In the Matter of : Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited Vs. Rajasthan Electricity Regulatory Commission, Jaipur and Others

Decided On : May-09-2008

Court : Appellate Tribunal for Electricity APTEL

LAW: the Electricity Act, the Limitation Act, Section 56(2, Section 86, Section 42(5, the Electricity Act, Section 86(1, Section 86(1)(e, section 86(4, Section 86(1)(e, Section 61(h, Section 86(1)(e, Section 86(1)(e, Article 2.2, Article 3.4, Article 3.4 of WB Agreement, Article 3.4 of the WB Agreement, Article 3.4 and 7.4, Article 3.4 and 7.4, the Electricity Act 2003, Section 86(1)(e, Section 86(4, the Electricity Act, units &#, the Electricity Act, Section 62 of the Act, the Limitation Act, the Limitation Act

PERSON: A.A. Khan, Manju Goel, Rajasthan, Rajasthan Vidyut, Jodhpur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd, AVVNL, JdVVNL, Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd, JVVNL, Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam, JVVNL, JVVNL, JVVNL, Art, P.N. Bhandari, Consumer, Licensee, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, Meter, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, Import Meter, Export Meter, M2, AVVNL, Export Meter, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, Purchase, AVVNL, Jaislamer, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, Kwh, Generated, AVVNL, AVVNL, Kwh, Kwh, 2400 Kwh, Kwh, lien, JVVNL, JVVNL, JVVNL, JVVNL, AVVNL, JVVNL, JVVNL, Bhandari, JVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, Kwh, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, meter, AVVNL, AVVNL, AVVNL, JVVNL, JVVNL, Appellant, JVVNL, JVVNL, 8220;There, AVVNL, Manju Goel, AVVNL, Jaipur DISCOM, Jodhur DISCOM, Billing Provision, Jhamarkotra, Rishabdev, District Jaisalmer, Pohara, District Jaisalmer, Jhamarkotra, District Udaipur, Barabagh, Pohara, Barabagh, Pohara, Jhamarkotra Mines., Jhamarkotra Mines, Udaipur, kVA, kVA, kVA, kVA, kVA, kVA, kVA 87

ORG: Judicial, Appeal, CPP, Commission, Commission, the State Government of Rajasthan, Rajasthan Electricity Regulatory Commission, Minerals Ltd., State, Captive Power, Non-Conventional Energy, Wheeling and Banking Agreement, WBA, Appellant, Purchase, Non-Conventional Energy, MW, GOR, WBA, MW, MW, RSMML, MW, RSMML, Balakrishan Industries Vs, Commission, Discoms, Power Purchase, Issues, RSMML, Commission, Issue of Jurisdiction, Appellant, Commission, Consumer Redressal Grievances Forum/Ombudsman, the Clause 3.4, CPP, NCE, Commission, Commission, National Electricity Policy, Commission, CPP, Commission, generation.&#8221, Chhattisgarh Biomass Energy Developers Association and Ors, Chhattisgarh State Electricity Regulatory Commission, Ors, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Appellant, Commission, Nigam, Emphasis, RSMML, Chhattisgarh Biomass Energy Developers Association and Ors, CSERC, Wheeling and Banking Agreements, Ministry of Non-Conventional Energy Sources, CPP, CPP, the Import and Export, Case &, = x Compare, Energy, No &#, Case &, WB, Commission, Wind Power Captive Generator, the Minimum Charges, Emphasis, MVA, the Maximum Demand, MVA, Commission, WB Agreement, COD, Commission, Industrial Tariff. &, RSMML, Delivery Points, Delivery, the Captive Consumption, Ajmer/Jodhpur Discom, RERC, Emphasis, Energy, Energy, Energy, Energy, the Jodhpur Discom/Ajmer Discom, Energy Charges of Large Industrial Service, Delivery Point, WB, Appellant, Power Purchase, WB Agreement, the Wheeling Charges, Appellant, Tariff Rate, Discoms, Wind Power, MW, GOR, Commission, WB Agreement, G Units Net, Large industrial Service Tariff, Commission, Commission, WB, WB, Table &#, i.e. &#, Table, Commission, Kwh consumption &#, Vitran Nigam, AVVNL, Commission, Commission, GOR, Commission, M/s Balkrishna, Commission, Commission, the Commission for HT-industrial, CPP, Commission, Tariff Category, CPP, Petition, Commission, Balakrishna Industries Ltd. Vs, Discoms, Discoms, Emphasis, Discoms, Discom, Emphasis, Commission, Commission, NCE, Commission, Appellant, Petitioners, M/s Balkrishan Vs, Commission, Sections 86(1)(e, Commission, the W.B. Agreements, Additional Observation and Analysis, Commission, WB, Discom, RSMML, Rupees, TABLE Without, RSMML, GOR, WB, Commission, RSMML, M/s Rajasthan Renewable Energy Corporation Ltd, Appellant, Wind Farm, Discom, Commission, And &, banked&#8221, play.&#8221, WB Agreements, Commission, RSMML, GOR, NCE, Commission, GOR, Wind Power, Commission, Respondents, Commission, Commission, Appeal, Commission, Appropriate, Appropriate Commission, Co. Ltd., Ors, AIR 1984 Calcutta 306, Supreme Court, Ester Industries Ltd., U.P. State Electricity Board, Board, SLP, Board, the High Court, Appeal, Commission, Appeal, Judicial, the Rajasthan State Electricity Board, RSEB, the Rajasthan State Electricity Board, Minerals Ltd., Barabagh, The Government of Rajasthan, Government, Rajasthan Energy Development Agency, the State Electricity Board, RSEB, RSEB, Jaipur Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Ltd., Jodhpur Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Ltd., RSEB, the Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd., RSMML, RVPNL, Ajmer/Jodhpur Discom, RERC, Energy, Energy, Energy, Energy, User, the Jodhpur Discom/ Ajmer Discom, Energy Charges of Large Industrial Service, Sanu (District Jaisalmer, Debari, MW, RSMML, Concerned Discom, Tariff Rate, Discom, RSMML, Jhamarkotra, DISCOM/AVVNL, Nov. &, Barabagh, DISCOM, Jhamarkotra, RSMML, State, DISCOM, RSMML, RSMML, Commission, Phase &#, MW, Discom, Phase &#, III, MW, Discom, Commission, RSMML, Discom, Discom, Discom, Discom, Discom, Commission, Commission, fed, Minerals Ltd., Minerals Ltd., Commission, Commission, Commission, GoR, Commission, M/s. Balakrishna Industries, Discom, Discom, upto ‘minimum energy&#8217, Commission, GoR, TABLE 13, TABLE 14, RSMML, RSMML, DISCOM, Commission, M/s. Balakrishna Industries, GoR, GoR, Commission, M/s. Balakrishna, Commission, Commission

ORDINAL: firstly, third, third, first, first, first, firstly, first, third, first, first, first, third, third, third, third, third, third, first, third, first, third, first, Firstly, Secondly, Firstly, Secondly, first, first, second, first, third, third, second, third, third, third, third, third, third, first, first, first, first, first, first

PRODUCT: Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, RVPN’s, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Agreement, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, M1 - M2, M2-M1 No, Appellant, Appellant, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, charges.&#8221, bills.&#8221, deviated.&#8221, generation.&#8221

CARDINAL: 3, 2, 2., 124, 100, 100, 3, 2, 4.0, 4.9, 16, 5.0, 2x4.9, 4, 101, 101, 7, 5, 6, 8, 2, 9, 24, 7.4, 3, 5.2.26, 10, 20, 11, 12, 2, 13, 5(a, 5(b, 3.4, 7.4, 5(a, 14., one, 15, 16, 17, 18, 04, 19, 20, 91.54, 21, two, two, 13, 22, 22, One, 22, NCE-, 23, 0, 25, 5, 2, 26, 2, 27, 2, 2, 2, 24, 6, 6, 29, 2, 33, one, 27(a, 200, 28, 20, 10, 12, 13, 300, 280, 120, 30, 20, 300-280, 107, 20, 87, 27, 32, 280, 120, 300, 300-280, 20, 20, 107, 87, 107-20, 300, 180, 180, 107, 107, 180, 33, 3600, 522, 522, 87, 107, 87, 13, 2, two, 32, two, 37, 38, 2, 2, 39, 1(iv, 2.2, 3.4, 7.4, 1, 2, 5(i, 7(i, 64, 2, 3, 41, 64, 2, 2, 5, 2, 10.46, 6.13, 10.46, 6.13, 5, 5, 2, 47, 48, 12, 13, 522, two, one, 31.01.2005, two, 2, 2, 1, 2, 3, 4, 2, two, 50, 2, 2, 2, two, 10, 51, 2, 2, 52, 53, 300, 280, 20, 107, 87, 280, 193, 87, 2, 55, 5600, 280, 5320, 5320, 3724, 87, 1596, 87, 56, 2, 27(d, 57, 101, one, 101, two, 62, 1, 2, 3, one, 59, one, equity.&#8221, 60, 11, 199, 61., 29 to 47, 62, 100, 63, 100, 13.04.2007, 2, No.2, No.2, No.2, No.2, 04.02.2000, No.2, 04.02.2000, three, No.2, No.2, 3, 4, 16.04.03, 5, 5, two, two, two, 100/06, 6, two, 7, 9.80, 5.9, 8), 6, 9, 5, 29.8.2001, 10, 3000, 2952, 316549, 388080, more than 71531, 316549, 2,00,000, 388080, 2,00,000, 1,88,080, 316549, 3,16,549, 71,531, 2,00,000, 4,01,320, 3,85,080, 16,240, 26.4.2005, 11, 300, 280, 120, 107, two, 300, 107, 12, two, two, two, 107, 107, 280, 15, 3,88,080- 3,16,549, 71,531, 2,00,000, 16

DATE: 2003, 13 Apr. 07, 2007, 04 Nov. 2006, 2006, 2006, 1984, 06 Feb. 02, 04 Feb. 2000, 29 Aug. 01, 19 Feb. 2004, 04 Feb. 00, 30 Apr. 03, Aug. 2001, 04 Feb. 00, 29 Aug. 01, May 02, Mar 04, Apr. 03, 19 Feb. 04, 2006, 25 Jul. 06, 2006, 21 Sep. 04, Oct. 2005, Nov. 2005, 2003, 2003, 13 later, 19 Feb. 04, 01, Oct. 05, 04 Nov. 06, Sep. 06, 2003, 2003, 2003, 06 Feb. 2002, 29Aug., 2001, 19 Feb. 2004, 29 Aug. 01, 19 Feb. 2004, Oct. 2005, six months, six months, Mar. 05, Nov. 2005, the next month, Nov. 05, monthly, 04 Nov. 2005, July 02 to Aug. 03, Feb. 05 to Oct. 05, Sep. 06, annually, the first two quarters of the year, the last two quarters of the year or, annual, the end of December, the year, 24, 29 Aug. 01, 19 Feb. 04, 1984, August 2001, 15 Apr. 1984, every year, five years, from year to, 06 Feb. 02, twenty years, ten years, 05 Dec. 02, the financial year, monthly, any month, that month, two months, monthly, 19 Feb 04, monthly, monthly, 2003, an year, the year, 1984, eL +, Aug. 2001, the preceding month, 20-10, eL +, Minimum Charges&#8217, eL +, eL +, eL +, eL +, 29, 04 Nov. 06, Monthly, first six months, next six months, month, monthly, first three years, 30 years, 1st month to 6 month, 7th Months to 12th months, first six months, / month, /month, successive months, 34, 35, 2003, 28 Aug. 2000, 19 Feb. 04, 61, 62, 40, 2003, 42, 61, 62, 2003, Nov. 05, 44, every month, monthly, 45, every month, 46, every month, a single month, every month, a single month, the month of July, August, September, 2002, months, the above months, each month, all the months, Nov. 05, 49, 28.01.2006, monthly, 15.04.2008, 54, 1596, 1509, three years, 2006, 2006, 2003, 58, the first three years, 1996, three years, 1963, 2006, 2006, 15th April, 1984, 15th April, 1984, 03.04.2003, 29.08.2001, a financial year, 2003, 20 years, a financial year, the financial year, monthly, any month, that month, two months, a year, annually, 19th February, 2004, monthly, monthly, monthly, any month, future months, November 2005, monthly, same month, subsequent month, that year i.e., December of that year, 25th July, 2006, 31st December, a month, the billing month of, April 05, the first six months, the rest of the months, monthly, the year, the 1st and 2nd quarter, the 3rd and 4th quarter of the year, April 05

GPE: Rajasthan State Mines and, Govt, Jaisalmer, Rajasthan, Discoms, Discoms, EA, energy.&#8221, Jan., Jun., Jul., Govt, India, Jodhpur Discom, Billing, Wheeled, Regulation, D.O., M.D., District Udaipur, Rajasthan State Mines and, Jaisalmer, Rajasthan, the Jodhpur DISCOM, the Jodhpur DISCOM, District Udaipur, Rajasthan, the Rajasthan State Mines and, Rajasthan State Mines and, JVVNL…

MONEY: as &#, 8216;RSMML&#8217, 8216;RVPN&#8217, 8216;Banking&#8217, #8220;…………….the Commission, 8220;……………it, 8220;……….it, as &#, no &#, 8220;Banking, 8211;I, 8211;II, 8211, 8220;The, 132 KV GSS, 8220;The, 8220;……&#8230, 8230;, 8211;(Energy, 8220;7.4, less than &#, 8216;units, 8211;I, 8211, 8216;generator&#8217, 8216;generator&#8217, 8220;Ideally, 8230;……………&#8230, 8220;we, 8220;while, 8220;The, 8216;captive, 8216;Captive, 8211;II, 8211;D, 8220;it, 8220;The, 8211, 8230;……………………………&#8230, 8230;……………………………&#8230, 8230;……………&#8230, 8220;In, 8220;3.4, 8217;05, 8220;5, 8220;14, 388080 &#, 3,88,080 &#, 8230

PERCENT: 95%, 5%, 75%, 25%, 5%, 95%, 5%, 5%, about 70%, 30%, 30%, 60%, 5%, 5%, 5%, 2%, 95%, 5%, 5%, 60%, 2% to 10%, 95%, 5%, the entire 5%, 5%, about 30%, 30%, 95%, 65%, 5%, 30%, 2% or, 10%, 60%, 2%, 10%, 2%, 95%, 5%, 10%, 75%, 25%, 95%, 5%, 60%, 10%, about 70%, 30%

FAC: Appellant, Power Producer, Power Producer

NORP: Captive, Balakrishan, Captive

LOC: Captive, Captive, Captive, the Respondent No.2, Respondent, Village Pohara

WORK_OF_ART: Demand (Fixed) Charges and Energy Charges, the Fixed Cost, HT Consumer Agreement, WB Agreement, HT-Agreement, Electricity Generation from Wind, Electricity Duty, 04.11.2006 in Petition No

QUANTITY: Two meters, 107