Union of India and Anr. Vs. Lt Col P.K. Choudhary and Ors.

Decided On : Feb-15-2016

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Section 31, Section 31, Officers, the Commissioning Officers, Article 14 of the Constitution, the Commanding Officers

ORG: THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL, ANR, COL, ANR, COL, ANR, COL, FARAN SIDIQUI & ORS, the Armed Forces Tribunal Act, the Armed Forces Tribunal, Original Application, Respondents, the Government of India, the Appellant-Union of India, Respondents, Respondents, Tribunal, Respondents, the Indian Army, the Indian Military Academy, Arms, Arms Support or Services, Arms, Arms Support or Services, Respondents, Army Service Corps, AMC, Combat Arms or Arms Support, Army Service Corps, Original Application No.430, Tribunal, Post-Kargil War, the Government of India, Kargil Review Committee, Committee, the Indian Army, Combat Arms, Committee, the Ministry of Defence (Finance, Army Headquarters, Ministry of Defence, the Indian Army, Adjutant General, Army Headquarters, Naval Headquarters, Committee, Committee, Navy, the Air Force, Committee, Committee, Government, the Indian Army, Colonels the Committee, Brigadiers the Committee, Committee, Army, Committee, the AVS Committee, Government, Commanding Officers, Government, Arms and Arms Support, ASC, AOC, EME, Arms, Arms Support and Services, Army, the Government of India, Army, the Armed Forces Tribunal, Government, the Government of India, Special Boards, the Union of India, Arms and Arms Support Units, The Appellant-Union of India, the AVS Committee, the Arms and Arms Support, the Government of India, the AVS Committee, the “Command Exit Model, the Armed Forces Tribunal, Government of India, the Government of India, the Armed Forces Tribunal Act, Tribunal, the AV Singh Committee, the AV Singh Committee, the Central Government, Arms, Arms Support and Services, the Indian Army, Government, Arms, Arms Support and Services, the AVS Committee, Army, AVS Committee, Arms Support and Services, the Appellant-Union of India, the AVS Committee, AOC, EME, the Committee, Committee, Committee, Army, Commanding, Committee, Arms, Arms Support and Services, Committee, Committee, Committee, the Army Headquarters Paper, Army Headquarters, Short Service Commission Officers, Battalion and Brigade Commanders, Sub Unit Commanders, Brigadier’s, Brigadier, Committee, the Kargil Review Committee, Committee, the Indian Army, Committee, Brigade, Battalion Commanders, Committee, Battalion Commanders, Indian Army Officers, Chinese Armies, The Committee, Combat Arms, Committee, the Indian Army, Committee, Arms and Services, Units, the Unit Commanders, Committee, |Arm/Service, |1038, |179, |2, |Total, Committee, Armoured Corps, Infantry, Field Artillery, Signals, Committee, Committee, the Unit Commanders, Committee, Armoured Corps, Infantry, Field Artillery, Signals, Emphasis, Committee, Committee, Arms, Brigadier, Committee, Committee, Committee, Armoured Corps, Infantry, Engineers and Signals and Brigadiers, Armoured Corps, Infantry, Engineers and Signals and Brigadiers, Colonels, AOC, EME, Minor Corps, |General, |17, |20 |42 |354 | |- | |- | |-, |25 |47 |225, |26, |30, |33, Emphasis, Committee, Army Headquarters, Government, Peel Factor, Committee, Committee, Unit Commanders, Committee, Armoured Corps, Infantry, Engineers, ASC, AOC, EME, Minor Corps, Colonels, AOC, EME, Minor Corps, Minor Corps, Unit Commanders, AOC, EME, Committee, AOC, EME Officers, the AV Singh Committee, Tribunal, AV Singh Committee, the Central Government, Government, the Army Headquarters to Arms, Arms Support and Services, Government, the “Command Exit Model, Government of India, Government, Committee, the “Command Exit Model, Reliance, Reliance, Government, Court, Government, the “Command Exit Model, AV Singh Committee, the AVS Committee, Government, Committee, Government, Government, Government, the Army Headquarters, Arms/Arms Support, Committee, Commanding Officers, Government, Government, Committee, Government, Army Headquarters, Committee, Government, the Command Exit Model, Government, Army Headquarters, Government, the AVS Committee, Government, Government, Committee, Government, Government, Arms or Arms Support, Government, Command Exit Model, |79 |17 |62, Engineers, Government, Government, Government, the Selection Board, Army, ASC, AOC & EME, Commanding Officers, Arms and Arms Support and Services, Court, Union of India, UOI, State of Bihar & Ors, Court, Directorate, Government, Directorate, Emphasis, Union of India and Others, Court, State of, U.P. & Ors, Bharat Singh & Ors, Army, Arms and Arms Support, Arms and Services, the Government of India, Reliance, Circular, Arms and Services, Arms and Arms Support, AV Singh Committee, the Indian Army, Army Ordnance Corps, Mechanical Engineers, Intelligence, Aviation, Minor Corps, Armoured Corps, Infantry, Artillery, Engineers, Signals, Army Service Corps, Army Ordnance Corps, AOC, Electronical, Mechanical Engineers, EME, Gentlemen Cadets, Commissioned Officers, The Defence Service Regulations, Regulations for the Army, First Appoinment, the Regular Army, Army, the Adjutant General’s Branch, Adjutant General’s Branch Circular, the Indian Military Academy, Arms/Services, the “Super Block, the Army/Service, Arms and Services, General Cadet, Super Block, Regiment/Battalion, Parental, Regt/Bn/Gp, GCs, Arms/Services, the Parachute Regiment, PARA, 10 &21, Para Battalion, Fd/Med/SATA/Msl Gps, GC, AD Arty, forArtillery, AAD, Armoured Corps, Mechanised Infantry, Infantry, Corps of Engrs, inter alia, Arms/Services, GC, Tribunal, Arms, Arms Support and Services, Union of India, Arms/Services, DRI, Services, Tribunal, Court, Combat Arms, Arms and Services, Combat Arms Support and Services, RA, under:“, the Kargil War Committee, AVS Committee, Combat Arms, Combat Arms, AVS, Combat Arms and Arms Support.38, the Selection Board, P K Chaudhary, ASC, Selection Board, Infantry, Selection Board, P K Chaudhary, Artillery and Infantry, P K Chaudhary, RA, Government of India, Army, Halsbury’s Laws of England, words:“81, Court, Food Corporation of India, Kamdhenu Cattle Feed Industries, Court, Court, Union of India, Hindustan Development Corporation and Ors, Court, Punjab Communications Ltd., Union of India and Ors, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Delhi Development Authority and Ors, Association v. Union of India, State of Bihar and Ors, Kalyanpur Cements Ltd., Energy Ltd. v. Union of India and Ors, Court, the Government of India, Combat Arms, Army, Combat Arms, Army, Regulations, Government, Government, Combat Arms, the Expert Committees, Committees, Combat Arms, Command Exit Model, unsettle, the Indian Army, Government, Government, Tribunal

PERSON: P.K. CHOUDHARY, CJI.1, Principal Bench, P.K. Choudhary, G.S. Dhillon, A.K. Pandey, R.M.S. Pundir, Ajay Chawla-Respondent No.5, Shri Ajay Vikram Singh, AVSC, Shri Ajay Vikram Singh, Air Headquarters, Generals, Principal Bench, Principal Bench, Meenakshi Lekhi, Maninder Singh, Singh, Lekhi, Cadre, Major, Colonels, Colonels, |132, |60 |2-3, Colonels, |21 |43 |354 | |-, |22 |44 |354 | |-, |23 |45 |225, |24 |46 |225, |31 |53 |225, |62 |21 | |35 |57, |21 | |37 |59 |- |- |-, |21 | |38 |60 |- |- |-, Peel Factor, |20 |05 |03, |75 |35 |, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, Singh, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, Command Exit, Maninder Singh, Maninder Singh, |tenure, Maninder Singh, Singh, Maninder Singh, AV Singh’s Committee, ’s Branch, K. S. Srinivasan, Chakradhar Paswan, M. Hara Bhupal, S. I. Rooplal, Merit, Volunteer, Armd Regt/, Mech Inf, Armd Regt/, Inf, Regts, Gazette, Chanchal Goyal, Anr, Monnet Ispat, Regulations, CJI, JOSEPH

GPE: T.S., New Delhi, New Delhi, New Delhi, Colonels, Pakistan, China, UK, Germany, Israel, Pakistan, Colonels, Colonels, Colonels, |31, Colonels, Delhi, Dehradun, SF, Bombay, DSR, Rajasthan, Singh v. State of Bihar, principles.46, T.S., New Delhi

DATE: 2007, 2nd March, 2015, 20th January, 2009, 2012, 41-42 years, 36-37 years, 44-45 years, 50-51 years, 51-52 years, 54-55 years, 55-56 years, 56-57 years, 1484, the first year, the second year, 1484, four years, 2004, 1484, 21st December, 2004, a period of, two years i.e., 2004-2005, November, 2008, five years, 2012, 2014, 2015, 29th January, 2009, 1484, 2nd March, 2015, 21st January, 2009, 2007, No.1 11, 1484, 23 years, the last year, the age of 50 years, the age of, 41-42 years, 44- 45 years of age, about 35 and 40 years, the age of, 36-37 years, 40 years of age, every year, Years, every year, every year, every year, each year, every year, Para 13, each|4857, the first two years, 1484, 5 years, |the 2nd year, annual, 1484, 1484, No.2 21, 22nd April, 2015, 22nd April, 2015, No.3 26, four years, two years, four years, four years, three years, four years, 2009, 3 years, 4 years, the year 2009, ten years, five years, the year 2009, the year 2009, that year, the year 2009, 5 years, No.4 30, 12th November, 1987, 1988, 31, 1997, 2000, 2011, 12th November, 1987, No.5 33, Para 63, August, 2006, Para 19(e, the age of 37 years, 2½ to 3 years, 1990, 1989, 1988, 1994, 2012, 1994, 3 in the year 2009 i.e., 2½ years, December 2012, the year 2009, Para 68, 1993, 43, 1993, 44, 1999, 2003, 2006, 2009, 2006, 2010, 2012, 1990, 3 years, the year 2009, 5 years, FEBRUARY15 2016

CARDINAL: four, five, one, 400, 300, two, 2008.6, 750, 734, 77, 147, three, three, 750, three, three, 750, 750, one, three, two, 406, |50, |97, 16, 354, 406, 354, one, more than one, 17, 374, 143, 354, 129, approximately 143, 31, 241, 374, 143, 354, 129, 17, 19, 18, 36, 36, 13, 19, 700, five, 20, 750, 750, One, 734, 734, two, 750, 734, 734, 750, two-fold, 734, two, 734, one, 2, 3, II, 734, 29, 141, 141, 141, No.3, one, two, 2, two, 3, 1, two, four, one, one, No.4, No.4, 11, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8), 9, 10, 11, three, 34, 11, 11, 25, 35, one, three, three, only one, three, five, 1,2,3,4,9, 10+2, three, 35, 30, three, 26, 2, only one, 26, 30, 2, 30, 0, 70, 37, No.3, 39, 151, 41, 1 SCC71one, 3, 33, 4, 3, 8, 1, 8, 3, 11, 64, 45, two, 68, 0, 2-1/2, 141, 2014.49

WORK_OF_ART: the Officers’ Cadre of the Army, the Officers’ Cadre of the Army, Arms, Arms Support and Services, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Arms and Arms Support Units, Arms and Arms Support, Command Exit Model, Arms Support on “Command Exit Model, No.4, Arms and Arms Support, Arms, Arms Support and Services, |2202 |1484 |400 |300 | 20, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model”.25, Command Exit Model, Command Exit Model, Arms Support, Arms and Arms Support, Arms and Arms Support, Arms and Arms Support, SCC644 this Court, Maths and Physics, Fourth Edition, Volume I(I, Wednesbury

PRODUCT: Report, |2-3, |32 |54, |75, |10 |08, the AV Singh Committee.22, Question No.2, |24, Arms Support, No.1, Para 68

FAC: the Officers Cadre, the Line of Control, the Fourth Pay Commission, Legitimate Expectation

ORDINAL: first, second, 3rd, 2nd, first, first, second, first, second, first, first, first, second, first, second, first, second, second, first, first, second, second, second, first, second, first, first, 2nd, second, second, first, first, second, second, second, second, first, first, first, 4th, first, second, 3rd, first, 2nd, first, first, Firstly

LOC: the Arms Support and Service Corps, Arms Support

NORP: |2, |2, |General, |38, |2025, |General, |General, |496

MONEY: |18 |40 |354 | |- | |- | |-

QUANTITY: |29 |51 |225, 0-1-2

PERCENT: 1%, 20%, 20%