Skip to content
How to use Judgment tools
  1. Click Tools to open PDF, Print, Tag, Note, Favourite, and CiteSignal.
  2. Use Brief & Ask in the toolbar for the AI Brief and case chat.
  3. Jump to sections with the pills below the help bar.

Sujatha vs Vender Sreekrishna Swami Kshethram Charitable Trust

Sujatha vs Vender Sreekrishna Swami Kshethram Charitable Trust

Type Court Judgment Court Kerala Orders Decided Oct 06, 2022
~17 min read
https://sooperkanoon.com/case/1474022

For advocates & juniors · 7-day free trial

Brief this judgment before chambers

Stop skimming 50 pages - get an 18-section AI Brief on this case, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial, no card required.

  • 18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
  • Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
  • Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
  • Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases

No card required · credentials emailed · Log in if you already have an account

Citation
Court
Kerala Orders High Court
Judge
Decided On
Case Number
RSA/277/2018

Parties & Advocates

Appellant / Petitioner

Sujatha

Respondent

Vender Sreekrishna Swami Kshethram Charitable Trust

Excerpt

.....aram muri , kottararecara viid age , ito ttaraickara-691505.r.s.a.nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 irol ra ben aged 73 yeus w/o. beiaskaran -vi-rihds ita,ir, saju emv:en, , 'rdb-riaetaiaini`i-6-9`i 5@j .. thekkumpu ram muri , puthoorsa4ukumm aged 48 years s/o. biiaskaran nzilr, sa4u bhavan, theececuncam am mi7ri , p(7thoor vlliaes , rottarakkh ra-691 507. 814uhuman red 43 years a/o. bhaskaran it air, sajtj bhavan, thereanmi ram m]ri , eu"c or viijijre , kottaraickara-691507. 3hx2l aged 43 years w/o. hareesh kumnr, paracecal. veei)u, thevaiappurzo4 rest, is-d-tjvini-eta -v-i-riaae , -ri6eirirri hra-6-9-1 5-06 . 10 sreem ri oil nor) aged 15 yelus s/o. hareesheaimar & 4aya, parackal veedu, tm=vaiappu ram pest, neduv athur vlnaer , kottarakkara-691 5o6, f gpresented 8¥ hls ro trer aiili a iari>ian daya (resrotil]ent no. 9) . 11 mjra!m ri (mlror) red 15 years a/o. elreesl]kumar a 4zi ta, parackal veedu, thevaiappurio4 west, rei}uv athur vl liach= , ecottarakka ra-6915o6, represented bt i]is cother and gti ardian java (re§poreent no. 9) . 12 srv ahari (minor) reli 11 yeas s/o. elasee8hla"ar & daya, parnc kzli, veedu, trevalaphm am rest, redtrv athur vlllj re , rottaraic kara-691 506, repr=s ented eif hls motlnr alto gnla rdian jaya (fgspondent no.9) . 13 gireesh kumhr aged 49 years §/6 ` -eara5-ri± ibaah, biraaizal -v==b-a , ii-rie-vifee>-tfaaira -fa§e , red!rvatrmir vllance , rotlarakegn ra-691 5o6. 14 sfuee- agei) 55 years d/o. barathi aioua, i)arackal veedu, trevaiappuram rest, rei)uvathur viliage , ec ottarzikkara-691 506.[apeq=iij`iit no. 1 , k. bhaen]ma ltei ab04k diei> peimneg tin appenl alro her l.r's were impleai)ed as addl. appelents 2 & 3 who are the appellants in this r.s.a. i [eurspo ni)ent no.2, m. bhaskaran it air and resporo ent no.7, k.bharathi ab04a died pending the appeal and their i..r. 's were i-riip-ierii}i@ i§ ieii>-i„ -k=§-b6fo=-riis 8 -16 -14 2lfo -is a -16 -re3pj:6i-ri7i:-i-€] ri by.....

Full Judgment

IN rmE HIGII count oF KERAIA AT ERNaKulnM PRESENT "E HONOURABIE ld RS. JUSTICE M.R.ANITEIA TEluRsmr, TRE 6" mr oF ocro BER 2022 / 14" Aswl RA, 1944 RSA NO. 272 0F 2018 Ai GZLINST THE JtJz}®n NT IN as 67/2ol2 oF SUB oc)URT, Kh RIJNZ`lGhppAniT os 558/igg8 oF MUNsl FF cou RT, Iro TTARAKKARA App EIIANIS/ADI)L.AppElnANTs IN A.s. 6 IR's oF pl AINTIFF IN gulp:

SUJATm D/0. BHANUMa THI Am4a, AGED 52, RAT BHAVAN, MalooR p,O. , pATHaieApu RAM, Now REslDINc ziT pERtJRATTu vEEDu, vE!ia AR m7RI , WTHOOR vlLlj RE , roTTARasoGn RA, ro LI", plN-691 507. G.S.SINE)HU @ RAOI S. SINDHU RED 30 YEARS D/o. su4ATHA, RAT BflAvnN, MalooR p.o. , pAmAiaAp(7RAM, KOLljM, Now REslDINc AT pERURATTu vEEDu, VENDAR rmml , PUTHOOR vlllAca , t©r.inFtAECEchRh, t©uj`b8, i.Ist-'6`9i 5`07 ` Fr owe. SRI. T.ICRISHNa NUNNI (sR. ) SRI.ASHWIN SATHYANATH sum . H . R . hum SMI . REERA . A . `s RI .vl NOD RAvlroRAitATt] SRI.VINAY RATt EW JOSEPH

RESEroNDENTs/REsp ONI)ENTs Alto ADZ)L.REspONDENTs IN A.s. AND DEFENDANTs 1, 3 TO 6 a L.R`s OF DEm NDAIT ro.2 a 7 IN sulT=

*1 G.copnmTHz`N PILIAI (DIED] AGED 64 Y- s/O. covlNmN PILIAI, PERUKA,TTu PUREN v EEI]u, vENmR, PUTHOOR, ro TTARAKKARA, Ero LIAM, plN-691507. [IT Is REccro ED TinT TEE lsT REsporo ENT Expl RED As PER o RDEF` DATED 7.2.2022 IN MEMO DATED 01.10.2021 IN R.S.A.272/2018] a. RExsoas REI) 45 YEARS s/0. mNARDmiaA Eunup, pERI7KATTu PUTHEN vEEDu, VENDAR MURI , REDuv ATHOOR vl LIAGE , mco4 sREESHyl AM, MnNAlcKATTu m7RI , MyNAGzippAIEly vlLIAee, ro LIAM, plN-690 519. A. HAREfsH ICLmR :h:ffiD io yEaRs s/O. AppuKUTm LN plll AI , TREVAIAEURAM pANDIN4ARu Mtj RI , REI]uvATHc OR vll4AGE , IroTTARAKKh RA-691 5o6. a. NAFIAYANZI P114AI RED 8o yEas s/O. SANKARA PILIN , vAIAyANATTu vEEDu, vEro AR MURI , EurTElcoR vl LI.Aer ; roTTziRhfcKaRzi-691 5o7. a. sz\RADAMa NI DEvl REI) 75 YEARS D/O. BHAVENI jLrm, cHaeroI}Ay AM, NEEmsw ARAM MURI , KOTTARARECARA VIId AGE , Ito TTARAICKARA-691505.

R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 Irol RA BEN AGED 73 YEus w/O. BEIASKARAN -vI-rihds ita,IR, sAJu Emv:EN, , 'rdb-riaEtaiaini`i-6-9`i 5@j .. THEKKUMpu RAM MURI , PUTHOOR

sA4uKUMm AGED 48 YEARS s/O. BIIASKARAN NzilR, sA4u BHAVAN, THEECEcuncam AM Mi7RI , p(7THOOR vlLiAes , roTTARAKKh RA-691 507. 814uHuMan RED 43 YEARS a/O. BHASKARAN it AIR, sAJtJ BHAVAN, THEREanmi RAM m]RI , Eu"c OR VIIJIJRE , KOTTARAICKARA-691507. 3HX2L AGED 43 YEARS w/o. HAREESH KUMnR, PARACEcal. VEEI)u, THEVAIAppuRzo4 REST, is-D-tjvini-Eta -v-I-riaae , -ri6EiriRri HRA-6-9-1 5-06 . 10 sREEm RI oil NOR) AGED 15 YElus s/O. HAREESHeaiMaR & 4AyA, pARACKaL vEEDu, Tm=vAiAppu RAM PEST, NEDuv ATHUR vlnAer , KOTTARAKKARA-691 5o6, f GPRESENTED 8¥ Hls ro TRER Aiili a IARI>IAN dAyA (REsrotil]ENT NO. 9) . 11 mJRa!m RI (MlroR) RED 15 YEARS a/o. ELREEsl]KUMaR a 4zi TA, PARACKAL vEEDu, THEVAIAppuRIo4 west, REI}uv ATHUR vl LIACH= , EcoTTARAKKa RA-6915o6, REPRESENTED BT I]IS COTHER AND Gti ARDIAN JAVA (RE§POREENT NO. 9) . 12 srv AHARI (MINOR) REli 11 yEas s/O. ELasEE8Hla"aR & dAyA, paRnc KZLI, vEEDu, TREvalapHm AM REST, REDtrv ATHUR vlLlj RE , roTTARAic KARA-691 506, REPR=s ENTED EIf Hls MOTlnR Alto Gnla RDIAN JAYA (FGSPONDENT NO.9) . 13 GIREESH KUMhR AGED 49 YEARS §/6 ` -EaRa5-ri± ibaah, biRaaizaL -v==b-a , ii-riE-vifeE>-tfaaira -fa§E , RED!rvATrmiR vllAncE , roTlaRAKEGn RA-691 5o6. 14 SFUEE- AGEI) 55 YEARS D/O. BARATHI AIOuA, I)ARACKAL VEEDU, TREVAIAPPURAM REST, REI)UVATHUR VILIAGE , Ec OTTARZIKKARA-691 506.

[APEq=IIJ`iiT NO. 1 , K. BHAen]Ma LTEI Ab04k DIEI> pEimneG Tin AppEnL Alro HER L.R'S WERE IMPLEAI)ED AS ADDL. APPELENTS 2 & 3 WHO ARE THE APPELLANTS IN THIS R.S.A. I [Eurspo NI)ENT No.2, M. BHASKARAN it AIR AND REsporo ENT No.7, K.BHARATHI AB04A DIED PENDING THE APPEAL AND THEIR I..R. 'S WERE I-riip-IErii}i@ i§ iEii>-I„ -k=§-b6fo=-riis 8 -16 -14 2Lfo -is a -16 -RE3pj:6i-ri7i:-I-€] RI BY ADV SRI.CHORE VARGHE5EPELku MP ijctjl:II¥II. SRI.A.R.DIId=Ep (er`v EATOR)

TEIIs REcul AR sEcroro App EAI. HAVING COME up roR ADMlssloN ON o6.io.2022, AnoriG wl TH Rsa.277/2018, -440/2018, Tin cou RT CIN TED saEd= Dz`r I)ELlv ERED THE FOLrm ING: R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 IN THE I]IGH COURT OF KERAIA AT ERNZLKul AM PRESENT TIRE HONOURABLE MRS. Jt JBTIC= M.R.ANITEIA TH`)R§DAr, "E 6" in:ir oF OCTOBER 2022 / 14TII ASwnm, 1944 RSA NO. 277 0F 2018 AGAINST THE ruDen NT IN As 6/2oi2 a A.s.Na.39/2oi3 oF SUB crot]RT, KAF`ina AGAPE>AILy os 5o6/igg8 oF m7Nslrr count, roTrARAKKa RA

AppELLANTs/ADI>I..App EIIANT ro.2 AND Fq=sEroNDENIs 5, 6 IN A.s.NO.6/2oi2 & AppELIANTs IN A.s.No.39/2oi3 AND DEFTNDANTs 3 ro 5 IN sulT. :

8UJAm D/O. BHANUMa THI Am4A, AGED 48, Ft AO SHAVEN, MALc OR p.0., pATHANApu RAM, Now REsl DING AT p ERI]KhTTu vEEDu, vENDziR mml , PUTHc OR VILIAGE , KOTTARAKEGARA, KOLIAM, PIN-69I 507. G.a.SINI)HU @ RZLJI a. SINDHU REi) 28 ¥Eng D/O. sud ATHA, RAT BHAVEN, MalooR p.o. , pATHANZLpu RAM, ro LLZIN, Ncw REsl DING AT pEFujRATTu vEEDu, vEro AR Dn]RI , puTHc OR vl LIAGE , KOTTAF!AKEca RA, rol4[EN, plN-6915o7. sc»4aRAdaN RAIR AGED 50 YEARS roLlj IN, Ncw REsl DING AT pERVIRATTu veEDu, ve NDAR M`ml , puTHooR VIIAAGE, KOTTARAICKARA, KOLIAM, PIN-691507. EFT ADVS. SRI.I.KRISHNANUNNI (SR.) SRI .asHwlN sATHTAi&ATH an.ut.a,tlllstI SMT . REERA . A . SRI .vl NOD RAvlNDFLm TH SRI .VIltz`Y RATREW .OSEPH

REspONDENTs/REspONDENTs 1 ro 3 IN A.a.NO.39/2013 AND NOT pARTIEs IN A.§.ro.6/2oi2 AND REspoNDENIs 1, 2 AND 4 ro 11 IN A.s.No.39/2oi3 AND plAniTIFFs AND eeoT ah RTI=s IN sulT:

VENDAR sREErc RISHNA s"AII KSHETHRAM CHARITABLE TFtt7sT vEro AR, ro"c OR, EcOTTARARIca RA TAm7!c, ron AM, plN-691 5o7 , REPRESENTED BY ITS E'RESENT SECRETARY G. COPIRATHAN PILIAI. *2 G.GOPINATEIAN PILIAI (DIED) RED 64 yEne s/O. covnm AN pl LIAI, AGED 64, pERI7IchTTt] RITEmN vEEDu, v ENI>AR, PUTHOOR, KOTTanAKKa RA, ro LI", plN-691 507. LIT Is REco RDEI) TELziT Tin 2ND REsporo ENT ExplFt ED As PER o RI>ER DpimD 7.2.zozz IEN bnMo DATED 1.1o.2o21 IRT R.s.A.277/2oi81.

R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 GopAIAKRlsEnaA pl LIAI AGED 54 TEas s/o. mmmls HRA PII.IAI, AerD 54, pERI7RATTu PUTREN vEEDu, vE;NDAR, pumooR, KOTTARA!cca RA, KOLI", E>IN-691 5o7 ,. Irol FIA BHAI AGED 74 YEARS w/o. BHASRARAN NzilR, sAiu BHAVAN, TREKKurfpu RAM ifl7RI , p{7mooR SJ- vILIAes, roTTARAKKzi RA, ro LI", plN-691507.

AGED 49 YEARS s/0. BHASKaF`AN RAIR, sAJu BIt AVEN, THEKKL"puF`AM D«JRI , PUTHOOR vl LIAGE, roTTARAKKARa, roll.EN, plN-691 So7. BIduEaine j RED 44 YEus vlLIAee , Ero TTARAK]czLRa, ro14Ai4, plN-691 5o7. RAEIUL S. NZIIR RED 28 yEas S/0. SUJATf IA, PERIJKATTU VEEDU, VENDAR M(JRI , PU"OOR VILIAGE , KOTTARAKKa RA, KOLLAM, plN-691 5o7. sANEcaF`A plLml ACID 76 YEARS s/O. BHANum THI Arm, MENGAIATHu TREKKATI]II„ ARILEq KUNNEN, SASTHAMCOTTA-682 313. ENITm DEvl JRED 69 YE,us -D/6. -B-ri2ilfiindhi5`ril j]indA, a-ri=-Rijvi-riihii.-giv -wit:-I]`t} , ii-ritinE>fahabiri -to-Ri.`ri -p. 6. ,

EIAvun4THITTA, pATHAit AMTI]ITTA-689 625. 10 COPAIAKRISHNA PILIAI AGED 64 rEaRs (FATHER'S Nzllc NOT ENOEN TO TfE APPELENTS) , SREEVIIASAM, I©oNa¥II., pARzrvcroR p.o. , KOLI"-6913ol. R2 EFT revs SRI.GEORGE vj RERESE {pERUMPELltco TTI¥II.) 8RI.A.R.I)IIJ=EP (CAVEATOR)

THIS RECUIAR SECOND APPEAI. HAVING Cc OG UP FOR ADMISSION 0N 06.10.2022, AIJONG wl" Rszi.272/2ol8 Awl) R.`s.A.44o/2oi8, urn cou RT oN TEE .gab:u DnT DEI.IVERED THE roLlowl NG: R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 a 440 of 2018 IN TilE Hlc!I cOu RT OF RERAln AT ERNzilcul AM PREBENI TEE HONOu RABIE MRs. rusTIch= M.R.ANITHA TH`JRsm¥, THE 6m RAT oF OCTOBER 2022 / 14TII ASwn IA, 1944 RSA NO. 440 0F 2018 AGAINST "E ORDER/dul]®d=NI IN As 61/2012 OF SUB -CCORT, RARImz`GAppAILy Os 495/1998 OF in]Nsl FF cOu RT, KOTTARAKKARA .AppELIANrs/App EI,ENTs/pl.AINTIFF's_:

F`Arl s.8INI)Hu AGED 30 YEus -D/6 §`bja-rfu, -rds-I-D-I-give ij -ida -riir-wirfu , iin±ab-R -fo, -phE`riarihEtjRaba, roTTARAIOGaRa Ti AI.uK. Sud ATHA AGED 51 ¥EARs, I)/o BHANUMA"I Amm,REsl DING AT RAT BHAVEN, Mhl,OOR co, pATHANApu RAM, roTTARAICEch RA TELUK. EY ADVS. sum . MEERA . A . SRI .AsttwlN aATHyAit ATH ar . M . R . MIN I SRI .vl NOD RAvlNDRun TH SRI.VIRAY RATHEW JOSEPH

RERESEicoomtTs/REspchtDmtTs/DEREiu}Aiars:

BHANtj MATHI Arm, (DIED) (LEGnl. HEIR REc ORI]EI]) Ace ± en iEas, ®/o ica RTZIT:arx NI am¢fi,REslDEe¢G az HRtHcaflT{7 vEEDu, VENDAR MURI ,v ENDAF` Eo, PUTHooR Vln AGE , KOTTARAKKARa, PIN-691507 . (IT IS RECORDED THZIT RESPONI)ENT NO.1 DIED ANI) APPELENT NO.2 IS TErn ld3GaL HEIR OF I>ECEASED isT REsp ONDENT As PER ORDER I)ATED 07.02.2022 VII)I MEMO DATED 18.12.2021.) B!msacaRa±l alalR fDIEz)] {LEanL HElz5 REcoztD5z)} AGED 71 YEARS, a/O KESAVA PILIAI, RESIDING AT SAa JU BHALVEN`, TH=Ioc[rEng RAM ea7RI I, ptrTIIooR Po-, KOTTARA!ocaRa,I, plw-6915o7 `. Gop INATHA pln AI, (Dlm -REco REEI]) AcaD 72 yEARs, s/O covlNnA pl LIAI, REsl DING AT RERUKATTu ro TREN vEEDu, vENn AR MURI , PUTHOOR vll AACH= ,KOTTARAKKARA-691507. (I.I I.s .RE®Rz)=D .TIIa:T `mzE See `RE.SPo±®=alT EXPIRED ®ai 2®.`0€.2021 As PER ORDER DATED 06.10.2022 VIDE MEMO DATED 01.10.2021.) IeiDIRa BHal [DIEI> I iRs REc OREED] Aesl) 77 TEARs, w/o BHASKz\Raei i IAIR, sAru BHAVAN, THEKEcupu RAM MURI , PUTHOOR pO, roTTARAREczi RA, plN-691 507. sAru raJMaR, (sTRI7cK OFF) AesD Si ¥EARs, s/a BHAszi=a REN RAIR, sAL7tJ SHAVEN, TREKKup(RAM eou RI , PUTHooR po, roTTARAKKARIi, plN-6915o7.

R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 BIru KLmaR, (`sTRucK OFny AGED 46 YEARS, S/O BHASRARAN laalR, sAru BHA:VAN, THEKKUEru RAM MURI , PUTHOOR PO, KOTTARAKKARA, PIN-691507.

IT Is EEc ORDED TEIAg R2 A)D RA DIED AID TZHIR IEa AL HEIRs ARE AIREADy IN THE pARTy ARRAy As REsporil>ENTs 5 AND 6 As PER THE QBI)ER DAED Q6.I.a.2o22 ni iniso DanD ia.i2.2o2|.) 'p EHI "zil4Es CTF RESEEcri"-uE-iETs 5 AHD 6 ARE sTEalcac OFF zn TRE RzsK oF THE APPELli ENTS AS PER ORDER DATED 17.06.2022 IN IA.2/2022. ail-D-I..Rj aaii5-ria b=-vI , {sE-give-k 6EE`i D/o.IAm BIIAN(mTzll Am4A, .IGh RTHIRA. , MaitiihN NaGiaR p . o . , PEFtt7Mpul.IREAI. , PANDAIAM, pATHANAnor HITTA DlsTRlcT , plN-683 52o . ADDL. Re SHABVKARZL plLml , (sTRI7cK OFF) a/o. Ram BHANun"I Anon, mNcal ATH THERETf]IL,Ayl KANAM,sHASTHAMFro TTA p.O. ,ro LIEN, plN-69o 521. ADDL. R9 REMrA, (s TRI}c:K OFF) RED 35,D/o.IAH ooaalAmlszINa, pll.IAI, {soN oF "zE lam BHANUMLTHI Ai04A) , .SREE vll ASAM. ,rcooNAyll, p.o. , pizLRavcoR,ro LI", PIN-691302. ADDL,Rio RESHMa, (sTRuclt off) AGEI) 32,D/0.IATE GOPAIAKRISHNA PILIAI, (SON OF THE IATE E]-riamj]ai'ni abaa`i , I. 3-RES -vi-Lin`. ,-*cO'±iili-yI`L p .a . , pnRz`vooR, ro LEN, plH-69i 3o2 . ADDI..Rll RAGINI, (STRUCK OFF) AesD 3o,D/O.THE in:TE cOpAIArmlsi INA pl LIAI, (son OF THE IATE Bf IANUIA"I Ab04A) ' SREE VIIASAM' , Kc ORAYII. P.O. ,PARavcoR,KOL",plN-691 `(taesrmm±ii`g§ 3o2-OFF 7 `TO 11 a RE .g`mu`cK . rma TRE pj`z`:giv aRRay as e±R

ORDER DA"D 06.10.2022 IN IA.3/2022.)

(TEE IEGAL HEIRs OF I)ECEASED lsT REsp ONI>ENT ARE n4pl.EAI]EI> As ADl)ITIONAL R7 TO Rll AS PER 0EOER DATED 10.03.2022 IN IA..2/.202|.-) ADDI.. Ri 2 RA)orofnN AGBI) 62 ¥Ejdas §/o. covnm AN HAIR, pR=s ENT PRESIDENT oF VENDAR sREEKRlsHNAsnarmr KSHETHRAM CHARITABIE TRUST,RESIDING AT 'SENTHIM' ,VENDAR p.o. ,roTTARAlc KARA, plN-691 5o7 . {ADDZ7,R12 I.S IMPLEAD=D AS PER ORDER Dj!RED 17.06.2®22 IN IA.1/2022 . ) R3 Blr AI)vs. SRI. cd=oF{ca VARCHESE |p ERI]MPAI.I.IIcu TTI¥II,) g RI .A. R . DIIJ3EP R12 8¥ ADv.SRI.A.R.DImEp

THls REcul AR sEc OND App EAL HAVING ccha up FioR ADMlssloN ON o6.io.2o22, Alo NG wl TH RSA.272/2oi8 a R.s.A.277/2oi8, TEE cou RT oN THE SAID I)Ag I)ELlv ERED THE FOLliow ING: R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 ccmorm .JI]D@fl HT [RSA Nos.272/2018, 277/2018, 440/2018]

R.S.A.No.272/2018 has been filed against the judgment

in A.S.No.67/2012 on the files of Subordinate Judge's Court, Karunagappally, which arose out of the judgment in 0.S.No.558/1998 on the files of Munsiffs Court, Kottarakkara.

2. R.S.A.No.277 has been filed against the judgment and

decree in A.S.No.6/2012 and A.S.No.39/2013 on the files of Subordinate ]udge's Court, Karunagappally, which were filed against the judgment and decree in O.S.No.506/1998 on the Lfiles of Munsiff s Court, Kottarakkara.

3. R.S.A.No.440/2018 has been directed against the

judgment in A.S.No.61/2012 on the files of Subordinate Judge's

Court, Karunagappa]]y which in turn arose out of the judgment

and decree in O.S.No.495/1998 on the files of Munsiff s Court, Kottarakkara.

4. On 17.06.2022 when the above R.S.As were taken up, the leaned counsel for both sides submitted that the matters can be settled in mediation and accordingly the cases were R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 referred for mediation to Ernakufam Mediation Centre, {High Court Hall). The mediator filed report stating that the matter has been settled in mediation and a memorandum of agreement has also been forwarded.

5. Respondents 1 to 4 died pending this appeal. Additional respondents 7 to 11 are impleaded as the legal heirs of deceased first respondent. Respondent Nos.5 and 6 are recorded as the legal heirs Of deceased respondent Nas.2 and 4. Third respondent alleged to have been impleaded in this suit in

his capacity as the President Of Vendar Sreekrishrm Swami K§heth-fa-in `Cha-fitable Trust. He-nee, afte`r ni§ death, 12th additional respondent has been impleaded as the present President of the Trust. Subsequently, respondent Nos.5 to 11 were deleted from the party array.

6. The appellants in RSA No.440/2018 as well as the third

appellant in R.S.A.No.277/2018 as appelfants and the remaining 12th additional respondent in R.S.A.No.440/201`8 entered ino an amicable settlement and memorandum of agreement has been executed between then, R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018

7. On going through the memorandum of agreenen.t,

I am satisfied that all the terms of settlement are legal and proper and there is no impediment in recording the terms of settlement arrived at between the parties. Hence the memorandum of agreement executed between the parties is heredy recorded.

8. In the result, R.S.A.No.440#018 is allowed in terms with the memorandum of agreement. The memorandum of agreement as well as the sketch attached to it will form part of the decne.

9. In view of the mediation agreement,

R.S.A.Nos.272/2018 & 277/2018 are dismissed as withdrawn. AIl other pending I.As. are closed. Sd/- M.R.ENITm SHG JUDGE r- BEFORE TIIE HONOURABLE HIGH COURT 0F KERALA AT ERNAKULAM ELS_A Nos. 440 of 2018. 277 of 2018 & 272 of 2018 Raji S Sindhu & aflmrs : Appellants Vs. Bhanumathi Amma (Died) and others Respondents BEPORTSUBMITTEDBYTHEMEDIATQLR ADV. ZOHRA M.A. Mediated, matter is settled. a Settlement Agreement is attached herewith. Dated this the 20th day of July, 2022. AIdrzchra A \ ® Mediator Ernakulam Mediation Centre BEFORE THE HONOURABLE HIGH COURT 0F KEELA AT ERNAKULAM BSAJtes=44Q4£2fl±fl±zzj2£2Q±a&2z2rif_2018 Raji S Sindhu & Others Appellants Vs. Bhanumathi Amma (Died) and others : Respondents

MEMORANDUMOFAGREEMENTUNDERSECTI0N890FTHECODE0FCIVIL PROCEI)URE READ WI" RULES 24 & 25 0F THE CIVIL PROCEDURE tAljTERNATlvE Dlspu TE risoLUTIONt,RULEs, 2008: The real parties to the above thl.ee Appeals being 1. Raji.S.Sindhu @ G.S Sindhu, D/o.Sujatha, 2. Sujatha, D/o.Bhanumathiamma and 3. Somarajan Nair, S/o.Gopala Pillai and husband of Sujatha on the side of Appellants and Vendar Sreekrishna Swami Kshethram Charitable Trust represented by the

r present President G Ram Mohan, S/o. K.Govindan Nair who has been duly authorised by the Temple Trust to represent the Trust and to enter into compromise as regards the matter in dispute vide its resolution dated 17/10/20214gtl rdandhence y" poyifend hencethe thepatties pall:ieshave havenew newresolved resolvedto to settle settle their their disputes disputes on on the the following foil-o;i=; -qu 'qpr / L__.___ _ 1 .. .

`i... terms and conditions:

1. The actual dispute is pertaining to the fixation of boundary of the property of the

2ndAppel|antwithpropertydedicatedtotheTelnplefromthepropertybelongingto the Tharawad of the lst and 2nd Appellants. As per the partition deed No.56/1960 , 50 cents of property was earmarked for the temple and 82 cents was alloted to the predecessor-in-interest of the 2nd Appellant Raji.S.Sindhu. But on measurement the actual existing area is only 103.25 cents. Hence the parties by way of colnpromise ® have agreed, to have the extent of 71.25 cents and 32 cents respectively which is earmarked in the appended survey sketch. The 71.25 cents is shown in green shade and 32 cents is shown in red shade in the appended survey sketch. The same is situated in Survey No.399/4 formerly in Kulakkada village and now in Re-Survey No.152/11,17 in Puthoor Village of Kottarakkara Taluk, Kollam District. c¥ erala State M®diati nd conciliation centr. High Court of Kerala Kochi -682 ®31 ,,+ JtryLin,ti r,v J- -2-

2. The Appellants have agreed to withdraw the connected Appeals namely

RSA 277/2018 and RSA 272/2018 in view of the above settlement. The Appellants also agree that they have no further challenge against Exhibit 81 and 82 documents or against the Management and Administration formed as per Ext.82 dated 13/07/1998.

3. The Appellants have agreed to hand over possession of properties having an extent

9 cents in Survey No.410/18, 10 cents in Survey No.400/11 and 11 cents in Survey No.411/26 allotted to the temple as per partition deed No.56/1960 (Ext 81) now to the existing trust. They also agree that the trust can proceed against the persons in occupation and possession o.f 10 cents in Survey No.398/9 A and 14 cents in Survey No.410/17 allotted to the temple as per partition deed No.56/1960 for which they r) have no objection.

4. On the above allotment and agreed possession, the dispute between the both parties

are settled finally and amicably between them and they have no further dispute in this matter. Hence they have no objection in granting a decree in the said terms in RSA No.440 of 2018 and making the sketch a part of the decree. raLdy# -

1. 5ct`JiL 3 4.!,L ,L }!.i..- KeralaSlafeMe.14wu,ianaConcilialionCentri High Court of Kerala Koctli -682 031 -3- Hence it is humbly prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to recordthisagreementaspaltofthisHon'bleCourt'sJudgmentintheaboveappeals andgrantingadecreeinRSA440of2018intermsofthisSettlementAgreementin the interest of justice. Dated this the 20th day of July, 2022. Appellants

1. Raji S.Sindhu c?RT, A :sSou:aa:a:anNa[rfro-iz9,Lq, ~` ..rt\F,.`* S® ,

I ` .(,I Respondent /a :#`, I, , '` PIES , , ` + ` ,I ®. Sreekrishna Swami Kshethram Charitable iru=[ i-N. ; I,varst represented by the present President G Ram Mohan, VI-`L- N\rodQaNnch QOQIL^th k 'L,c3`hq A&%telte,\q`g r) Counsel for the Appellants Counsel for the Respondent rJo` \2- XeralaslaleMeL%andconc"ialio„entr. High Court of Kerala Kochj -682 031 9;.9faii _ \fo\\Q tt . +4ut _\froTh®®a.Hha`

9Vu:`L~#O~-@,"f#O,,ey„ ®qre.a _© -\2 . C]£ eq~9 C32.a C3ul LL) ® -28.8t n c7l.2SCLnt9J eulngJct6dy¢eralb8i\s.*uo:ct#„:nco,Cberm tod Sill.veyor .ffippt.?sO:rd#K# Pranovya Nivas R.S.A.Nos.272, 277 & 440 of 2018 APPEro IX R.S.A.NO.277/2018 APPEIIANTS ' ANNEXu RES : NII- REsroNDENTs. ANNExuREs : ANNEXURE 1: A TRUE COPY OF TRE 'CHARTH' ISSUED BY T[]E THENT[)RI ANNEXURE 2: PHOTOGRAPHS SIIOWING THE PRESENg STATE 0F 'THIDAPPAILY'

Continue Your Research


AI Briefs · Semantic Search · Save & annotate judgments

Start your 7-day free trial