Overruling - Judgment Search Results

S.P. Gupta Vs. President of India and ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1982SC149; 1981Supp(1)SCC87; [1982]2SCR365

..... majority opinion was that the plea of privilege should be overruled but although the categories mentioned above consisted of confidential documents ..... had no locus standi to file the appeal the objection was overruled by the disciplinary committee of the bar council of ..... that of the highest administrative authority having the power to overrule the opinion of any other authority from the specific roles .....

Florida Dhrs Vs. Florida Nursing Home Assn.

Court: US Supreme Court

..... has voted today consistently with his vote in edelman itself the arguments in favor of overruling edelman are appealing particularly because i share the opinion of justice brennan justice marshall and ..... the lower court s decision respondents requested that the court instead grant certiorari and consider overruling edelman see supplemental brief for respondent nursing homes 4 13 footnote 2 2 in 1972 .....

Firestone Tire and Rubber Co. Vs. Risjord

Court: US Supreme Court

..... 2d 377 1980 before considering the merits of the appeal the court reconsidered and overruled its prior decisions holding that orders denying disqualification motions were immediately appealable under 1291 ..... to address the standing issue footnote 15 two other courts of appeals that have overruled their precedent and held that orders denying disqualification motions are not immediately appealable have .....

Chandler Vs. Florida

Court: US Supreme Court

..... those utterly corrupted by press coverage there is no need to overrule a holding never made by the court footnote 9 brief ..... wholly unsuccessful effort to distinguish that decision i would now flatly overrule it while much was made in the various opinions in ..... criminal trial if the defendant objects so understood estes must be overruled to affirm the judgment below it is arguable however that estes .....

Donovan Vs. Dewey

Court: US Supreme Court

..... whether camara represented such a fundamental misreading of the fourth amendment that it should be overruled i would merely observe that that option is more viable today than when some of ..... restrictions that the fourth and fourteenth amendments place upon conventional searches the frank decision was overruled eight years later in camara v municipal court 387 u s 523 over the dissent .....

T.G. Srinivasa Murthy, Etc., Etc. Vs. Bharat Earth Movers Ltd. Etc., E ...

Court: Karnataka

Reported in: ILR1982KAR622; (1982)ILLJ268Kant

..... 14 15 16 and 311 is available the argument is therefore overruled applying the above ratio i hold that even though the impugned ..... within the meaning of art 311 this contention also must be overruled 30 in motiram deka s case supra once again the constitutional ..... law declared by the supreme court which has the effect of overruling such a binding decision the view expressed by dasgupta j irrespective .....

Sm. Nandarani Bose and anr. Vs. Ranchhoddas Muldas Ramanuj and anr.

Court: Kolkata

Reported in: AIR1981Cal275

..... the application on all its grounds by the order impugned he overruled the prayer made under section 36 of the act on the ..... a court lacking territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit was rightly overruled by the learned subordinate judge we keep it on record that ..... by the judgment debtors petitioners 11 for the reasons aforesaid we overrule the second contention raised by mr bhunia 12 as both the .....

Kundan Lal and anr. Vs. Hari Ram and ors.

Court: Delhi

Reported in: AIR1981Delhi144; 19(1981)DLT293; ILR1981Delhi619; 1981RLR290

..... air1957all561 3 11 now all the three authorities followed by the learned judge had been overruled in subsequent decisions it is unfortunate that later decisions overnuling them were not brought to ..... jagatjit distilling and allied industries supra rubabbai v assistant custodian evacuee property indore air1962mp38 was overruled by a division bench of madbya pradesh high court in union of india v ismail .....

Krishna Chandra Pramanik and ors. Vs. Hari Sadan Sahana and anr.

Court: Kolkata

Reported in: AIR1981Cal435,86CWN105

..... the pre emptor by upholding the contention of mr mukherjee and overruling that of mr roychowdhury 10 in the result the revisional ..... 000 along with consideration for the sale such a contention was overruled by the two courts below it was held that since ..... defence of the pre emptee should succeed and it was wrongly overruled by the courts below on this ground therefore the revisional application .....

Pritam Singh Gill Vs. State of Punjab and ors.

Court: Punjab and Haryana

Reported in: AIR1982P& H228

..... the nature of the writs of prohibition and certiorari stands virtually overruled and no longer holds the field with respect this assumption is ..... i am unable to see that this judgment in any way overrules or renders irrelevant the dictum of lord justice atkin in ..... er 66 supra and find nothing therein which in any manner overrules or wipes away lord justice atkin s celebrated observations in electricity .....