R.Thirunavukkarasu Vs. State of Tamil Nadu

Decided On : Apr-05-2013

Court : Chennai

LAW: Article 226 of Constitution of India, Article 226 of Constitution of India, Article 226 of Constitution of India, Rule 5-A of Fundamental Rules, Fundamental Rule 9, Rule 35, Rule 35, Section 36(b)(ii)(2, Rule 35 and Rule 36(b)(ii)(2, Rule 25 of Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, Rule 25, Rule 36, Rule 36, Rule 2(1).22, Article 226 nor, Article 226, Rule 25, Rule 35, Rule 25 of Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, Rule 25 of Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate

PERSON: JUDICATURE, JUSTICE R.BANUMATHI, JUSTICE K.RAVICHANDRABAABU, A.V.Rajaraman, Thiruvannamalai, Thiruvannamalai, Kanniyakumari, Kanniyakumari Dt, K.M.Mayilvahanan, Addl, Addl, Ramamoorthy, Addl, Chennai.22, Addl, Addl, Head Quarters, Addl, Addl, Addl, Addl, Addl, Asst, Babu, Kumar 39, A.John Rose 40, K.Ramachandran, Paul Sudhakar 62, K.Jagadeeswaran, Santhosha Muthu 69, Krishnamoorthy, Mathew David 91, Order, Kumar 12, A.John Rose 13, Kumar 6, A.John Rose 7, Madurai.5, Headquarters, K.M.Mayilvahanan, Chennai, Respondents W.P.Nos.25736, 10.T.Murugesan, Petitioners Vs, Respondents W.P.No.25737, Vel 8.V.Anna 9.M.Rajkumar, Petitioners Vs, Kennedy, Petitioners Vs, Respondents W.P.No.25739, Thomas, Petitioners Vs, Petitioners Vs, Petitioners Vs, Kumar, Petitioners Vs, Anna Salai, Thiruvannamalai, Chennai, Kamarajr Road, Tamil Nadu, Petitioner Vs, Anna Salai, W.P.Nos.25736, Certiorari, Certiorari, Narayan W.A.No.849/2010, N.G.R.Prasad, A.Prabhakara Reddy, N.Manoharan W.A.No.2066/2010, R.Singaravelan, R.Singaravelan, D.Selvanayagam, M.Radhakrishnan, V.G.Guhan Murugan W.P.Nos.25736, I.S.Inbadurai, A.SriJayanthi, Spl, I.S.Inbadurai, A.SriJayanthi, Spl, G.Sankaran, B.Saravanan, JUDGMENT R.BANUMATHI, K.RAVICHANDRABAABU, promotion&quot, W.P.Nos.25736, No.332 Home, Paragraph, No.332 Home, No.1237 Home, G.O., No.1237 Home, Head Constable, Tamil Nadu State, Government Order, No.468, Tamil Nadu State, Contentions Challenging, Vijay Narayan, Appellants, N.G.R.Prasad, A.Prabhakara Reddy, V.G.Guhan Murugan, N.Manoharan, R.Muthukumarasamy, No.468, D.Sankaran, No.332 Home, Radhakrishnan, No.332 Home, R.Singaravelan, Petitioners, R.Singaravelan, No.798, Rashmi Srivastava Vs, Appellants, Tamil Nadu State, Tamil Nadu State, Tamil Nadu, promotion&quot, promotion&quot, No.468 Home, promotion&quot, Addl, C.P.Chitrarasu, v)56 Head Constables/Havildars/Special Sub-Inspector of Police, Head Constables/Havildars, Record Clerk, separately.6, Tamil Nadu State, N.G.R.Prasad, Tamil Nadu, Vide Haji T.M.Hassan Rawther, Lal Yadav, Appellants, Appellants, No.468, Gold Medal, No.468, High Order, No.468, Head Constable, No.468, Head Constable, Head Constable, Head Constable, Appellants, C.P.Chitrarasu, C.P.Chitrarasu, K.Govindaraju, Para No.(9, Writ Petitioners, Head Constables, R.Singaravelan, Rashmi Srivastava Vs, right.56, Appellants, Vijay Narayan, Appellants, Vijay Narayan, S.D.SHARMA, K.Govindappa, N.G.R.Prasad, Appellants, A.Prabhakara Reddy, Rue, Tamil Nadu State, Appellants, Schedules Tribes, Backward Classes:- Rule, transfer&quot, Tamil Nadu State, Tamil Nadu State, Tamil Nadu State

CARDINAL: 05, 04.2013, 854, 1, 2, 3, 009.2, S.P.Murugesan, 31 to 36, 23.7.2012, 38, 41, 42, 43, 45, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 53, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 65, 66, 67, 68, 72, 74, 78, 79, 81, 82, 84, 87, 88, 89, 90, 37, 60, 23.7.2012, 61 to 91, 853, 6, 7, 8, 9, 4, 9, 23.7.2012, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 10 to 33, 23.7.2012, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 4 to 27, 23.7.2012, 28.S.Ganapathy, 30.V.K.Murugan 31.P.Rajangam, 28, 31, 1.N.Rajarajan, 3.S.Asokan, 5.K.Rajeswaran, 8.S.Selvasuresh, 9.S.Karuppu, 21.S.Selvaraj, 27.G.K.Chandrasekaran 28.S.Balasundaram, 2.The, 10.S.Gnana, 11.P.Nagaraj 12.S.Velumani, 15.M.Nallasamy, 2.The, 1.R.Senthil, 12.C.T.Sundarapandian 13.G.Kalidhas, 15.M.Adhiyaman, 17.J.Vijayakumar, 18.K.Kumar, 2.The, 16.R.Parthasarathy, 2.The, 1.D.Kandasamy, 3.L.Selvan, 6.A.Masilamani, 7.K.Sivakumar, 10.K.Raja, 21.M.Arulazhagan, 22.V.Rasa, 2.The, 2.J.Lakshmanan, 6.N.Chellapandian, 7.A.Haridass, 9.M.Murugesan, 13.P.Balasubramanian, 16.P.Ramachandran, 2.The, 3.A.John, 6.R.Mutharasu, 14.P.Premkumar, 16.P.K.Pethu, 26.S.Elango, 1A, 2.The, 6.M.Rajendran, 10.Annakodi, 11.Shanmugarajan, 13.Mohan, 14.Balasubramanian, 15.Veeraperumal, 16.Loyola, 17.J.Rathinavel, 4 to 19, 22.3.2013, 2.R.Alagu, 2.The, 1A, 2.The, 6.M.Rajendran, 4 to 6, 22.3.2013, 854, 14.10.2009, 14.10.2009, 1, 2, 29.10.2004, 851, 854, 37 to 60, 10 to 33, 853, 4 to 27, 2, 1 to 3, 854, 91, 31, 4, 19, 4 to 6, 5,7,9, 12, 854, 854, 12.4.2012, 3, 748, one, 748, 748, 159, 6.12.2004, three, one, one, 131, 30, 131, 5(e, one, 9, one, one, one, 19.03.1996, one, 851, 854, 854, 2010.16, 29.10.2004, 31 to 36, 31, 36, 36, 19.3.1996, 61 to 91, 131, 61 to 91, 61 to 91, one, 36(b)(i, 29.10.2004, 7, 561, 3, 3, 6, 1, 2, 3., one, 4., 5, 6, 8, 25, three, 18.10.2004, 19.10.2004, 752, 22.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 19.3.1996, 2, 19.10.2004, 752, 5, one, 10, 3, 2, 3, 1, 748, Seven hundred and forty, one, 27, three, 748, 19.3.1996, 29.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 27.1.1997.28, 2:-, 29.10.2004:-, one, 19.3.1996, one, 1, 15.[P.S.Sadasivaswamy, 29.10.2004, 29.10.2004, one, 1, 5, 6, 29.10.2004, 19.3.1996, 19.3.1996, 19.3.1996, 45, 19.3.1996, 19.3.1996.46, 19.3.1996, II, 19.3.1996, one, one, 2.Must, 3.Of, 4(B, 2.Must, 3.Of, 3(d, 2, 29.10.2004, one, 9, 29.10.2004, 7, 561, 3, 29.10.2004, 3 to 7:-, more than one, 29.10.2004, 4, 9, 6, 1, 1.to, one, 66, 67, two, 14, 15, 2(14)-, 14, 2(5, 15, 68, more than one, more than one, 69, 36, 2)a, two, two, two, 25, 25, 10, 15, 35.76, 35

ORG: HONOURABLE, HONOURABLE, The State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, Secretariat, Madurai, Superintendent of Police, Superintendent of Police, Special Task Force, AC, Police, Crime &amp, Traffic, Salem, Superintendent of Police, SIT, Traffic, SIT, Trichy &amp, Madurai, SBCID, Special Division, CCBI, SIT, PEW, Vellore.25, Security Branch CID, Government Estate, PEW, Cuddalore.27, PEW, N.Rathinam, PEW, Superintendent of Police, Asst, Asst, Asst, Intelligence Section, Chennai Police, Asst, Traffic Investigation, Vigilance &, Respondents, Court, Justin, Pandi .. Respondents (Respondents, Respondents, Court, Respondents, T.Siva, The State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, Secretariat, Chennai-4.3, Court, The State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, Secretariat, Chennai-4.3, 27.3.2013, Coimbatore District, The State of Tamilnadu, Government, Home Department, Secretariat, Chennai-4.3, Superintendent of Police, Civil Supplies CID, Chennai, Superintendent of Police, SIT, Coimbatore, CBCID, Chennai, State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, State of Tamil Nadu, Government, Home Department, Home Police, Secretariat, Tamilnadu Public Service Commission, Thiruchendur South Division, City Crime Branch, CBCID, Coimbatore, Crime Records Bureau, Sami, Core Cell Security, Government, Home Department, Secretariat, Respondents W.P.(MD, Home Police, Secretariat, Tamilnadu Public Service Commission, Thiruchendur South Division, City Crime Branch, CBCID, Coimbatore, Court, Court, No.1396, No.1252, No.332, No.332, W.A.Nos.850 &amp, M/s.Row &amp, M/s.APR Associates, W.A.Nos.850, Advocate General 2010 &amp, G.P. Respondents, WA.2066/2010, J &amp, Special Task Force, intra-Court, Home Department, No.1396 Home, Respondents, Executive Orders, W.A.Nos.849, No.1396 Home, State Government, State Government, No.1396 Home, the Division Bench, Advocate General, Government, No.1252 Home, No.1346 Home, the Writ Appeals, No.1396 Home, No.1252 Home, the State Government, Special Task Force, Government, us.6, No.1346 Home, No.1357 Home, No.1252 Home, Government, No.1396 Home, the Additional Superintendents of Police, No.1252 Home, 6.12.2004 Government, No.1396, Home, No.1396 Home, No.1396 Home, Government, No.1396 Home, No.1396 Home, No.1396 Home, Appellants, Government, No.1396 Home, the Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, General Rules, SS Rules, the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission, State, Accelerated Promotion Board Minutes, S.T.F., Guidelines, No.1252 Home, No.1396 Home, No.1396, Appellants, TNS &amp, SS Rules, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Senior Counsel, No.1396 Home, TNS &amp, SS Rules, W.P.Nos.850, No.1396 Home, No.1396 Home, No.1396 Home, Appellants, Special Task Force, No.1252 Home, No.1252 Home, No.1396 Home, Sub-Inspectors of Police, the Inspectors of Police, Learned Senior Counsel, Home, Committee, Learned Senior Counsel, TNS &amp, SS Rules, Appellants, S.T.F., Respondents, the Writ Court, Government, No.1396 Home, Writ Petitions, Government, Appellants, No.1396 Home, Advocate General, Special Task Force, Learned Advocate General, Advocate General, Learned Advocate, State of Tamil Nadu, the Writ Court, the Tamil Nadu State Subordinate Service Rules, Appellants, Inspectors of Police, Appellants, No.1252 Home, "names, Government Order, Suraj Parkash Gupta, State, Vikram University and Others, S.I. Paras Kumar, No.1252, Home, Government Orders, Respondents, the Appellants/Police, Special Task Force Team, the Police Officers, No.1396 Home, No.1396 Home, No.332 Home, the Accelerated Promotion Board, the Accelerated Promotion Board, Special Task Force, No.1252 Home, Special Task Force including "one, No.1252 Home, No.1252 Home, Award of Accelerated Promotion Orders Issued, VIII, No.1252 Dated 29.10.2004 Read:1, Chennai Letter Rc, No.1247 Home, Honourable, the Press Meet, "One Stage, Superintendent of Police, Thirunavukkarasu, Additional Superintendent of Police, Additional Superintendent of Police (Category II, iv)76 Sub-Inspectors of Police/Sub-Inspectors of Police (Technical, Inspectors of Police/Inspectors of Police (Technical, Sub-Inspectors of Police, Grade II Police Constables, Grade I Police Constables, The Inspectors of Police, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission, 27.1.1997, Board, No.1252, Home, Government, No.1252 Home, Government, No.1252 Home, the "member, Appellants, No.1252 Home, Government Orders, Respondents, the State Government, No.1396, Home, the Writ Court, Advocate General, the TN S &amp, SS Rules, Advocate General, the Special Task Force, Advocate General, No.1252, Home, Appellants, No.1252 Home, Respondents, Court, Government, No.1396 Home, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Court, Courts, Court, unsettle, ....&quot, Advocate General, Advocate General, No.1252, No.1252, No.1252 Home, Government, STF, State, Kerala Financial Corporation, Tata Cellular v. Union of India, Appellants, Court, the State Government, No.1252, Court, Appellants, Appellants, Court, No.1252 Home, Govt, Operational, the All India Police Duty, First Rank, Motor Transport, International, National/All India Police Meet Records, Board, Board, Board, Government, No.133841/Pol, Board, No.133841/Pol, Home, Board of accelerated promotion, Board, Board, Board, Government, Police Personnel, Home, Board, Home, Home, the Writ Court, Board, the accelerated promotion committee, Board, Inspectors of Police, the Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, Tamil Nadu S &amp, SS Rules, Home, Government, No.133841/Pol, S.T.F., STF, STF, Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service Rules and Special Rules, merit cum, Sub-Inspectors of Police and Inspectors of Police, the Service Rules/Executive Orders, Rank Restriction/Condition, Additional Superintendent of Police, the Tamil Nadu Police Service Special Rule, Probationer, the TNPS Special Rule, the Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, Sub-Inspectors of Police, Inspector of Police (Local, Sub-Inspectors of Police, Inspector of Police, the Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, Head Constable (Local, Sub Inspector (Local, Range Promotion Board, the Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, Head Constable (Armed Reserve, Sub Inspector of Police, Range Promotion Board, No.1681, Home Department, Home Department, No.107160/Pol, Special Task Force, Additional Superintendent of Police, District/Special, No.1252 Home Department, No.1252 Home Department, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission, Inspectors of Police, Sub-Inspector of Police, Special Rules, Special Rules, Sub-Inspector of Police, the State Board/Range Promotion Board, Inspectors of Police, Home, Sub-Inspectors of Police, 798 Home, Suraj Parkash Gupta, State, Vikram University and Others, Appellants, No.1252, No.1252, Government, Appellants, TNS &amp, SS Rules, TNS &amp, SS Rules, Appellants, No.1252 Home, No.1396, Home, Government, the earlier Government, State, Court, U.P., TNS &amp, SS Rules, No.1396 Home, No.1252 Home, Government Orders, Government, Government Order, Government, Appellants, General Rule, Appellants, Special Task Force and Rule, TNS &amp, SS Rules, Respondents, Additional Superintendent of Police, Tamil Nadu Police Service, Inspector of Police, the Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, Special Task Force, Special Task Force, Special Task Force, Respondents, Tamil Nadu Police Subordinate Service, under:- "Member, Commission, the Government of India, the Government of a State Provided, the Government of India, the Government of a State, the Government of India, the Government of a State, category:&quot, TNS &amp, SS Rules, under:- "35, the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission, Appointing Authority, recruitment&quot, recruitment&quot, Police Officers, Tamil Nadu Police Service, TNS &amp, SS Rules, TNS &amp, SS Rules, the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission, TNS &amp, SS Rules, TNS &amp, SS Rules, Sub Inspectors, the Police Training College, Tamil Nadu Police Service, Grade I Police Constables and Police Constables, ...........&quot, Additional Superintendent of Police, Tamil Nadu Police Service, Inspectors of Police, Tamil Nadu Police Service, No.1252 Home, No.1346 Home, Tamil Nadu Police Service, the Writ Court, No.1396 Home, No.1396, No.1252 Home, No.1346 Home, No.1396 Home, No.1252, VIII, Depar

DATE: 2010, 2066, 2010, 2010, 20728, 2012, 2012, 2010, 10.S.Muthusamy, 11.R.Chinnasamy, Dt.14, 2012, 2010, 37, 44, 46, 52, 55, 63, 64, 70, 73, 75, 76, 85, N.Venkatesan 86, 2012, 2010, 2010, 2010, 2010, 2010, 2012, 2012, 2010, 2012, M.P.No.5 of 2012, 2010, 2010, 4.R.Rayappan, 6.S.Saravanan, 12.A.Logeshwaran, 13.K.Logesh, 15.V.P.Balasubramanian 16.M.S.Madasamy, 18.S.Prabakaran 19.P.Sachithanandam, 25.M.Palanisamy, 2010, 2010, 4.K.Pakiyam, 5.D.Kumarappan, 6.A.Venkateswaran, 2010, 1.A.M.Maran, 3.K.Ganesan 4.P.Muthukumaran, 6.A.Venkateswaran 7.M.Venkatraman, 11.G.Ravichandran, 12.G.Velusamy, 13.A.Jayaraman 14.N.Tamilarasan, 20.U.Palanivelu, 22.J.Shanmugam, 24.U.Pandian 25.K.Ilayaraja, 27.B.Anbu, 2010, 9.K.Balaji, 12.S.Muthukannan 13.K.Chandran 14.N.Kannan, 19.R.Mahendran, 2010, 1.A.P.Jayachandran, 10.V.Chinnadurai 11.T.R.Ravichandran, 2012, 1.S.Radhakrishnan, 11.V.Gnanasekaran, 20.K.Ramachandran 21.S.Venkatachalapathy, 18.A.Elango, 2012, 1.K.Saravanan, 3.S.Prabakaran 4.R.Ranjith, 2012, 2010, 37136, 2007, 2010, 2008, 25741, 2010, 2012, 2012, 2010, 2010, 2010, 17731, 2012, 2010, 20728, 2012, 25741 of 2010, 2012, 2010, 2066, 2010, 2010, 2066, 2010, 2010, 12.04.2012, 14.10.2009, 29.10.2004, 20728, 2012, 2012, 29.10.2004, 27.10.2004, 27.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 5.6.2007, 29.10.2004, 1346, 3.10.2007, 03.10.2007, 25.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 2010, 2010, the year 2006, 2010, 25741, 2010, 2010, 29.10.2004, 2010, 2010, 2010, 2010, 2012, 2012, 2012, 5.6.2007, 2000, 2011, 1995, 2004, 29.10.2004, 3.10.2007, 25.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 25.10.2004, ten days, 29.10.2004, 2)/2004, 22.10.2004 and 25.10.2004 3.G.O.Ms, 28.10.2004, ten days, 27.1.1997, ten days, 29.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 29.10.2004, 1975, six months, the most a year, 32, the year 2004, 29.10.2004, the year 2004, 1988, 1994, 1994, 29.10.2004, 27.1.1997, 27.1.1997, 27.1.1997, 22.10.2004, 25.10.2004, 27.1.1997, 4 years, 1 year, 5 years, 2 years, the age of 55 years, 55 years of age on the first date of the year, the age of 53 years, the first day of July of the year, the "C&quot, 7 years, less than 4 years, the age of 55 years, the first day of July of the year, the "C&quot, 7 years, less than 4 years, 5 years, 15 years, 12.10.1992, 07.01.1998, 10 years, 50, four years, one year, 2010, 2010, four years, 2010, 2010, 2007, one year, Para 34, 29.10.2004, 2000, 2011, 1995, 2004, 29.10.2004, 3.10.2007, 1986, one year, 1998, 2008, 2011, 2009, 29.10.2004, the same day, five years, two years, three years, the same day, the same day, the same day, the same day, 74, 29.10.2004, 03.10.2007, 29.10.2004

LOC: Southern Range

GPE: Dindigul, Dindigul District, Alandur, Chennai.12, Salem Rural, Pudhukottai, M.Manohar, Principal, W.A.No.849/2012, Perambalur District, Perambalur District, Coimbatore-641 028, S.Rajendran, M.Manohar, Britto, Kumaran, Govt., Tuticorin District, Madurai City, Madurai, Rathnam, Madurai District, Singh, Kannan, Singh, Govt., Tuticorin District, Madurai City, Madurai, W.P.No., Spl, W.P.No, Spl, Veerappan, W.A.No.2066, Paragraph 5(e, Orissa, Veerappan, F.M.Hussain, Veerappan, Home, Home, Bihar, Home, "begin, individual.&quot, District, Paragraph, S.T.F, Orissa, Home, Home, INDIA, Karnataka

PRODUCT: J.Vijay Anand 83, Kumar, 4.R.Moorthy, Prasad 16.S.Thirugnana, 4.B.Anburaj, W.P.No.25736, 757 Police, Task Force, Para 5(e, Task Force, Para 5(e, Appellant, Inspectors, category&quot, Para, Task Force, Task Force, Grade II, Grade, Para 5(e

NORP: Tirunelveli, Pandian, Rules, Hon'ble, M.Sundararajan, Hon'ble, Hon'ble, service&quot, quickly&quot, Proforma, regard&quot, service&quot, service&quot, Rules, service&quot, Rules

QUANTITY: 8.M.Muralitharan 9.M.Elangovan, 3 SCC 653.S.I. Paras Kumar, 6 SCC 88).55

MONEY: 18.M.Kannan, 3.C.Kalaiselvan

FAC: Babu 9.A.D.Mohan Raj, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Kamarajar Road, Tamil Nadu State, the Tamil Nadu State, Tamil Nadu State, Tamil Nadu State, Tamil Nadu State

ORDINAL: first, first, 1st, 1st, first, first, 2nd, 3rd, 2nd, 3rd, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, First

WORK_OF_ART: G.O., G.O., Officers, the Schedule Castes