Eaton Corporation and anr. Vs. Bch Electric Limited

Decided On : Jul-01-2013

Court : Delhi

LAW: Section 151 CPC, Section 28, Section 29, Section 29, The Caution Notice, the Registered User Agreement, Section 48 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, Plaintiff No.1, Plaintiff No.2, Plaintiff No.2, Plaintiff No.2, Plaintiff No.1, Paragraphs 23, Paragraphs 32 &34, Paragraphs 22, Page 3-6, Paragraphs 10, 11, Paragraphs 30 &31, the Caution Notice, Another Export Agreement

DATE: January 11, 2013, July 01, 2013, 1911, 1916, more than 100 years, the year 2010, the year 1893, the year 1919, the year 1954, Class 9, 8th June, 1954, 1958, the year 1978, 28th November, 1979, 23rd January, 1980, 1958, 1999, 1999, 1101, the year 1965, the year 1995, 25th October, 2007, the year, 3rd June, 1974, the year 1979, 19th February, 1979, seven years, the year 1986.21, November, 1975, 1958, the year 1992, the year 2003, around 23rd June 2004, the year 2007, 1999, 19th December, 2011, the year 1954, 22nd December, 2011, the month of January, 2012, the month of February, the month of March, 2012, the year 1992, several decades, 16443, 33, the year 1996, 22nd, December, 2011, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2001, post 1986, 1986, the years 2008-2011, the year 2008, the year 2008, post 1986, 19th December, 2011, 19th February, 1979, 1958, 1986, the last 25 years.38, 13th July, 1988, September, 1990, 10th April, 1990, 11th December, 1992, March 16, 1994, 11th October, 1994, 22nd October, 1999, 2004-2005, 2001-2005, 1st March, 1996, nearly half a century, a few decades, the year 1978, 28th November, 1979, January 23, 1980, 31st May, 2010, 20th August, 2003, 28th April, 2012, 2nd May, 2012, over 25 years, 1994, 2002, 2008, 2005, 2009, 1998, 67, 70, 71, 82, 90, 92, 94, 18818, 1990, 6th January, 2012, 14th October, 1992, the last several decades, the last 25 years, 14 th October, 1992, Class 9, October, 1992, the year 1893, 28th August, 1916, 6th December, 1928, 8th June, 1954, 23rd January, 1980, 1954, 23rd January, 1980, period 8th June, 1989 to 8th June, 1996, November, 1961, 23rd January, 1980, period 3rd, November, 1989, November, 1996, the year 1965, February, 1974, 3rd June, 1977, 10 years, the day, 10 years, 19th August, 1978, February, 1978, 07 years, 13th March, 1979, 13th July, 1988, 2 years, 10th April, 1990, 1988, 10 years, 4th September, 1990, 5 years, 14th October, 1992, December, 8 years, 1992, 16th March, 1994, 1992, 11th October, 1994, the period 11th October, 2004 to 11th October, 2014, August, 1995, 1st March, 1996, 10.11.2004, 4th April, 2003, 179395, 9th March, 2005, 29th May, 2007 one, 29th May, 2007, 25th October, 2007, 7th April, 2011, 19th December, 2011, 6th January, 2012, 4th January, 2012, 9th January, 2012, 8th January, 2012, 18th February, 2012, 3rd March, 2012, 20th July, 2012, 06.1954 1893, 1919, 22, 24/ 28, 35, 20563, 1960, 1960, 36, 1994, 11897

EVENT: I.A. No.1204/2012, the User Agreement, Trading Name Agreement

GPE: CS(OS, CS(OS, CS(OS, CS(OS, United States of America, New Delhi, Ohio, Australia, Brazil, Canada, China, Costa Rica, Czech Republic, Dominican Republic, France, Germany, India, Indonesia, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, Monaco, Netherlands, Poland, Puerto Rica, Singapore, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Switzerland, Taiwan, Thailand, United Kingdom, United States of America, India, India, India, India, India, India, Bhartia, India, India, New Delhi, CS(OS, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, Canada, India, India, USA, Delhi, Delhi, India, India, Mumbai, India, India, Karnataka-Single, S.P., Delhi-Single, Network, India, India, CH.46, India, India, Ohio, No.205632, India, Sales, Bhartia, Germany, CS(OS, CS(OS, CS(OS, Delhi

ORG: EATON CORPORATION & ANR, Advs, BCH ELECTRIC LIMITED Through, BCH ELECTRIC LIMITED, EATON CORPORATION & ANR, Eaton Corporation & Another, BCH Electric Ltd., Eaton Corporation & Another, Plaintiffs, BCH Electric Limited, M/s Eaton Corporation, Eaton Power Quality Pvt. Ltd., Electrical, Fluid Power, fluid power systems, Cutler- Hammer Inc., Cutler-Hammer Inc., CH, Cutler-Hammer Inc., CH Control and CH, CH Control and CH, CH Control and CH, Cutler-Hammer Inc., the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, Cutler-Hammer Inc., Form-24, Certificate, CH Control and CH, Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, CH Control and CH, BCH Electric Limited, New Delhi House, Kolkata-700017, CutlerHammer Inc., Bhartia Industries Limited, BCH Electric Limited, Cutler-Hammer Inc., Cutler-Hammer Inc.s business, Sales Agreement, License and Technical Service Agreement, the Cutler-Hammer Inc., Cutler-Hammer, Cutler-Hammer Inc., Cutler-Hammer Inc., Cutler-Hammer Inc., Cutler-Hammer Inc., CutlerHammer Inc., CH & CH Control, the Trade Mark Owners, Marks, CH Control & CH, CH, CH Control, Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, the Registered User Agreement, No.582999, No.582999, CH Control, No.1189782, Application No.1189782, the Registrar of Trade Marks, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER (, CH Control and CH, CH, CH Control, CH, CH Control, CH Control, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, I.A. No.1204/2012, CPC, CH, I.A. No.4318/2012, Cutler-Hammer, Inc., the Trade Marks Registry, No.582999, Court, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, the Trade Marks Registry CH, the Trade Marks Registry 642706 Removed, the Trade Marks Registry, CH, CH, CH, The Times of India, the Trade Marks Registry, the Registered User Agreement, inter alia, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, CH, Plaintiff, Bhartia International Private Limited, License and Technical Service Agreements, Export Agreement, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, the Examination Report, the Trade Marks Registry, No.582999, Director - Sales & Marketing PD, No.1s, Moeller HPL India Private Limited, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, CH, CH, CH, Vigilantibus Non, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, the Trade Marks Registry, Certificate, Registry, CutlerHammer, Inc., Certificate of Amendment of Certificate of Incorporation, Eaton Electrical, Inc., the Trade Marks Registry, Cutler-Hammer Inc., Resident Engineer, AIR, Control Appliances & Ors, Sumeet Machines Pvt. Ltd., Atlas Products Pvt. Ltd. & Anr, DLT, Kirloskar Proprietary Limited & Ors, & Ors, AIR 199.KANT 1, Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. & Anr, Harinder Kohli & Ors, Surendra Electricals And Ors, Jagannath & Others, AIR, AIR, ITC Limited, ITC Hotels Limited Vs, Punchgini Inc., United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit, Docket NO, Vee Excel Drugs and, Cluett Peaboy & Co. Inc., UTO Nederland B.V. & Anr, Tilaknagar Industries Ltd., Barcamerica International USA Trust Vs, Tyfield Importers, Inc., United States Court of Appeals, the Ninth Circuit D.C., United States Court of Appeals, the Ninth Circuit D.C., Wander Ltd., Court of India 3 Judges, K.R. Jadyappa Mudaliar & Ors, inter alia, CH, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, CH, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, CH, CH, Caution Notice, Plaintiff, BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, CH, CH, Court, Court, I.A. No.4318/2012, Cutler-Hammer Mfg. Co., Eaton Corporation, CutlerHammer, Inc., Cutler-Hammer, Inc., Eaton Corporation, Cutler-Hammer, Inc., Eaton Corporation, Cutler-Hammer, Inc., Eaton Corporation, Cutler-Hammer India Limited, Cutler-Hammer, Inc., Bhartia CutlerHammer Limited, Cutler-Hammer World Trade, Inc., Cutler-Hammer International, Cutler Hammer Export Sales Corporation, the License and Technical Service Agreement, CutlerHammer World Trade Inc., CutlerHammer World Trade Inc., Cutler Hammer, Inc., Cutler-Hammer India Limited, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Cutler-Hammer, Inc., Cutler-Hammer, Inc., CutlerHammer, Inc., Eaton Corporation, Bhartia International Private Limited, Eaton Corporation, License and Technical Service Agreement, Bhartia-Cutler Hammer Limited, Bhartia International Private Limited, Eaton Corporation, Trademark CH Control, No.582999, Bhartia Industries Limited, License and Technical Service Agreement, Bhartia-Cutler Hammer Limited, License and Technical Service Agreement, Eaton Corporation, Bhartia Industries Ltd., Powerware International Private Limited, Eaton Power Quality Private Limited, No.1189782, Eaton Corporation, Notice of Opposition, No.1189782, Trademark BHARTIA CUTLER-HAMMER, Bhartia Industries Limited, Registry, Bhartia Industries Limited, the Trade Marks Registry, CH, Bhartia Industries Limited, BCH Electric Limited, Eaton Corporation, BCH Electric Limited, Eaton Corporations, CH, Cease, No.582999, the Registrar of Trade Marks, the BCH Electric Limited, Statement, Eaton Corporation, Eaton Power Quality Pvt. Ltd., the High Court, CPC, Rectification Petition, CH Control, No.582999, the Intellectual Property Appellate Board, Chennai, LOD:19, LOD:19, TMJ, Legal Proceeding Certificate, TMJ, TMJ 144.(26.01.2010

PERSON: Sudhir Chandra, Navneet Momi, Neha Gupta, Sandeep Sethi, C.A.Brijesh, Maidini Phul, V.Mohini, P.Kalra, Sandeep Sethi, C.A.Brijesh, Maidini Phul, V.Mohini, P.Kalra, Sudhir Chandra, Navneet Momi, Neha Gupta, MANMOHAN SINGH MANMOHAN, Order XXXIX, Truck, Form-24, AJC Bose Road, Mathura Road Faridabad-121, Haryana, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Ltd., Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Cutler-Hammer, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Licensee of Cutler-Hammer, CUTLERHAMMER, CUTLERHAMMER, Registrar, Order XXXIX, Sandeep Sethi, Sethi, Sethi, No.642706, Jamshed Khurram, Ajay Jain, Directors, BHARTIA CUTLERHAMMER, Sethi, Cutler-Hammer, Kolkata, Cutler- Hammer, Arvindbhai Rambhai Patel & Ors, Kirloskar Dimensions Pvt, Anr, Prem Singh Vs, Research Lim, Arrow Apparals, MANU, Antox India Pvt. Ltd., K.B. Venkatachalam, Anr, CUTLERHAMMER, CUTLERHAMMER, vii, no.1, CUTLERHAMMER, no.1, Cutler Hammer, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Cutler-Hammer, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Cutler-Hammer, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Eaton Limited, Eaton Limited, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited & Eaton Corporation, No.642706, 48.7 Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Bhartia Cutler-Hammer Limited, Classes, Order XXXIX, Appr, TM Regd, Kolkata iii, Appr, TM Regd, Appr, TM Appln, TM Appln, Appr

NORP: J.1, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Desist

CARDINAL: two, 200, approximately 73,000, more than 150, four, 9, 11.1975 2, 06.1954 3.12, 10.1994, 27, 001, 1E216, 20/4, 18, two, 2012.29, two, trademarks.32, 1,94,82,68,813/-.35, 33, two, approximately 1800, 150, over 30, over 500, thousands, 25, 200.SC, 105, 2, 26-34, 101, 24, 38, 18.(High, 30, 85.(Paragraph7, 233, 05, 39, 2, 1, 72.(Supreme, 5, 1990)1, two, two, 14, two, 08.06.2020, 48.1, 48.2, 48.3, 48.4, 48.5, 48.6, 48.8, 48.9, 48.10, 21, 48.11, 16443.”08, 215/222, 3.12, 3.12, 16443.”08, 05.12, 9, 03, 11.1961, 05.12, 23.08.2011, 10.1994

ORDINAL: first, second, first, first, first, 3rd, second, 4th, first, 3rd, 3rd, 24th

PRODUCT: No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, Made, No.1, no.1, No.1, No.1562940, No.1, No.1562940, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, Agreement, Agreement, Registrar, No.1562940, No.1

MONEY: $19.92 billion, 48.12 Caution Notice

TIME: 1.

FAC: the Cutler-Hammer Inc.s

LOC: South Asia, Europe, Far East, Middle East, Africa, South-East Asia, Trademark CH

WORK_OF_ART: Atlas Cycles (, The Registered User Agreement