Narasappa vs Bheemayya

Type Court Judgment Court Karnataka Kalaburagi Decided Jan 20, 2026

~5 min read

https://sooperkanoon.com/case/1508094

For advocates & juniors · 7-day free trial

Brief this judgment before chambers

Stop skimming 50 pages - get an 18-section AI Brief on this case, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial, no card required.

18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases

Citation: sooperkanoon.com/1508094
Court: Karnataka Kalaburagi High Court
Judge: R.Nataraj,Tyagaraja N. Inavally
Decided On: Jan 20, 2026
Case Number: RFA/200162/2025

Parties & Advocates

Appellant / Petitioner

Narasappa

Respondent

Bheemayya

Excerpt

-1- ! " # $ # $ % "" & ' ( ) ! " digitally signed by # sachin location: high court of karnataka ! $ % ! -2- ! & ' ( ) ! deleted vide court * order dated 11.11.2025 ! " ! ! + " -3- ! ! , ! ) ! ' $ ( ! * % ! ! $ $ -4- ! ! &' - # . " . "!" " ( - - $ * - -% " !* "!"# *# "! % % - - -- - - % $ / % % / % % ' / % %( 01 2131425467 8 " # 542 94 8 *# "! 05:1 39;12 6097 5<<15; =05;;14>94> 601 ?@2>a146 542 21=b11 25612 " !* "!"# cd e09=0 601 7@96 38b 21=;5b56984 83 696;1 -5- 83 601 <;59469337 542 68 21=;5b1 6056 601 ;854 b59712 cd 601 213142546 8 # 3b8a 601 213142546 8 57 486 c94294> 84 601 <;59469337 e57 21=b112 " 01 7@96 94 8 *# "! e57 39;12 38b 521=;5b56984 6056 601 <;59469337 5b1 601 5c78;@61 8e41b7 83 7@96 7=012@;1 <b8<1b6d 542 38b <1b<16@5; 94?@4=6984 542 68 21=;5b1 6056 601 ;854 b59712 cd 601 213142546 8 # 3b8a 601 213142546 8 cd =b15694> =05b>1 8:1b 601 7@96 <b8<1b6d 97 9;;1>5; @41438b=15c;1 542 486 c94294> 83 601 <;59469337 542 38b =8471f@14695; b1;913 83 b1=6939=56984 83b1:14@1 b1=8b27 01 <;59469337 =;59a12 6056 601 7@96 <b8<1b6d e57 <@b=05712 cd 6019b 35601b 54@a5 , 54@a54605 3b8a 841 54>5 84 !" ! * 542601b15361b 097 45a1 e57 1461b12 94 601 b1:14@1 b1=8b27 01 7592 54@a5 , 54@a54605 2912 # d15b7 <b98b 68 601 39;94> 83 601 7@96 ;15:94> c10942 097 38@b 7847 45a12 011a5dd5 09aa5dd5 5>5b122d , 5>5<<5 542 5b575<<5 542 6e8 25@>061b7 45a12 .....

Full Judgment

-1- ! " # $ # $ % "" & ' ( ) ! " Digitally signed by # SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA ! $ % ! -2- ! & ' ( ) ! Deleted vide court * order dated 11.11.2025 ! " ! ! + " -3- ! ! , ! ) ! ' $ ( ! * % ! ! $ $ -4- ! ! &

'                                                                 -                #           .
                  "                     .
                          "!"       "                         (
                            -                                 -
                      $                           *           -                           -

% " !* "!"# *# "! % % - - -- - - % $ / % % / % % ' / % %( 01 2131425467 8 " # 542 94 8 *# "! 05:1 39;12 6097 5<<15; =05;;14>94> 601 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 25612 " !* "!"# CD E09=0 601 7@96 38B 21=;5B56984 83 696;1 -5- 83 601 <;59469337 542 68 21=;5B1 6056 601 ;854 B59712 CD 601 213142546 8 # 3B8A 601 213142546 8 57 486 C94294> 84 601 <;59469337 E57 21=B112 " 01 7@96 94 8 *# "! E57 39;12 38B 5

21=;5B56984 6056 601 <;59469337 5B1 601 5C78;@61 8E41B7 83 7@96 7=012@;1 =05B>1 8:1B 601 7@96 5; @41438B=15C;1 542 486 C94294> 83 601 <;59469337 542 38B =8471F@14695; B1;913 83 B1=6939=56984 83

B1:14@1 B1=8B27        01 <;59469337 =;59A12 6056 601 7@96
5   84   !" !     *    542

601B15361B 097 45A1 E57 1461B12 94 601 B1:14@1 B1=8B27 01 7592 54@A5 , 54@A54605 2912 # D15B7 83 601 7@96 ;15:94> C10942 097 38@B 7847 45A12

 011A5DD5       09AA5DD5      5>5B122D ,         5>5<<5 542
 5B575<<5 542 6E8 25@>061B7 45A12           09AA5GG5 542
 4?545AA5       01 79H =09;2B14 83   54@A5 ,      54@A54605

-6- 052 7@==11212 68 097

?8946 35A9;D         01D =;59A12 6056 94 8B21B 68 5:59; ;854 3B8A
39454=95; 947696@69847 542 C54G7 542                  8 8<1B569:1 78=916917
542   5;78      68     5:59;    7@=0     35=9;96917     8:1B4A146 601D >86 6019B 45A17 1461B12 94 601 B1:14@1 B1=8B27 94 B17<1=6 83 <8B69847 83 601 7@96 76 601A
 01D =;59A12 6056 601 213142546                8       35601B 83 213142546
 8 " 542 0@7C542 83 213142546                      8 # >86 6019B 45A17
1461B12 94 B17<1=6 83 !                 5=B17 !" >@4657 94           @B:1D
 8    I I    94      61BA7     83    A@656984      7     94
 8     "!!      !)      =;59A94> 68 C1 601 784 83               54@A5 ,
 54@A54605            9G1E971 601 213142546             8 " >86 097 45A1
9461BB12 94 B17<1=6 83 !            >@4657 94 097 45A1 57 601 784 83
601 <;5946933        8)      01D =;59A12 6056 E09;1 601 <;59469337
C1;84>12 68          8;;5 =5761 601 2131425467 C1;84>12 68 29>5
 5761 542 E09;1 601 <;59469337J 7@B45A1 E57                     52E5; 601
7@B45A1        83     601      2131425467       E57        525>5A528229
01B138B1 601 <;59469337 =;59A12 6056 601D 5B1 486 B1;5612 -7- 68 601 2131425467 94 54D A5441B 542 6056 601 B1:14@1 B1=8B27 CB8@>06 5C8@6 CD 601 2131425467 5B1 5;; 3B5@2@;146
542 5B1 486 C94294> @<84 601 <;59469337               01D 5;78 =;59A12
6056 213142546        8 # 052 5:59;12 5 ;854 3B8A 601 213142546
 8     84 601 71=@B96D 83 601 E57 486 C94294> @<84 601A # 056 7@AA847 94 601 7@96 E57 71B:12 84 601
2131425467          01 2131425467     87       68      39;12 5 EB96614
76561A146       8E1:1B 6019B =8@471; B169B12 3B8A 601 =571
 01B15361B 601 213142546         87    68       292 486 5<<15B 542
292 486 <5B69=9<561 94 601 6B95; C@6 B1A59412 5C7146                01
213142546       8     39;12 097 EB96614 76561A146 542 =;59A12
6056 96 E57 486 5E5B1 83 601 5771B69847 A521 94 <5B5 " 68 83 601 <;5946 6 =84614612 6056 96 052 754=698412 5 ;854 68 213142546 8 # 94 5==8B254=1 E960 ;5E 542 57 <1B 601 06 68 711G 38B 5 21=B11 6056 601 ;854 5:59;12 CD 213142546 8 # 3B8A 213142546 8 97 9;;1>5; 4@;; 542 :892 -8- 5712 84 60171 B9:5; =8461469847 601 6B95; 8@B6 3B5A12 977@17 542 716 28E4 601 =571 38B 6B95; 01 <;5946933 8 E57 1H5A9412 57 $ 542
A5BG12       H      68       #" 542 1H5A9412           $" 542     $#             01
213142546         87         68        292 486 =B877 1H5A941 60171
E96417717 542 292 486 ;152 54D 1:9214=1                       01 213142546
 8      E57 1H5A9412 57                $         542 A5BG12   H        68        #
5712 84 601 5C8:1 542 65G94> 9468 5==8@46 601 35=6 6056 601 213142546 87 68 052 486 =84617612 601 7@96 601 6B95; 8@B6 21=B112 601 7@96 83 601 <;59469337 542 21=;5B12 6056 601 <;59469337 5B1 601 8E41B7 83 601 7@96  5>>B91:12 CD 601 7592 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 601 213142546 87 68 5B1 C138B1 6097 8@B6 01 ;15B412 =8@471; 38B 213142546 87 68 7@CA96612 6056 601 2131425467 E1B1 @45E5B1 5C8@6 601 21=B11 <57712 57 6019B 5ED1B 052 B169B12 3B8A 601 =571 542 601D 052 48 9469A56984 6056 601 =571 B54612 5 21=B11 83 21=;5B56984 94 601 35=1 83 :5B98@7 B1:14@1
28=@A1467 E09=0 9429=5612 6056 213142546 87 68 E1B1 601 8E41B7 83 601 B54612 68 601 2131425467 68 =846176 601 7@96 84 A1B967 1 601B138B1 412 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 C1 716 57921 542 54 8<<8B6@496D C1 >B54612 68 601 2131425467 68 =846176 601 7@96 84 A1B967 ) 601 ;15B412 =8@471; 38B 601 <;59469337 =84614212 6056 601 >B54235601B 83 601 <;59469337 052 <@B=05712 601 1 83 601 79A9;5B96D 94 601 45A17 83 601 35601B 83 601 <;59469337 542 6019B 35601B 542 05:1 CB8@>06 5C8@6 :5B98@7 B1:14@1 146B917 94 6019B B17<1=69:1 45A17 94 B17<1=6 83 601 7@96 
8<<8B6@496D 97 >9:14 68 213142546 87 68 601D E9;; 486 C1 94 5 <8796984 68  68 6E8 29331B146 =57617 542 C1;84> 68 6E8 29331B146 08@7108;27 1 601B138B1 =8461427 6056 48 @713@; <@B<871 E8@;2 C1 71B:12 94 B1768B94> 601 7@96 542 5;;8E94> 54 8<<8B6@496D 68 601 2131425467 68 =846176 601 7@96 84 A1B967
$1 05:1 =847921B12 7@CA9779847 A521 CD 601 ;15B412 =8@471; 38B 601 <;59469337 542 601 ;15B412 =8@471;
38B 213142546    87     68    542 <1B@712 601 B1=8B27 <;5=12
C138B1 @7    01 84;D <8946 6056 5B9717 38B 8@B =847921B56984
94 6097 5<<15; 97       KE01601B 54 8<<8B6@496D 057 68 C1
>B54612 68 213142546         87       68   68 =846176 601 7@96 84
A1B967LM * 6 97 765612 94 601 ?@2>A146 <57712 CD 601 B95; 8@B6 9671;3 6056 601 2:8=561 38B 213142546 87 68 052 B169B12 3B8A 601 =571 542 6056 213142546 87 68 292 486 <5B69=9<561 94 601 7@96 542 292 486 ;152 54D 1:9214=1 01 2131425467 =;59A12 696;1 68 =1B6594 <8B69847 83 601 7@96 - 11 -  696;1 68 601 ;542 94 @B:1D 8 01B138B1 608@>0 601 2131425467 E1B1 486 29;9>146 94 21314294> 601 7@96 1:14 5361B 601D 14>5>12 54 2:8=561 D16 601D =54486 C1 =8421A412 @4015B2 01 94=84:14914=1 =5@712 68 601 <;59469337 =54 C1 7@965C;D =8A<1475612 542 601 2131425467 =54 C1 <@6 84 61BA7 78 57 68 147@B1 6056 601D 28 486 3@B601B 
7 097 E8@;2 5;78 7@C 71B:1 601 1427 83 ?@769=1 8471F@146;D E1 5B1 83 601 8<94984 6056 608@>0 601 2131425467 05:1 486 A521 8@6 54 1H6B58B2945BD =571 38B @<716694> 601 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 <57712 CD 601 B95; 8@B6 D16 794=1 601 9A<@>412 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 5331=67 601 06 696;1 542 9461B176 83 213142546
 87       68    94 601 7@96 B54612 68 213142546          87   68   68 =846176 601 7@96
84 A1B967        ==8B294>;D 601 <8946 38B =847921B56984 3B5A12
CD @7 97 547E1B12 94 35:8@B 83 213142546        87   68
! 4 :91E 83 601 5C8:1 E1 <577 601 38;;8E94> - 12 -
9(      01 5<<15; 97 5;;8E12 94 <5B6
99(     01 9A<@>412 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11
       <57712 CD 601               B95;    8@B6 97 716 57921
        01 7@96 C138B1 601                        B95;    8@B6 97
B1768B12 7@C?1=6 68 <5DA146 83 =876 83 7 ! !!! <5D5C;1 CD 213142546 87 68 68 <;5946933 87 68 ) 8B 6019B ;1>5; B1
999(   6 97 A521 =;15B 6056 93 213142546
        87         68      359; 68 <5D 601 =876 601
        B95;            8@B6       705;;      B1961B561       601
       ?@2>A146 <57712 84 "                   !* "!"#
9:(     01         B95;        8@B6 705;; 3B5A1 3B170
977@17 93 41=1775BD 84 601 41H6 2561 83 015B94> 542 B1=8B2 601 1:9214=1 542 =B877 1H5A9456984 83 601 <;59469337 3 601 977@17 ?@7693D B171B:94> 601 B9>06 68 ;152 B1C@665; 1:9214=1 CD <;59469337 601 B95; 8@B6 A5D 28 78 01 2131425467 705;; 5;78 ;152 6019B - 13 -
1:9214=1 C138B1 601 B95; 8@B6 542 5;78 A5G1 601A71;:17 5:59;5C;1 38B =B877 1H5A9456984 CD 601 <;59469337 01 B95; 8@B6 705;; B171B:1 ;9C1B6D 68 601 <;59469337 68 ;152 54D B1C@665; 1:9214=1 :( 01 B95; 8@B6 705;; 14215:8B 68 297<871 83 601 7@96 E96094 5 <1B982 83 79H A84607 3B8A 601 2561 83 601 <5B6917 =84=;@294> 6019B 1:9214=1 :9( 01 <;59469337 705;; 5<<15B C138B1 601 B95; 8@B6 84 "! !" "!"
*' & ( *' & % (
   '

Same Court & Year Karnataka Kalaburagi · 2026 Same Parties Narasappa vs Bheemayya Same Judge R.Nataraj,Tyagaraja N. Inavally