Mumbai Court July 1959 Judgments

Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay City Vs. Phirozshaw Pallonji Mistry ...

Court: Mumbai

Reported in: (1959)61BOMLR1342; [1959]36ITR582(Bom)

Shah, J.(1) The assessment years in this reference are 1949-50 and 1950-51. Phirozshaw Pallonji Mistry and Shapurji Mistry are the two assessees. Their respective wives held shares in a private limited company styled Shapurji Pallonji and Co. Ltd. An order under Section 23A of the Income-tax Acdt was passed by the Income-tax Officer in making the assessment of Shapurji Pallonji and Co. Ltd., and the income deemed to have been distributed as dividend under Sec.23A in the hands of the respective wives of the two assessees was sought to be included in the income of the two assessees relying upon Section 16(3) of the Income-tax Act on the ground that the shares in the company held by the respective wives were purchased with the funds provided by the two assessees. It was contended by the assessees that where an order under S. 23A is passed the dividend income is only deemed to have been distributed amongst the share-holders and such income cannot be included in the income of the assessees ...