Dis Proportionality - Judgment Search Results

Sri S.M. Honnappa S/O Mudlappa Gowda Vs. the Bangalore University, by ...

Court: Karnataka

Reported in: ILR2007KAR2414; 2007(6)KarLJ104; 2007(4)KCCRSN224; 2007(5)AIRKarR103

..... the appellate authority have committed a grave error and proceeded to impose the dis proportionate punishment to the petitioner which cannot be sustainable to substantiate his submission he ..... retirement that too without considering the documentary evidence proceeded to impose the punishment dis proportionately and that too without considering the explanation submitted by the petitioner nor taken .....

Khuman Singh Vs. State of Rajasthan and ors.

Court: Rajasthan

Reported in: 1997(3)WLC258; 1997(2)WLN153

..... to the gravity of charges the punishment of removal is not dis proportionate to the delinquency committed by the petitioner if the case ..... to explain that the punishment awarded to the petitioner is proportionate to the delinquency committed by him thus there is no ..... servant based upon a proved misconduct against government servant its proportionality also cannot be gone into by the court the only .....

GKN Sinter Metals Ltd. Vs. Ramapriya Raghavan, Assistant Commissioner ...

Court: Mumbai

..... year 2004 05 indicating that the allocation of expenditure amongst the three manufacturing units was dis proportionate having regard to its turn over resulting in excessive allocation of expenditure to non ..... sought for were furnished and it is now observed that there has been a dis proportionate distribution of expenses between various units belonging to the petitioner for claiming deduction under .....

Pancham Giri Vs. State of U.P. and ors.

Court: Allahabad

..... with accordingly 6 in appeal the petitioner raised several grounds including the ground of dis proportionality of the punishment and all other grounds which had been raised before the disciplinary ..... been clearly found to have committed a misconduct and therefore the punishment is not dis proportionate it is submitted that the petitioner has voluntarily entered into the second marriage and .....

Yash Paul Vs. Union of India (Uoi)

Court: Jammu and Kashmir

Reported in: 2004(2)JKJ401

..... also been challenged on the ground that the same is dis proportionate to the offence alleged to be committed by the petitioner ..... the punishment imposed upon the petitioner is too harsh and dis proportionate it is admitted fact that the petitioner over stayed for ..... punishment of dismissal from service appears to be harsh and dis proportionate to the offence said to be committed by the petitioner .....

Smt. Pushpa Devi Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court: Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Jodhpur

..... also arbitrary and illegal the alleged order of removal passed by the disciplinary authority was dis proportionate to the alleged mis conduct of the husband of the applicant and consequently these two ..... unauthorised absence from duty for about six months removing the delinquent from service is quite dis proportionate to the mis conduct for which he was charged when the punishment as awarded to .....

Secretary to Government of Madras and Another Vs. P.R. Sriramulu and A ...

Court: Supreme Court of India

Reported in: AIR1996SC767; I(1996)BC286(SC); 1996(1)CTC235; JT1995(8)SC305; 1995(6)SCALE589; (1996)1SCC345; [1995]Supp5SCR551; 1996(1)LC612(SC)

..... and the levy imposing as it does on a particular section of litigants is grossly dis proportionate part of the burden and the same is unreasonable and arbitrary the expenditure incurred by ..... the levy at the aforesaid rate imposing on a particular section of litigants is grossly dis proportionate part of the burden and therefore deserves to be struck down being unreasonable and arbitrary .....

The Registrar, High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad ...

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: 2008(1)ALLMR879; 2007(6)BomCR827; 2008(2)MhLj914

..... and reprehensible that a sentence of fine would be wholly dis proportionate to its gravity to put it differently a sentence of ..... gross and reprehensible that sentence of punishment would be held dis proportionate to its gravity to put it differently a sentence of ..... preferred to submit representation dated 30th august 2006 thereby expressing dis faith no confidence as meeting was scheduled on 31st august .....

Sri K. P. Narayanan Kutty Vs. The State Bank of India

Court: Karnataka

..... 09 2004 it is also contended that the penalty is harsh and dis proportionate to the charges levelled against the petitioner 35 24 we have ..... the above we do not wish to dilate on the aspect of proportionality of punishment as the order of dismissal with effect from 28 ..... of india officers service rules1992i refer to the charge sheet bearing no dis con 98 dated 19 02 88 and the inquiry ordered into .....

K.P. Narayanan Kutty Vs. The State Bank of India and Others

Court: Karnataka

..... 09 2004 it is also contended that the penalty is harsh and dis proportionate to the charges levelled against the petitioner 24 we have perused ..... the above we do not wish to dilate on the aspect of proportionality of punishment as the order of dismissal with effect from 28 ..... findings of the inquiring authority were furnished to you under letter no dis con 16 458 dated 30 04 03 i have carefully perused .....