Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : AIR1982Raj297; 1982()WLN294
..... of formal democracy, retarding the progress to be achieved in ati aining the cherished goalof 'social justice'' eradication of poverty and removal of wide gaps of inequality between the privileged and unprivileged, rich and poor and have and have mots, and failure of emancipating and liberating teaming minions of poverty-strickens, half-naked, half-dressed, semi-starved, centuries ..... paid to article 46 by all concerned including the champions of the scheduled caste and tribes, can be assessed from the fact, that most of these valuable reports which got a treasure of all informations and the statistics about the annual functioning of the various legislations and constitutional protection for scheduled castes and tribes, are ..... surprising and revealing experience to find that my almost one month persistent sending of the reminders, messengers, and telephonic talks through my staff for obtaining reports of the scheduled caste and tribe commissioner issued every year from 1952 to 1981, there was conspicuous coldness indifference and lethargy in assembly library, ..... 3983,01,72,22154,73,61,9281971lok sabha522774014vidhan sabha3771518321321977lok sabha542783812vidhan sabha399754028213101970.lok sabha54279401080vidhan sabha399755730317note :-the above figures of statistics are based on the available reports of tha scheduled castes & scheduled tribes commisioner, government of india published every year under article 338 of the constitution and partially on the government of india .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : (1980)15CTR(Raj)180; [1981]127ITR308(Raj)
..... the course of arguments which were made on three successive days, we have pointed out a number of times to the learned counsel for the revenue that the valuation officer or valuation cell report or audit report in respect of these properties' valuation may be very material and, in any case, have got great relevancy and bearing on the issues of controversy involved in these writ applications and, ..... the assessment on the ground that the petitioner had made true and full disclosure of all material facts and the wto, after full consideration of the case, accepted the approved valuer's report and the certificate about the valuation of the jaipur property and no conditions precedent for the exercise of jurisdiction under section 17 of the act existed nor there was an iota of ..... issued without any legal foundation and are consequently liable to be quashed in all these 11 cases on this second important premises also, the first being that the report of the valuation officer under section 16a obtained for the purposes of considering the question of reopening is non est, illegal, void and invalid ab initio because section 16a cannot be ..... for the revenue expressly mentioned that they are not privileged documents which can be withheld from the court but even then, though the hearing continued for more than three days and the judgment is being given after the lapse of sufficient time, the department has chosen to withhold these reports and deprive this court of the benefit of perusing them .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : 1978(11)WLN304
..... judge of high court who entertains or deals with a petition challenging any order or decision of a legislature imposing any penalty on the petitioner or issuing any process against the petitioner for its contempt, or for infringement of its privileges and immunities, be who passes any order on such petition, does not commit contempt of the said legislature and the said legislature is not competent to take proceedings against such as a judge in the exercise and ..... required to be made by a minister in the parliament for the discharge of his duties as such minister, the above two questions would certainly depend upon the decision of this court about the powers and privileges of the members of parliament who become ministers regarding their speeches in the pail lament as contemplated by article 75 of constitution and the others relevant provisions in the constitution and the rules of business of the lok ..... benches. he was speaking on the subject of policy of non-alignment and reported gnat progress in the improvement of relations with the neighboring countries, when he referred to the post-dinner ..... : [1969]3scr603 that newspaper reports are not admissible unless the correspondent is examined to ..... to any proceedings in any court in respect of anything said or any vote given by him in parliament or any committee thereof, and no person shall be so liable in respect of the publication by or under the authority of either house of parliament of any report, paper, votes or proceedings .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : AIR1978Raj140; 1978(11)WLN137
..... i want that all these facts should come on record so that the privileges obtained by him be scrutinised, and the privileges which are allowed to a married man be diverted from him to maintain my child and myself for a decent living. ..... on a false report that he is maintaining his wife. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : AIR1978Raj72
..... it was next urged on behalf of the petitioner and the intervenor that the president in case of failure of constitutional machinery in the state on the receipt of the report of the governor of a state or otherwise, on being satisfied that the government of a particular state cannot be carried on, he may himself assume all or any of the functions of the state government. ..... (7) when a temporary vacancy in the office of the vice-chancellor occurs by reason of leave, illness or otherwise, the syndicate shall forthwith report the same to the chancellor who shall make such arrangement for carrying on the office of vice-chancellor as he may deem fit. ..... 2345):'the judges of the high courts owe their appointment to the constitution and hold a position of privilege under it and are not government servants in the ordinary signification of that expression. ..... over the state government against the wishes of a chief minister, who enjoys the confidence of the state legislature, though of course, the president may keep himself informed of the affairs in the state through the reports of the governor, which may lead to the removal of the ministry, under article 356.37. ..... he is entitled under clause (3) of article 158 to such emoluments, allowances and privileges as may be determined by parliament by law and such emoluments are guaranteed during the tenure of his office.78. ..... he owes his appointment to the constitution and holds the position of privilege under it. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : 1974WLN969
..... chief justice to proceed with the enquiry with the charges made against the petitioner it should be taken that the enquiry was made by the high court and, there- fore, the enquiry report, on the basis of which governor imposed the penalty, cannot be said to be suffering from any infirmity, and the penalty imposed by the governor was quite in consonance with the provision of the constitution ..... m.b.l bhargava, appearing on behalf of the petitioner, on the other hand contended that the subsequent adoption of the report of mr justice bhargava, who was incompetent to initiate the disciplinary enquiry by framing charges against a member of the ..... ground between the parties that thereafter the full court met on december 11, 1965, and discussed the inquiry report, made by hon'ble justice bhargava in the light of the observations made by the court. ..... the circumstances of this case cannot be said to have been taken by the high court and his report, therefore, could not be used by the governor to impose the penalty of removal as mr. ..... a disciplinary authority and, therefore, he could neither frame charges nor could be conduct the inquiry and recommend to the government about the petitioner's removal from service and subsequent acceptance of that report by the full court does not give any validity and sure the defects of that report which was from its very inception illegal. ..... he full court has not been placed before us, as the registrar has claimed privilege to produce this document in the court. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : 1973CriLJ1637
..... is privileged on the same principle as an accurate report of proceedings in a court of justice is privileged, viz ..... act, 1885, to inquire into the inadequate performance of the ecclesiastical duties of any benefice, creates a judicial tribunal, and the occasion on which a witness gives evidence before the commissioners is absolutely privileged, and no action is maintainable in respect of evidence so given.in ratan lai's law of tort, 19th edn. p. ..... from the above authorities it is manifestly clear that absolute privilege, which the accused are entitled to claim under fourth exception to ..... unless the complainant was given an opportunity of adducing his evidence, it cannot be held at this stage that the accused are entitled to claim absolute privilege under fourth exception to section 499, indian, penal code. ..... section 499, indian penal code and that the reports so published did not form part of the ..... nevertheless they claimed unqualified privilege for the publication of the court-proceedings, under fourth exception to section 499, ipc which privilege they are entitled to claim in the light ..... not a necessary ingredient in the exception.in the present case it has not been shown to me that the impugned report, published in 'veer arjun' was not substantially correct. ..... er 558, it is not essential that every word of the evidence, of the speeches, and of what was said by the judge, should be inserted, if the report is substantially a fair and correct report of what took place in a court of justice. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : AIR1972Raj209; 1971(4)WLN660
..... 1877' gives an account of the legendary history of the salt production of pachpadra and he pointed out in para 54 of that report that when a salt manufacturer wanted to excavate a pit he used to intimate his intention to the hakim and when the pit was completed he had to present a nuzzer of re. ..... they are accompanied by some rather extravagant assertions, such as that the source is khalsa every handful of soil, every drop of brine and every ounce of salt is raj property and that the only privilege possessed by the kharwals is the right to labour -- 'hak-i-mazduri' -- on reasonable terms. ..... the sources, according to his assertion is khalsa, every handful of soil, every drop of brine and every ounce of salt is raj property and the only privilege possessed by the kharwals is the right to labour -- 'hak-i-mazduri' on reasonable terms-'19. mr. ..... apart from this historical background and the reports of the high officials of the british government intimately connected with the manufacture of salt in pachpadra and didwana, a perusal of article iv indicates that the jodhpur ruler while entering into the agreement was conscious of this ..... inland customs in his 'general report on the salt producing capabilities of the state of jodhpur or marwar dated the 13th june. ..... adam's report on pachpadra in the printed volume. ..... inland customs and the report of mr. ..... it is in this connection that the learned author discussed the report of mr. r. m. .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : AIR1970Raj281; 1970CriLJ1561
..... the recommendation that due regard shall be had to the guarantee or assurance given under the covenant or agreement, the parliament or the legislature of a state makes laws inconsistent with the personal rights, privileges and dignities of the ruler of an indian state, the exercise of the legislative authority cannot, relying upon the agreement or covenant, be questioned in any court, and that is so expressly provided by article ..... a new state and such provisions may be recognised by courts as law partaking the character of an act of the state, but the' provisions in a covenant dealing with the rights or privileges of individuals, be they ex-rulers, cannot claim the status of a law and they will not be enforceable in courts of law as such, unless there is legislative sanction in support of such provisions in the covenant.13. ..... ruler of an indian state is exempt from personal appearance as a complainant in a criminal case instituted by him on the basis of his so-called personal privileges saved by or arising from the covenant resulting in the integration of the indian state of which the complainant was the ex-ruler with the union of states. ..... in the punjab case the first information report for an offence under section 408, indian penal code was lodged by the private secretary to the nawab of former nalerkotla state which had integrated with the pepsu union, ..... of the madhya pradesh high court reported as abdul alim khan v. ..... of the punjab high court reported as shaukat ali khan v .....
Tag this Judgment!Court : Rajasthan
Reported in : AIR1970Raj72
..... appears however that the maharana felt aggrieved by the decision of the state government on the report of the rating committee and his master of household made a representation to the state government that the concession regarding the supply of electricity to his highness was a 'privilege' granted in his highness's favour, which was maintained in the covenant and safeguarded in the ..... it may be mentioned here that when the case came up for hearing on april 27, 1967, it was reported that parts 'r', 'c', and 'd' of the file of the trial court had been weeded out, so that only part ..... as has been stated, it was an intrinsic part of the report of the rating committee that the concession admissible to the maharana of udaipur should be cancelled and that the general rates of supply to the consumers should be applicable to his palaces because, in the opinion of the rating ..... ' in accepting the rating committee's report the government, therefore, undoubtedly accepted this recommendation for the abolition of the ..... went into the matter and its report has been published in notification no.f. ..... report was published on september 26, 1953, the new charges could not be effective earlier than two months thereafter so that the plaintiff will be liable to pay according to the revised rates after the expiry of the period of two months from the date of publication of the report ..... the report of the rating committeewent to the state government and, as has been stated, it was notified in the state gazette dated .....
Tag this Judgment!