Earl Cadogan (Appellant) Vs. Pitts and Another (Respondents) and One Other Action

Decided On : Dec-10-2008

Court : House of Lords

LAW: The Leasehold Reform Act 1967, section 9, section 82, the Housing Act 1969, the 1967 Act, The Housing Act 1974, section 9(1A, section 145, Chapter I of the 1993 Act, section 109(3, the Housing Act 1996, Chapter and Chapter II, section 42, section 82, the Housing Act 1969, section 82, the Housing Act 1969, section 42, Chapter II, Chapter II, section 42, the Leasehold Reform Act 1967, section 9, section 109, the Housing Act 1996, Inheritance Tax Act, the Leasehold Reform Act 1967, section 32, section 56, Chapter II, Schedule 13, Section 9 of the 1967 Act 37, Act 38, the 1967 Act, section 110, Schedule 13, section 42, section 109, the Human Rights Act, Article 1 of the First Protocol to the Convention, section 3, the Human Rights Act, section 3, section 9, section 3, section 9(1D, The Leasehold Reform Act 1967 , the Leasehold Reform Act 1967, Section 1 of that Act, Section 9 of the 1967 Act, section 21, Custins v Hearts of Oak Benefits Society, Section 82, the Housing Act 1969, The 1967 Act, section 1, the Housing Act 1974, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 9, section 21, the Housing Act 1980, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 9, Section 9(1D, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, chapter II, chapter II, section 1 of the 1967 Act, section 42, section 56, Chapter I, section 32, Chapter and Chapter II, section 42, the Housing Act 1996, section 109, section 9, section 9(1, section 9(1, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 82, section 9(1A, section 9(1D, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 9(1A, section 82, section 9(1A, Schedule 13 to the 1993 Act, section 9, section 82, section 9(1, section 9(1, section 42 - i.e., chapter II, chapter II, chapter II, section 52, section 42, section 9(1A, section 18

CARDINAL: 1, one, 2., 1914, 3, 472, 3, zero, two, 4., two, 5., 209, 239, 6., more than half, half, half, 8, half, 9, 6, 2, three, 3, 4(2, 10, 3, two, 3, 12, 9(1, 9(1, 3, 13, 3, 14, 104, 15, #, 16, 17, 1909, 1, 18, 19, 209, 239, 20, two, two, 21, two, 22, 23, 3(1)(a, one, 3(1, 209, 239, 24, 25, 26, three, two, 27, 9(1, one, 28, One, 3(2, 2008, 1, 49, 29, 83, 9(1, 37, 20, 30, 6, 13, 3, 6, 27/29, 32, 3, 12, 33, two, 34, 160, 168, 2, 273(3, 35, 2, 13, 2, 3(2, 3(4, 36, 13, 6, 13, 6, 6, 209, 239, 13, two, 13, only two, only two, 39, 13, 2, three, 3, 4, 5.&#8221, 4, two, 4(2)(a)(i, two, 4(2)(b)(i, 4(2)(a)(i, two, 4(2A, 40, 3, 3(2, 3, 4, 6, 6, 13, 42, 6, 4(2, 4(2)(a, 4, 6, 3, 3, 43, 6, 3, 2, more than one, 3, one, two, one, 3, 4(2)(a, 3, 3, 3, 6, 6, 13, 8, 123, 13, half, 49, 54, 27/29, 27/29, five, 27/29, 2008, 1, five, three, more than twenty-one years, 209, 239, 9(1, two, 9(1, 9A, 57, three, 1, 209, two, two, 59, two, 1, 209, two, two, 60, 1, 57, 61, half, 1, 215, 1, 203, three, about 35 to 40 years, 64, 145, 146, two, one-half, 1E, 66, 67, 1, 209, 1, 68, 6, 1, 143, 69, 1, 105, 1, 209, 3, 139, 188, three, 27/29, three, 1, 153, 112, 1, 71, II, 13, 2 to 4, 3, 3(1, 2, 4(1, 2, 2, 73, 74, II, 3, 3(1, 4(1, 2, 2, 75, 109, 110, 2, 6, 3, 13, 3, 6, 3(1A, 4(1, 1D, 1E, 4(1, 3, 13, 3, 6, 1., 2, 3, 13, 3, 4, 4, 3, 4, 79, 1, 2, 3, 13, 4, 3, 4, 6, 4, 3, 9(1, four, 9(1, 81, 82, 9(1, 83, 1, 3, 13, 9(1, 84, 85, half, half, 1, 209, more than half, 1, 48, half, 86, 2001, 1, 105, 1, 209, half, 87, 3, 20, 88, 20, half, two, two, 1, 209, one, 1, 132, 134, 36, 185, 1914, 3, 90, half, half, 1, 48, half, 91, two, 9(1, 3, 16, 13, 94, 95, 3(2, 9(1, 9(1, 92, 6, 96, 3(1, 1A, 3(1A, 2(1, 4(2, 4(2)(a, 4, 97, 3, 98, 4, 1, 6, 6, 100, 6, two, 101, 6, 102, 3, 6, 103, 3(1A, 9(1, 3, 104, 2008, 1, 50, one, 3(1A)(b, 105, 4, 3, 9(1, 9(1A, 106, 107, two, 13, 108, 4, 3, 3, 109, 3, 4, 3, 110, 1, 56, 111

PERSON: Carnwath LJ, Lordships, Herbert Cozens, Lordships, Lordships, Strathclyde, Lordships, Strathclyde, Carnwath, Sportelli, Lordships, Neuberger, Neuberger, Schedule 6, Hoffmann, Lordships, Schedule 6, Schedule 13, Schedule, Lordships, Schedule 13, 8220;(with, Schedule, Hoffmann, Schedule 6, para 4, Hoffmann, Schedule 6, Schedule, James v United Kingdom, James, Neuberger, Sportelli, Neuberger, Hoffmann, Sportelli, Mrs Sportelli, Pitts, Ms Wang, Earl Cadogan, v Sportelli, Earl Cadogan, Earl Cadogan, Hopper, Lowther v Strandberg, Lordships, Sportelli, Lands Tribunal, Bartlett QC, Schedule 6, 8220;(with, 8220;(with, para 1(A, Schedule, Schedule, Carnwath LJ, Carnwath LJ, Earl Cadogan, Carnwath LJ, 8220;with, Carnwath LJ, Carnwath LJ, Lordships, para 3(1)(c, Schedule, para 3(1)(c, Schedule, Carnwath LJ, Hoffmann, Hoffman, Schedule, Carnwath LJ, Hoffmann

ORG: Neuberger of Abbotsbury, IRC, the Lands Tribunal, Custins v Hearts of Oak Benefit Society, the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act, House, the House of Lords, market.&#8221, Neuberger, the words &#, and “buy&#8221, Reliance, Fletcher Moulton LJ, the Chesterfield Gas and Water Board, Custins v Hearts of Oak Benefit Society, Neuberger, Parliament, Custins v Hearts of Oak Benefit Society, the Court of Appeal, Bar, Lordships, Lordships, House, Parliament, Schedule 13, the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act, Neuberger of, Abbotsbury, Tribunal, Wang, Parliament, Wang, Lordships, Neuberger of Abbotsbury, the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act, Lordships, Parliament, Parliament, Parliament, Parliament, Schedule 6, Schedule 6, purchaser (&#, Lordships, Custins v Hearts of Oak Benefit Society, Schedule 13, Schedule 13, Schedule 13, House, Parliament, Parliament, Wang, Wang, NEUBERGER, ABBOTSBURY My Lords, The Court of Appeal, Sloane Gardens Ltd, Grandeden Property Management Ltd, Atlantic Telecasters Ltd, Wang, Cadogan Estates Ltd, House, the house &#8230, Lands Tribunal, the Lands Tribunal, Parliament, the words &, the house &#8230, Wang, the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act, the Lands Tribunal, a Leasehold Valuation Tribunal (&, the Lands Tribunal, the Lands Tribunal, Lloyd-Jones v Church Commissioners for England, Lloyd-Jones, the Lands Tribunal, the Lands Tribunal, Trinity College, Lands Tribunal, Leasehold Enfranchisement, Lloyd-Jones, Tribunal, the Lands Tribunal, LVT, Blendcrown Ltd v Church Commissioners for England, Lands Tribunal, and &#, Gesso Properties, Shulem B Association Ltd’s, Lloyd-Jones, LVT, The Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act, the Leasehold Reform Housing and Urban Development Act, Schedule 13, the landlord &#8230, LVT, the freeholder’s interest &#8230, LVT, the words &#, the words &#, Lordships, LVT, the Lands Tribunal, Parliament, the participles &#, and &, the Court of Appeal, the Lands Tribunal, LVT, the Court of Appeal, Lloyd-Jones, the Court of Appeal, Lloyd-Jones, the Lands Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Parliament, Tribunal, the Court of Appeal, the Lands Tribunal, Lloyd-Jones, Fox LJ, Donaldson J, F R Evans, English Electric Co Ltd, Inland Revenue Commissioners v Clay, Parliament, the words &, Schedule 13, the Court of Appeal, The Court of Appeal, Schedule 13, Parliament, the Court of Appeal, Schedule 6 result &, the Court of Appeal, and “buy&#8221, Schedule 6, the Court of Appeal, Schedule 6, Schedule 13

MONEY: #8220;third parties&#8221, 8220;buying&#8221, 8220;seeking, 8220;otherwise, 8220;absolute, 8220;as, 8220;involve, 8220;with, 8220;appropriate&#8221, 8220;(with, 8220;9(1, 8230, 8230;&#8221, 8216;a, 8216;(with, 8220, 8230, 8230;&#8221, 8220;LVT&#8221, 8220;Mr, 8230, 8220;(1D, 8230, 8220;a, 8220;Collective, 4 &#8230, 8230, 8230, 8230, 8230, 8212, 8212, 8230, 8212, 8230;.&#8221, 8220;2(1, 4 &#8230, 8230, 8230, 8230, 8220;A, 8220;(with, 8220;buying&#8221, 8220;seeking&#8221, 8220;conferred&#8221, 8220;[t]o, 8220;a, 8220;likely&#8221, 8220;willing, 8220;(with, 8220;a, 8220;seem[ed, 8220;sold, 8220;buying&#8221, 8220;buying&#8221, 8220;assumption&#8221, 8220;difficult

ORDINAL: third, third, third, first, First, first, second, third, third, first, third, first, second, first, first, second, first, first, second, second, first, 2nd, 3rd, first, First, Secondly, first, first, first, first, second, 2nd, second, first, second, First, First, Secondly

EVENT: the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1993 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1993 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1993 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act &#, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act, the 1993 Act, the 1967 Act

DATE: 1969, a later date, 1993, 2002, 4, 3. 11, 1993, 18 May 1993, 1679, 1996, 1996, 999 year, 999-year, 999-year, 29, 1969, 3(1A)(b, 3(1A)(b, 44, 1969, 1996, three years earlier, 2142, 1967, 1993, the years, 1993, 1996, annual, 1984, 1992, 272(1, 1967, 1969, 1993, twenty years, 110 years, 1993, 44, 45, 46, 48, 1986, 50, 51, 2007, 1042, 2142, 2007, 1280, 52, 53, 1969, 54, 55, 1974, 56, 1993, 58, ten years, 1982, about twelve years, the remaining 12 years, the end of the 12 years, annual, 1982, 1982, 1976, 1985, 62, 1987, 9-55, edition, 1999, 9-40, 63, 2002, 80 years, 65, 1982, 1982, 2004, 77, 2001, 1982, 2005, 2007, 1993, 72, 1993, 76, more than 80 years, 80, the day, 2008, 2142, 49, 1982, 2008, 2142, 1982, 2007, 14, 1982, 89, 1987, 1977, November 1977, 2008, 2142, the next day, 2007, 86, more than eighty years, 3(1A)(b, 2008, 2142, 54, 2142, 999-year, 999-year, 4, section 18, 2008, 2142

GPE: Re Lucas, Pitts, Pitts, Grandeden, Strasbourg, Strasbourg, Pitts, Grandeden, Gestingthorpe, Abbotsbury, Gestingthorpe, Abbotsbury, Pitts, Grandeden, Pitts, Pitts, Norfolk, Cambridge, Hague, Hague, Grandeden, Shulem, Pitts, Hague, Pitts, Gestingthorpe

TIME: 6 to that Act

NORP: Atlantic Telecasters, Atlantic Telecasters, Atlantic Telecasters, Atlantic Telecasters, Dennis

LOC: Sloane Gardens, Sloane Gardens, Sloane Gardens, Sloane Gardens

PERCENT: 50%, 5%, around 15%, 50 %, at least 50%, 50 %, 50%

PRODUCT: 210M, Schedules 6, Schedule, Para 4

FAC: Arbib v Earl Cadogan