counsel for the respondent has taken the preliminary objection that this appeal is incompetent inasmuch as the court of small causes is not a court subordinate to this court within the meaning of section 476-b and section 195 cr. p. c. this objection must, in my opinion, prevail. under section 476-b an appeal from a decision of any civil revenue or criminal court refusing to make a complaint under section 476 or 476-a lies to the court to which the civil, revenue of criminal court is subordinate within the meaning of section 195(3) of the code.now under section 195(3) a court is deemed to be subordinate to the court to which appeals ordinarily lie from the appealable decrees or sentences of such former court or in the case of a civil court from whose decrees no appeal ordinarily lies to the principal court having ordinary original civil jurisdiction within the local limits of whose jurisdiction such civil court is situate.no appeal lies from the decisions of the court of small causes, therefore under section 476-b read with section 195 (3) cr. p. c., an appeal against an order passed by the court of small causes refusing to make a complaint under section 476 would lie to the principal court of ordinary original civil jurisdiction where the court of small causes is situated.here the principal court of ordinary original civil jurisdiction is clearly the court of district judge gwalior. the appeal should have been, therefore, filed in the court of district judge gwalior and not in this court. it is clearly incompetent and is accordingly rejected.

Full Judgment

Dixit, J.

1. The facts of this appeal are that the appellant Durga Prasad made an application in the Court of Small Causes Lashkar for the institution by that Court of a complaint against Shivnarayan in respect of offences under Sections 209 and 193 I. P. C. It was said that Shivnarain had committed the said offences in a civil suit decided by the Court of Small Causes. The learned Judge of the Court of Small Causes refused to make any complaint against Shivnarain. Durga Prasad has now filed this appeal under Section 476-B Cr. P. C.

2. Mr. Ramroop Tiwari learned Counsel for the respondent has taken the preliminary objection that this appeal is incompetent inasmuch as the Court of Small Causes is not a Court Subordinate to this Court within the meaning of Section 476-B and Section 195 Cr. P. C. This objection must, in my opinion, prevail. Under Section 476-B an appeal from a decision of any civil revenue or criminal court refusing to make a complaint under Section 476 or 476-A lies to the Court to which the civil, revenue of criminal Court is subordinate within the meaning of Section 195(3) of the Code.

Now under Section 195(3) a court is deemed to be subordinate to the court to which appeals ordinarily lie from the appealable decrees or sentences of such former court or in the case of a Civil Court from whose decrees no appeal ordinarily lies to the principal court having ordinary original civil jurisdiction within the local limits of whose jurisdiction such civil court is situate.

No appeal lies from the decisions of the Court of Small Causes, Therefore under Section 476-B read with Section 195 (3) Cr. P. C., an appeal against an order passed by the Court of Small Causes refusing to make a complaint under Section 476 would lie to the principal court of ordinary original civil jurisdiction where the Court of Small Causes is situated.

Here the principal court of ordinary original civil jurisdiction is clearly the Court of District Judge Gwalior. The appeal should have been, therefore, filed in the Court of District Judge Gwalior and not in this Court. It is clearly incompetent and is accordingly rejected.

Same Parties Durga Prasad vs Shivnarain Same Subject Criminal Same Judge Dixit, J.

Criminal