Sukhlal and Sukhlal Jee Vs. State of Jharkhand and ors

Sukhlal and Sukhlal Jee vs State of Jharkhand and ors

Type Court Judgment Court Jharkhand Decided Aug 26, 2013

~1 min read

https://sooperkanoon.com/case/1024846

For advocates & juniors · 7-day free trial

Brief this judgment before chambers

Stop skimming 50 pages - get an 18-section AI Brief on this case, ask scoped follow-ups, and find related precedents with Semantic Search. Full trial, no card required.

18-section brief - facts, issues, ratio, relief
Ask this case - answers cite the judgment
Semantic search - find precedents by meaning
Research drawer - sections, cites, related cases

Citation: sooperkanoon.com/1024846
Court: Jharkhand High Court
Decided On: Aug 26, 2013
Subject: Education

Case Summary

AI-generated summary - not the official court judgment text.

Education

Key legal issue: Education

Parties & Advocates

Appellant / Petitioner

Sukhlal and Sukhlal Jee

Respondent

State of Jharkhand and ors

Excerpt

inthehighcourtofjharkhandatranchi w.p .(pil)no.2590of2012 sukhlal@sukhlaljee ... ... petitioner versus thestateofjharkhand&ors. ... ... respondents coram :honebletheactingchiefjustice :hon'blemr.justiceshreechandrashekhar forthepetitioner :mr.shabhakarmishra,advocate forthestate :mr.indrajitsinha,advocate th 12/dated:26 august,2013 perd.n.patel,a.c.j.1. this writ petition has been preferred challenging the tender issuedbythemunicipalcorporationofdhanbadvideadvertisement no.1057 dated 14th march, 2012 for collecting fees for vehicle parking.2. havingheardthecounselforboththesidesandlookingtothe averments made in this public interest litigation and the affidavit filedbytherespondents,itappearsthatthiswritpetitionhasbeen preferredchallengingthetenderissuedbythemunicipalcorporation ofdhanbadvideadvertisementno.1057dated14thmarch,2012.the saidtenderwasissuedforoneyear.thus,theperiodofoneyearhas already been over. moreover, learned counsel appearing for the petitionerisunabletoestablishthatthereisanencroachmentonthe footpathalso.thus,itappearstobeaprivateinterestlitigation.the action of the dhanbad municipal corporation appears to be for regulatingthetrafficjam,forwhich,systematicparkingisrequiredfor theplaceallotedforthesaidpurposeandtomanagethisaffair,token amountistobecollectedbythepersontowhomthecontractisgiven.3. weseenoreasontointerferewiththispublicinterestlitigation. thereisnosubstanceinthepublicinterestlitigation,andhence,itis herebydismissed. (d.n.patel,a.c.j.) (shreechandrashekhar,j.) manish/r.k.

Full Judgment

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFJHARKHANDATRANCHI W.P .(PIL)No.2590of2012 Sukhlal@SukhlalJee ... ... Petitioner Versus TheStateofJharkhand&Ors. ... ... Respondents CORAM :HONEBLETHEACTINGCHIEFJUSTICE :HON'BLEMR.JUSTICESHREECHANDRASHEKHAR ForthePetitioner :Mr.ShabhakarMishra,Advocate FortheState :Mr.IndrajitSinha,Advocate th 12/Dated:26 August,2013 PerD.N.Patel,A.C.J.

1. This writ petition has been preferred challenging the tender issuedbytheMunicipalCorporationofDhanbadvideAdvertisement No.1057 dated 14th March, 2012 for collecting fees for vehicle parking.

2. Havingheardthecounselforboththesidesandlookingtothe averments made in this Public Interest Litigation and the affidavit filedbytherespondents,itappearsthatthiswritpetitionhasbeen preferredchallengingthetenderissuedbytheMunicipalCorporation ofDhanbadvideAdvertisementNo.1057dated14thMarch,2012.The saidtenderwasissuedforoneyear.Thus,theperiodofoneyearhas already been over. Moreover, learned counsel appearing for the petitionerisunabletoestablishthatthereisanencroachmentonthe footpathalso.Thus,itappearstobeaPrivateInterestLitigation.The action of the Dhanbad Municipal Corporation appears to be for regulatingthetrafficjam,forwhich,systematicparkingisrequiredfor theplaceallotedforthesaidpurposeandtomanagethisaffair,token amountistobecollectedbythepersontowhomthecontractisgiven.

3. WeseenoreasontointerferewiththisPublicInterestLitigation. ThereisnosubstanceinthePublicInterestLitigation,andhence,itis herebydismissed. (D.N.Patel,A.C.J.) (ShreeChandrashekhar,J.) Manish/R.K.

Same Court & Year Jharkhand · 2013 Same Parties Sukhlal and Sukhlal Jee vs State of Jharkhand and ors Same Subject Education