Court : Supreme Court of India
..... trial court, on 24.08.2017, allowed the application filed by the app after noting certain previous decisions of this court where it was held that if the evidence tendered in the course of trial shows that any person not named as an accused has a role to play in the commission of the offence, then he ..... while dismissing the petition, the high court noted that at the stage of section 482, the court is only supposed to see if there exists a prima-facie case. ..... having taken note of the provision, we will note the principles laid down by a constitution bench of this court in hardeep singh v. ..... at the outset, we may note that the four accused who were charge-sheeted, have passed away. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... observed that normalization of marks means increasing and/or decreasing the marks obtained by students in different timing sessions (shifts) to a certain number, as observed by the high court in its judgment, and it was noted that such normalization techniques help in comparing corresponding normalized values from two or more different data sets in a way that it eliminates the effects of the variation in the scale of the data sets, i.e. ..... therein, the learned judge noted that four categories of candidates emerged: (i) the newly qualified reservation category candidates for the main examination (2,721, in number), as per the result dated 10.10.2022; (ii) 1,918 select list candidates, who had ..... we may also note that the judgment in kishor choudhary (supra) was not subjected to challenge before this court after the dismissal of the ..... we may also note that rule 4(3)(d)(iii) of the rules of 2015 patently harmed the interests of the reservation category candidates, as even meritorious candidates from such categories, who had not availed any reservation benefit/relaxation, were to be ..... as already noted hereinabove, writ appeal no.2017 of 2023 was filed against the very same judgment by the mppsc before a division bench of the high court and the said appeal is ..... noting that courts would recognize that the process of selection involves a high degree of expertise and discretion and that it 2 2023 scc online sc34418 would not be appropriate for courts to substitute their judgment for that .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Karnataka
..... court committed an error in entertaining the petitioner at the instance of respondent no.1 therein challenging the tender conditions who had not participated in the tender process, at the outset, it is required to be noted that respondent no.1 claiming to be a non-profit organisation carrying out research, advisory and advocacy in the field of civil aviation had filed a writ petition challenging the tender conditions in the respective rfps. ..... judge to act as a superboard, or with the zeal of a 60 pedantic school master substitute its judgment for that of the administrator.7.9 when there is nothing on record of the present case, rather as noted above, the decision making process leading to incorporation of the condition of timeline of twenty one days for submission of bids underwent examination of the committee and also with due application of mind, only because the ..... (para18) 7.1 along with reply filed by the respondent-corporation, copy of the entire office note relating to tender and the board resolutions are produced, which reflect the decision making process undertaken on the part of the respondent and the considerations 55 which have ..... 6.3.1 it was viewed by the court, once the reasons are accorded and noting in the files discloses the application of mind, it would meet the test, in other words, if the order or the noting in the file would disclose that there is due application of mind by the superior authority for reducing the time stipulated under sub-rule (1), it would .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... opponents to the change report had contended that jagdishchandra was not the eldest son of mallikarjun mahalingappa patil, but the assistant charity commissioner noted that ashok mallikarjun patil, the eldest son, had died issueless and the second 9 son, satish, claimed no interest in the trust ..... before we proceed to consider the matter on merits, we may again note the fact that the act of 1950 was amended in 2017, whereby a proviso was added in section 22(1), providing for condonation of delay in the filing of a change report, if sufficient cause is ..... the change report was held to be legal and valid, taking note of the fact that no one had taken an objection thereto. ..... further, the assistant charity commissioner took note of the fact that the revision filed against the registration of the subject trust had been dismissed by the joint charity commissioner ..... the joint charity commissioner also noted that the revision applicants were not members of the family of mallikarjun mahalingappa patil and that their other revision, being revision application no.60 of 2017, challenging the order dated 17.06.1954 passed in inquiry application no.25 of ..... would be apposite at this stage to note the statutory scheme obtaining under the act of ..... therein, while noting that some of the devotees of the temple had filed objections to the said report, he ultimately held that the change report was legal ..... it may be noted that no such proviso was in existence at the time change report no.899 of 2015 was submitted .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... trial court vide order dated 01.09.2023 noted the compliance of the above order of this court. ..... appellant s wife was directed to deposit the amount before the trial court has already been dismissed, the trial court vide order dated 09.02.2021 refused to accept the demand draft presented by the appellant by noting that such an application is not maintainable.6. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... 8(3). any person aggrieved by the refusal of the reserve bank to pay the value of the notes under sub-section (2) may prefer an appeal to the central government within fourteen days of the communication of such refusal ..... him. the delinquent was advised to peruse, examine and take notes of the said documents/statements half an hour before the commencement of ..... allotted. if the allotment made of marks under various category is taken note of and if it is compared with the marks allotted to some of the wait-listed candidates certain disparities can ..... . the totality of the situation ought to be taken note of and if on examination of such totality, it comes to light that the executive action suffers from the vice of non compliance with the doctrine, the law courts in that event ought to set right the ..... the provision providing for appeal in section 8(3) of the high denomination bank notes (demonetisation) act, 1978 reads as under:- ..... impleaded. what is of importance to note is in para 9 of the memo of appeal, few of the selected candidates were named and ..... act, on the other hand, is not required under clause 3 to entertain all kinds of objections and it may even refuse to consider the objections mentioned earlier in view of the truncated scope of the hearing under clause 3(ii) as noted ..... . it may be noted at this juncture that in some cases it has been observed that where grant of opportunity in terms of principles of natural justice does not 55 improve the situation, useless formality theory can be pressed .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... per contra, learned counsel for the respondent no.3 submitted that at the time of filling up the descriptive roll, the same was based on an oral declaration and apparently the authority, which was noting down the date of birth, had committed an error. ..... pausing here, the court would note that by reckoning his date of birth as 12.03.1955, the respondent no.3 would be much below the age of 18 years at the time of initial employment, which was the minimum requirement in law. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... duty. this court noted that the aforesaid circular dated 12.07.1989 was withdrawn by the subsequent circular dated ..... act. after noting that there was no specific legal provision to determine the rate of duty in such cases of warehoused goods where the bond period had expired, it was concluded that the residual clause of section 15(1)(c) of the customs .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... jagannadha sastry submitted his inspection report dated 25th january, 2014 noting inter-alia that the purchase of machinery from m/s. ..... brief facts essential for adjudication of the present civil appeal are noted hereinbelow.3. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Supreme Court of India
..... of the individual and balance the same with interests of the state or investigative agency in prem shankar shukla v delhi administration, (1980) 3 scc526 in bhim singh, mla v state of jammu and kashmir, (1985) 4 scc677 this court noted that police officers are to exhibit greatest regard for personal liberty of citizens and restated the sentiment in sunil gupta v state of madhya pradesh, (1990) 3 scc119 the scenario in delhi judicial service association v state of gujarat ..... we hold back noting that justice ought to be tempered with mercy. ..... be it noted, the appellant has additionally received rs.25,000/- (rupees twenty five thousand only) as ordered by the commission. .....
Tag this Judgment!