Subhash Chandra and ors. Vs. State of U.P. and ors.

Decided On : Mar-17-2004

Court : Allahabad

LAW: Article 226, Constitution of India, Paras 5 to 20, Chapter III, Paras 14 to, Article 233 of the Constitution and the Rules, Article 233(2, Rule 5 and Rule 18, Article 233(2, Article 233, Constitution of India, Article 309, Article 233 of the constitution):PART II-CADRE5, Rule 5, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Constitution, Para 6, Article 233, Constitution, Article 233, Constitution of India, Article 233(2, the Rules 5, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233(2, Rule 5, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Rule 34, Chapter 143, Paras 37-18, Rule 34, Article 233(2, Article 124 of the Constitution, Article 217, Constitution, Article 233, Article 233, Article 233, Article 233, Article 233(2, Constitution, Paras 16, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Article 236, Constitution, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233, Article 233, Article 233, Article 233(2, Article 236(b, Article 233(2, Article 234, Article 233, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, the Constitution, Judgment, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233(2) Constitution, Article 233, Article 233, Article 233(2).(4, Article 136 of the Constitution, Article 233, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Constitution, Article 233(2, Article 233(2, Article 233, Constitution, Article 233, Chapter 22, Rule 6, Article 233...........'91, the Industrial Disputes Act, Section 7A of Industrial Disputes Act, Article 217, Article 233(2, Article 217(2, Constitution, Article 217(2, Constitution, Article 217, Article 217(2, Chapter 143, Article 233(2, the Rule 18(4, Article 233(1, Article 14.'138, Constitution

PERSON: A.K. Yog, Abdul Quaiyum, Narendra Kumar Singh, Registrar, Misc, Subhash Chandra, Abdul Quaiyum, Narendra Kumar Singh, de novo, Sri P.K. Goel, Joint Registrar, Nyayik Sewa, Narendra Kumar Singh, State,13, ineligible.14, Nyayik Sewa, Backward Classes, India.(2, H. J. S. Exam, Gopal Krushna Rath v. M. A. A. Baig, P. Mahendran v. State, Sri Sudhir Agarwal, Sri Sudhir Agarwal, Anr, Mubarak Mazdoor v., K.K. Banerjee, Bangalore, Anr, D. P. Sharma, Anr, Pleader, I. Whether, Krishna Iyer, S. Gopal Reddy v. State of A.P., lien, O.No, O.M., Rameshwar Dayal, Articles 124, Chandra Mohan v. State, Chandra Mohan v. State, Rameshwar Dayal, H.M. Seervai, IIIrd Edition, Articles, Chandra Mohan v. State, Chandra Mohan, Chandra Mohan, Satya Narain Singh, Lab IC, Gopi Nath, Civil Misc, Rameshwar Dayal, Chandra Mohan, Chandra Mohan, Sri Lal Narain Sinha, Sri K.K. Venugopal, S.K. Das, Narayan Singh, Application.71, V.N. Singh, J.78, A.K. Yog, Anr, Basant Lal Malhotra v. State of Punjab and Ors, Vol, Counsel, Narayan Singh, Sri S.P. Gupta, Chandra Mohan, Sri Dutta, Sri Dutta, Sri Dutta's, Narayan Singh, Narayan Singh, Rameshwar Dayal, Harbans Singh, P.R. Sawhney, Rameshwar Dayal, Sri Harbans Singh, Circular, Petitioners, Nos, Nos, Abdul Quaiyum, Narendra Kumar Singh, Chandra Mohan, Para 33, Articles 14, Articles 14, (5)..........................................'134, Articles 14, E.P. Royappa v. State, Maneka Gandhi v. Union, Articles 14

NORP: J.1, Hon'ble, Hon'ble, Hon'ble, Hon'ble, Hon'ble, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Punjab, Hon'ble

GPE: Chandra, Newspaper, H.J.S. Examination, District Judges, District Judges, P.C.S., Bihar, question.12, the State of Jharkhand, India, District Judges, U.P., States, Jharkhand, Bihar, Karnataka, India, context.39, India, H.J.S., general.64, States, India, Explanations, District Judges, Clause, India, District Judges, Singh, India, Satya, India, Satya, Counsel, District Judges, Clause, Satya, Satya, District Judges, Division Beach, Subordinate, Satya, Clause, Horizon Union, India, India, District Judges, Satya, Satya, District Judges, India, and(a, India, Jharkhand, States

CARDINAL: four, 2, 14.1.2001, three, 2, 14.1.2002, 6, three, 5, two, 2, 9 to 13, 385, one, 17, one, two, two, two, 1, 233, 7.0%(iii, half, half, 85, less than three, 16, 38, 19, 8, 1, 10, 1.1.2001.(3, 1.1.1959, 1.1.1966, 16.8.2000, 2, 1.1.2001.BROCHURE, 20, 6700, 16, 17, 3, 17, 22, 17(2, 18, 5(a, 1, 7, 6, 1, 416, 5).'5, two, one, 233(2, two, 17, 1975.40, 323, 45, 5(2)(a, 54, 1, 4, 6f, 2, 155, two, 23.6.2001, 6.6.2001, 34, 3(2, 15, 15, more than six, 5, 6, 1, 17-20, 16/2/1968, 1, 3, 2, 124, 217, 2, 217, 1, 2, about two, 18, 5 JJ, 2002(3, 3-JJ, 26.8, two, two, 162, 8642, 6, 594, 594, 2, 2, 3, 1, 528, 6346-6351, 548, 3, two, two, 822, 1, 2, one, 1, 2, 233, 1, 2, 178, 1, 6, 7, two, 5(a, 594, 2, 3, 3, 1965.94, 2, 100, 2, two, 102, 1, 2, 3, 18(1, 16, 18(1, two, two, 2,3, 4, 2, 3, 18(3, 18(4, 16, two, two, 16, 487, 130, two, 16

ORG: U.P. Higher Judicial Service, Hon'ble Court, High Court, Allahabad, Court, Advocate, U.P. Nyayik Sewa, Administrative Judges, the Selection Committee, U.P. Nyayik Sewa, Registry, Court, Angad Prasad, the High Court, the High Court, High Court, Allahabad, the U.P. Public Service Commission, U.P. Nyayik Scwa, 'Full Court', the High Court, Suail Kumar Panwar/Rall No, Sri Pradeep Kumar/Roll No, Judicial Services, the State of Jharkhand, the Selection Committee, the Judicial Service, Additional District, Judicial Service, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, U.P. Higher Judicial Services, the High Court', H.J.S, Judicial Service', U.P. Higher Judicial Services Rules, State, State, the High Court, State, Advocate, the High Court, a City Civil Court, a Small Cause Court, Magistrate, Additional Sessions, Assistant Sessions Judge;(b, Judicial Service', the U.P. Higher Judicial Service, the Uttar Pradesh Nyayik Sewa, Additional Sessions Judges, Uttar Pradesh Nyayik Sewa, Uttar Pradesh Judicial Officers Service, Judicial Magistrates, Judicial Magistrates, Judicial Magistrates, Selection Committee, Judges of the Court, Selection Committee, Court, State, Court, Court, Bar, High Court, the High Court, Court, The Selection Committee, Committee, Selection Committee, Selection Committee, Court, the Selection Committee, the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service, Registrar, Allahabad, Candidates, the U.P. Higher Judicial Service, Court, the Higher Judicial Service, Advocate, Bar Council, State, Income Tax, Income Tax, Professional Misconduct or Contempt of Court, the State Bar Council, the High Court, the Supreme Court of India, Court, the Appellate Court, Revisional Court, Brochure, Court, U.P. Higher Judicial Service'23, Court, High Court, the Registrar General/Registrar, the High Court, Selection Committee, Committee, Brochure, Learned Counsel, Registry, Court, Advocate, Uttaranchal, High Court, Direct Recruitment, Advocate, the High Court, the University Grants Commission, Court, Court, Learned Counsel, Additional Advocate General, Bar, Advocate, U.P. Higher Judicial Services, Bar, Bar, Counsel for the Respondent, as--'an Advocate', Andhra Pradesh High Court, K. Naga Raja and Ors, Superintending Engineer, Irrigation Department, AIR 1987, AP 230 (FB, K. Naga Raja, Supreme Court, K. Naga Raja, Learned Counsel, the Rules/Advertisement, AIR 1958, Regional Transport Authority, AIR 1989, Court, Legislature, Civil and Sessions Judges--(i, the Uttar Pradesh Civil Service, Judicial Branch);(ii, Advocate, Aforesaid Rules 1953, High Court, U.P. Nyayik Sewa Examination, Bar, Court, Apex Court, Seaford Court Estates Ltd., Asher, Parliament, Parliament, Higher Judicial Service, U.P. Judicial Service Examination, the U.P. Public Service Commission, U.P. Higher Judicial Service, the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Service Rules, State, U.P. Nyayik Sewa, U.P. Judicial Service Rules, U.P. Government Servant Conduct Rules, Government, Head of Department, Government, Government, the Lok Seva Ayog, Uttar Pradesh, Union Public Service Commission and Public Service Commissions, Public Sector Corporations, Head of Department, Departments/Heads, the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Service Rules, U.P. Nyayik, Government, Judicial Officer, Judicial, U.P. Nyayik Sewa, Answer, Examinations, AIR 1961, Supreme Court, Learned Counsel, the Supreme Court, a High Court, State, Advocate, the Lahore High Court, Bar, Uttar Pradesh, the Supreme Court, State, Supreme Court, U.P., AIR 1966, Supreme Court, State, Court, Bar, All India Judges', Association v. Union of India and Ors, SC 503, Supreme Court, the Shetty Commission, the Higher Judicial Service, the Supreme Court, U.P., the High Court, State, the High Court, the High Court, the Supreme Court, the High Court, the High Court, State, the Supreme Court, State, Judicial, the Supreme Court, Bar, All India Judicial Services, Direct Recruitment, NOC, Jain, the U.P. Nyayik Sewa, Judicial Magistrates, Court, Advocate, the Bar Council, Court, Behariji Das, AIR 1969 All, Court, Prayag Narain, Judicial Magistrate, Prayag Narain, Prayag Narain, Behariji Das, Prayag Narayan, State, the Higher judicial Service, Prayag Narayan, Prayag Narayan, Judicial Magistrate, Behariji Das, AIR 1969 All, Court, State, the Higher Judicial Service, Prayag Narayan, AIR 1985 SC 308, Supreme Court, the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Services, the High Court of Allahabad, the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service, the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Service, the Higher Judicial Service, the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Service, the Higher Judicial Service, the Allahabad High Court, the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Service, the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service, Court, Court, the Uttar Pradesh Judicial Service, Court, the High Court of Allahabad, Judicial, the High Court, the High Court, AIR 1961, State, Advocate, The Supreme Court, Direct Recruitment, Direct, Learned Counsel, Supreme Court, Direct Recruitment, Advocate, Court, K. Naga Raja and Ors, Superintending Engineer, Irrigation Department, AIR 1987, AP 230, recruitment.82, State, State, the High Court, State, the High Court, AIR 1969 P&H, the Home Gazette Notification No, Andhra Pradesh High Court, Court, the Division Bench, this High Court, Behariji Das, AIR 1969 All, Sri Prayag Narayan, Advocate, Court, State of Assam, AIR 1967 SC 442, an Industrial Tribunal in Assam, Apex Court, the Industrial Tribunal under Clause, a High Court, Behariji Das, Prayag Narayan, Sri Prayag Narayan.97, the Division Bench, Supreme, Advocate, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, P.R. Sawhney, P.R. Sawhney, Advocate, Tribunal, State, the Uttar Pradesh Higher Judicial Service Rules, The Selection Committee, Committee, Jharkhand State, the Selection Committee, Jharkhand State, Court, the Personnel Department of, the High Court, the High Court, Angad Prasad, Full Court, the High Court, the Full Court, Selection Committee, Court, the Selection Committee, the High Court, Full Court, the Apex Court, the Selection Committee, Full Court, State, State, the Full Court, Selection Committee, the Full Court of the High Court, State.(2), the State of Jharkhand, Judicial Service, the Selection Committee, Sri Sandeep, Tamilnadu, AIR 1974, SC, AIR 1981, SC, D.S. Nakara v. Union of India, AIR 1983, AIR 1978, the Apex Court, A.L. Kalra v. Project and Equipment, Corporation of India Ltd., AIR 1984, the Apex Court, the Jharkhand State, U.P. Nyayik Sewa, Judicial Service

DATE: 8th June, 2000, 2000, 1.1.2001, 7 years', more than 7 years', 1.1.2001, 26th November, 2000, three years, December, 2003, 8th, 12th and 15th January, 2004, 23.3.2001, 26.3.2001, 23.5.2001, 16.1.2004, Para 16, 16.1.2004, less than 7 years, the first day of January of next following the year, first day, year, 7 years, 4103, 25th/26th November, 2000, December, 2003, the year 2001, interview.10, Para 5, 16.1.2004, 1225, 2088, Para 29, 7 years, 1975, less than seven years, less than seven years', the first day of January next following the year, less than seven years', the first day of January next following the year, less than seven years', the period of, seven years, '18, 8th June, 2000, 1975, less than 7 years', the age of 35 years, the age of 42 years, the 1st day of January, 2001, '19, less than 7 years, 2000, the year, less than seven years, the first day of January next following the year, 1.1.2001, 1.1.2001, 1975, less than 7 years', 1975, 1999, 1990, the last date, '33, years, seven years, 1975, less than 7 years', Section 86(3, Para 15, '44, 1953, '5, more than 7 years', 1975, 1953, more than 7 years', 1975, Rule 5, 1975, seven years', Rule 5, 1975, 1975, less than seven years, 1981, Para 12, '55, Para 17, '56, 1996, Para 12, '57, 1949, '58, 13.3.2001, 1999, selected.61, 2001, '34, '63, 2001, 1956, one month, '65, 1091, January 23, 19702, June 19, 1979.(a, November 19, 1959, 1091, January 14, 2001, Para 12)In, Para 12, '12, seven years', 1987, 1987, Para 17, Para 26, 2511, years, 1979, 1978, 1978--V.K., less than seven years', Rule 17(2, less than seven years, Para 18, less than seven years, 1980, 11th October, 1984, 1980, 7 years, 1982, October 11, 1984, October 11, 1984, less than 7 years, the 7 years', less than seven years, '87, 7 years, '90, Para 13, 1947, less than three years, '93, the year 1965, at least ten years, '95, Para 17, '96, Para 6, October 20, 1959, fir at least ten years, at least ten years, 1975, Para 1091, 1989.115, Para 33, 16, '14

ORDINAL: 25th, second, first, second

PRODUCT: Para 14, Para 29, Rules.16, Rule 8, Respondent 1, Rule 5 of the Rules, Para 19, 816, Articles, Full Bench, 816, Para 1090, Para 33

WORK_OF_ART: 1975 Rule, 'the Constitution' and 'the Rules, Scheduled Caste, Maharao Sahib Shri Bhim Singhji v. Union of India and Ors, 'Selection Process', the Constitution of India, 'Constitutional Law of India', the Constitution of India, 'Appointment', 'Appointment', 'Appointment'

LOC: Additional District, Joint District, Single, Additional District, Additional District, Additional District Judges, Additional District, Additional District, Additional District, Additional District Judges

FAC: the Nyayik Sewa, Sri Prayag Narain's, Ajay Hasia's

TIME: 5 p.m., Earlier Rule 5

MONEY: 25 per cent