Skip to content


Judgment Search Results Home > Cases Phrase: national commission for safai karamcharis act 1993 Court: central administrative tribunal cat delhi Page 1 of about 25 results (0.165 seconds)

Aug 21 2007 (TRI)

S.K. Sood, Ias Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and anr.

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

Reported in : (2008)(2)SLJ94CAT

..... appointment as secretary in abeyance has not been revoked and rather applicant who was yet to be absolved in the disciplinary proceedings to be instituted against him and as the aforesaid process was taking time he was appointed as secretary, national commission for sc not in the capacity and as a result of the earlier decision but as a posting to the applicant on his compulsory wait in the rank of an additional secretary to the government of india. ..... accordingly, it is stated that unlike the post in ministry, the post of secretary in the national commission for sc being a statutory post, selection for post of secretaries under the staffing scheme in the central secretariat is different from the selection for post equivalent in other departments, not forming part of the secretariat, namely, technical post or post in income tax, excise etc ..... learned counsel lastly states that there is no post of additional secretary, national commission for sc/st and as the applicant took over as the secretary, he would have to be deemed as secretary with all attendant benefits.19 ..... in a manner the respondent (sc commission) have espoused the case of the applicant with a further submission that as per the right to information act, 2005 under section 4( 1 )(b)(v) every public authority, including the respondent no. ..... therefore, even if in 1993, some ineligible candidates were wrongly treated as eligible, the first respondent cannot insist that she also must be treated eligible though she is ineligible .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jan 18 2007 (TRI)

Smt. G. Lalita W/O Shri G.V.S.S. Vs. Union of India (Uoi) Through the

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

..... another detailed representation dated 01.08.2006 was also addressed to national commission for women pointing out high handedness of authorities in issuing said ..... consequence is that court should draw an inference that there was no public interest served in passing said orders.incidentally, this question had been considered by the hon'ble supreme court in ramadhar pandey 1993 supp (3) scc 35, the relevant excerpt of which reads as under: 16 'what is to be considered is whether there is any public interest involved in the transfer of the appellant as joint secretary. ..... of the examiner of question documents, chandigarh was received on 10.7.2006 & ddg, submitted his preliminary inquiry report on 17.10.2006, & respondents concluded the alleged incident/act amounts to criminal misconduct, as revealed vide note dated 4.12.2006, why they did not take any final decision in the matter & dragged their feet? ..... consideration to the facts noticed, rival contentions raised vis a vis the material on record, i am of the considered view that in given circumstances it is not necessary to lift the veil as the real circumstances, motive and foundation for such transfer were disclosed by the respondents not only vide memo dated 27th july, 2006 but also in reply filed to present oa, as noticed hereinabove. ..... the entire edifice for applicant's transfer had been built upon the incident of her act of handing over some papers relating to a departmental enquiry against ..... words, the respondent acted in haste. .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jul 10 2012 (TRI)

K. Kannan, Peon Mts New Delhi and Others Vs. the Chairperson, National ...

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

..... to 6th central pay commission (cpc) period, the nhrc had the recruitment rules (rrs) for the post of peon by which direct recruitment used to take place, but on the basis of 6th cpc recommendations, all group d posts (daftry, peon library attendant, farash and safai karamchari) had been re-designated ..... six applicants (two ldcs and four peons) working from july, 2008 on ad hoc basis in the national human rights commission (nhrc) whose temporary service has not been extended, have joined together in the present oa seeking following relief(s): 8.1 to direct the respondent to consider the applicants for appointment on regular basis in the cadre of ldcs and peon at par with the similarly circumstances officials who have been ..... honble high court of delhi in sheenu saxenas case (supra) if the applicants have already applied or to apply in near future for the relevant vacant post(s) in nhrc, the requisite age relaxation shall be granted by the nhrc to the applicants in their respective categories ( ..... in the present oa and set aside the order of the tribunal passed on 01.02.2012 in oa no.3469/2011 while allowing grant of age relaxation to the respondents, shri gaur, learned counsel for the applicants would submit that all the applicants in the present oa should be extended same benefit of age relaxation. 5. ..... they have enclosed in annexure a-5 copy of orders received under the right to information act in support of their claim that 6 persons initially appointed on ad hoc basis in the .....

Tag this Judgment!

May 07 2012 (TRI)

Vijay Dhankar and Others Vs. Chief Secretary, Govt. of Nct of Delhi 9t ...

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

..... it is also provided that as per rule 6(2) of the dhs (allopathic) rules, 2009 the contract doctors shall not automatically become the part of dhs but they sill be subject to assessment of their suitability by the commission and requisite qualifications and experience prescribed for the post and being found fit, shall be deemed to have been appointed under these rules and assigned to the sub-cadres of gdmo or non teaching specialist, as the case may be, and ..... the honble supreme has held though section 18 was reintroduced by the 1995 amendment act with certain conditions yet the legislature fixed 6th august, 1993 as the cut off date as the state government had decided to make regular selection and steps in that behalf had already been ..... proposal of the government was based on the decision of the government of delhi to form a new service known as national capital territory of delhi health service for medical practitioners under allopathy system, and om was issued in this respect on 18.2.2006. ..... that the proposal of the government of nct of delhi for framing of national capital territory of delhi health service (allopathy) rules, were initially received on 18.12.2008 and it was examined on various ..... of nct of delhi for framing of national capital territory of delhi health service (allopathy) rules, was initially received on 18.2.2008 (annexure r-4-1) and the proposal was examined and after series of discussion with the representative of the government of nct of delhi, various .....

Tag this Judgment!

Apr 30 2012 (TRI)

Jasmer Singh and Others Vs. the Director Central Bureau of Investigati ...

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

..... the government has considered the recommendations of the sixth central pay commission for introduction of a macps and has accepted the same with further modification to grant three financial upgradations under the macps at intervals ..... the state of rajasthan, from granting such financial upgradations/selection grades to the concerned applicants as its employees, at a much lower eligibility levels of 9 years, 18 years and 27 years of service for the grant of such selection grades, while the union of india followed the much less lenient acp scheme of stagnation over 12 years or 24 years of service earlier, and has only now made ..... admitted, his services were borne on the rajasthan state police from 11.06.1993 till the date of his absorption in the cbi on 17.04.2006 on ..... of the lien held by him, and the applicant herein held his lien with the state government of rajasthan from 11.06.1993 to 16.04.2006, prior to the date of his permanent absorption in cbi w.e.f. ..... therefore, from 11.06.1993 to 17.04.2006, the applicant had held his lien in the state government of rajasthan for a total period of 13 years, and, obviously, in accordance with the above cited rajasthan state government scheme for grant of financial upgradations after stagnation of 9 years, 18 years and 27 years, issued on 17.02.1998, and effective from 1.9.1996, the applicant was entitled to receive financial upgradation on completion of 9 years ..... 1993 onwards also for ..... constable in the rajasthan state police (grp) on 11.06.1993. .....

Tag this Judgment!

May 09 2012 (TRI)

Krishna Kumari Vs. Govt. of Nct of Delhi Through Its Chief Secretary, ...

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

..... . the government has considered the recommendations of the sixth central pay commission for introduction of a macps and has accepted the same with further modification to grant three financial upgradations under the macps at intervals of 10, 20 ..... acp and macp schemes are beneficial schemes, in the nature of a safety-net, to provide financial upgradation assistance to employees who have stagnated in a pay scale, without any increment over decades long periods, and had prescribed for financial upgradations to be granted to the stagnating government employees, who had stagnated over a time period of 12/24 years of regular service in the case of acp scheme, and 10/20/30 years of continuous regular service in ..... also came to be decided and disposed of by the honble high court on 07.01.2011, observing that there was no error apparent in its judgment on the face of the record, and under review it was not permissible for an erroneous decision in a case to be re-heard and corrected, and an error which is not self-evident, and has to be detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face ..... , the applicant is aggrieved that her representation dated 4.5.2010 (annexure a-2) has not been acted upon by the respondents, and she has had to approach this tribunal on the ground that since the acp scheme earlier stipulated a second financial upgradation to be granted after 24 years of ..... ishwar singh khatri and others 1993 (2) scale 730, which has been .....

Tag this Judgment!

Nov 22 2011 (TRI)

Sh. Ravi Kumar Uppal and Others Vs. Press Council of India Through the ...

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

..... proposal of the second respondent to switch over the employees of pci from cpf scheme to pension scheme has not been agreed to, (ii) letter dated 16.9.2009 (page 97) whereby the proposal of pci for conversion from cpf to pension scheme for its employees has not been acceded to by the second respondent; and (iii) the circular dated 11.08.2010 (page 98) in which the 1st respondent informed the decision of the 2nd respondent as ..... shri ravi kumar uppal and 60 others working in the press council of india (pci) have joined together and approached this tribunal under section 19 of the administrative tribunals act, 1985 praying (i) to declare the regulation 13 of the regulations 2002 as illegal, contradictory as the same deprives the benefits of pension scheme to the applicants; and (ii) to declare that they are entitled ..... [1973 (1) scc 651] to submit that where the government has made a reference to the pay commission in respect of central government employees and such recommendations have been accepted, the government is bound to implement the ..... and circumstances of the case, we come to the considered conclusion that the regulation 13 is intra vires of the pci act, and the impugned letters dated 29.7.2008, 16.9.2009 and 11.8.2010 being in conformity with the concerned statutory provisions are legally ..... like dental council of india, sahitya academy, national council for women, indian council of agricultural research society, central council for research in unani medicine etc. ..... uoi [1993 (4) scc .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jan 13 2012 (TRI)

Surinder Singh Vs. the Secretary, Ministry of Defence (Finance), New D ...

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

..... penalty and it shall not be necessary to give the government servant any opportunity of making representation on the penalty proposed to be imposed: provided that in every case where it is necessary to consult the commission, the record of the inquiry shall be forwarded by the disciplinary authority to the commission for its advice and such advice shall be taken into consideration before making an order imposing any such penalty on the government servant. 13. ..... in the office of deputy controller general of defence accounts (administration) and as such only deputy controller of defence accounts, who was the competent disciplinary authority being the appointing authority of the applicants authorized to act under rule 11 of the rules ibid, the punishment imposed by an authority suboridiante to the appointing authority not only vitiates statutory rules, sro 43 but is an infraction to article 311 of the constitution of ..... court in the case of punjab national bank (supra) in which it had been categorically provided, following earlier decisions, that if the disciplinary authority does not agree with the findings of the enquiry officer that the charges are not proved, it has to prove, at this stage, an opportunity of hearing to the delinquent so that there may still be some room left for convincing the disciplinary authority that ..... b.karunkaran, (1993) 4 scc 727, the high court held that after reinstating the applicant in service, he may be placed under suspension and continue the enquiry .....

Tag this Judgment!

May 16 2007 (TRI)

Dinesh Kumar Patnaik Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

Reported in : (2008)(1)SLJ134CAT

..... that the requirement of supplying a copy has to be completed before imposition of penalty by the disciplinary authority, because the commission's advice is an additional material which is taken into consideration by the disciplinary authority for arriving at its conclusion, but this requirement of law will be applicable only prospectively, and the cases in which the disciplinary authority had already imposed penalty before 1.10.1993 when the hon'ble supreme court delivered judgment in managing director, ecu, hyderabad v. b. ..... it is also the case of the respondents that the applicant did not make any representation against the memorandum dated 22.9.2004 and, therefore, the original application is hit by section 20 of the administrative tribunals act, 1985 as also the same is barred by limitation having been filed on 11.9.2006 challenging the memorandum dated 22.9.2004.there does not appear to be any merit in the preliminary objections even though specifically and boldly taken in ..... this is, no doubt a mitigating factor, but it does not diminish the seriousness of his action in having an affair with a foreign national in a country with which india has national security interests of a high order, and where indian diplomats and officials need to exercise a special caution in their actions. .....

Tag this Judgment!

Jul 29 2003 (TRI)

Yatendra Singh Jafa Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

Reported in : (2004)(2)SLJ185CAT

..... it is open to the court or the tribunal to examine whether the satisfaction of the president or the governor is vitiated by mala fides or is based on wholly or extraneous or irrelevant grounds and for that purpose the government is obliged to place before the court or tribunal the relevant material on the basis of which the satisfaction was arrived at subject to a claim of privilege under sections 123 and ..... allegations made against the suspect or any of them should be disclosed to the suspect and he should be given an opportunity to furnish his information; or (ii) whether on grounds of national security or the nature of allegations made against the suspect, it is not advisable or necessary to disclose the allegations against the suspect or to call upon his reply thereto. ..... , on the averment of the department that no decision had been taken in respect of the applicant and they were precluded from doing so on account of the interim order dated 9.9.1993 but this was wrong, as the hon'ble high court of j and k in their judgment dated 21.4.99 in lpa (sw 631/99) filed by ashok kumar, dig, bsf had ..... an officer belonging to ips of maharashtra cadre, even if on deputation to bsf, for the purposes of disciplinary matters he could not at all have been dealt with under bsf act and rules but only in terms of all india service(discipline and appeal) rules, 1969 (ais (d and a) rules, for short).according to the respondents, however, all those who are on the rolls of ..... act of omission or commission .....

Tag this Judgment!


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organize Client Files //