Dr. Md. Asrarul Haque (Scientist F (Retd) and Others Vs. Union of India Through Ministry of Environment and Forests Through Itand#8217;s Secretary, Paryavaran Bhawan, Cgo Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi and Another

Decided On : May-22-2012

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

LAW: the Promotion Panels

PERSON: Ramesh, Chandra Panda, Anr, S.K. Murti, V.S. Rao Chintala, Anr, S.K. Murti, Shri R. K. Kapoor, Shri R.K. Kapoor, V.S. Rao, D.S. Mahendru, Shri Mahendru, Shri Mahendru, Grade-G., O.M. No.2/41/97-PIC, M.A. Haque, Haque, Haque, Shri Rajiv Sinha, A.K. Tyagi, Shri Mahendru, Naseem Ahmed, Grade, Grade, Shri Mahendru, Grade, Madhumita Biswas, Geography, Husain Ahmad, V.S. Rao, V.S. Rao

CARDINAL: 1, Six, 2, 29.06.2011, two, 3, 4, 5, 6, 2., 3., follow./sd/(ALOK, 7, 10, 3      &nbsp, 4  &nbsp, 5&nbsp, 6    &nbsp, 7      &nbsp, 8, 85%  &nbsp, 80%  &nbsp, 70%  &nbsp, 65%  &nbsp, 60%  &nbsp, 85% &nbsp, 80% &nbsp, 75%  &nbsp, 70%  &nbsp, 85% &nbsp, 80%  &nbsp, 75%  &nbsp, 70%  &nbsp, 80%  &nbsp, 75%  &nbsp, 80%  &nbsp, 75%  &nbsp, 10, 8, 9, 7.9.1984, 31.3.2001, 1.1.2006, 28.7.2002, 27.7.2008, 9.1, 10, 30.8.1996, 16.6.2000, 27.6.2004, 22.4.2010, 30.08.1996, 16.6.2000, two, 10.1, 11, 30.01.1995, 1.1.1999, 1.1.2000, 1.1.2003, 1.1.2004, 6.9.2004, 1.1.2009, 31.12.2009, 11.1, 12, 01.01.2000, 30.12.2001, 30.09.2015, 12.1, 13, 1.7.1994, 1.7.2000, 9.5.2006, 1.7.2000, 13.1, 1.7.2000, 01.07.2000, 6, 6.1.1989, 1.7.2004, 1.7.2004, 4.4.2005, 14.1, 1.7.2010, 15, half, 15, 16, 16, 17, 18, 9, 14.1, 19

ORG: Original Application under Section 19, FCS, Supreme Court, Union of India, Tribunal, Scientist B/C/D, FCS, the Assessment Board, the Government of India and Ors, Union of India, Special Leave to Appeal (Civil, Supreme Court, Annexure A-10 and Annexure A-11, Government, FCS, FCS, Tribunal, Learned Counsel, Shri T.N. Tripathi, FCS, FCS, FCS, Supreme Court, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Original Application, Tribunal, Central Government, FCS, Departmental Screening Committee, DSC, Departmental Review Committee, FCS, FCS, DSC, DSC, DSC, DSC, DRC, Government Department, OA, FCS, the Flexible Complementing Scheme (, the Government of India, the Department of Personnel and Training, DOPT, Departments, the Ministry of Environment and Forest, Scheme, Office Memorandum, DOPT, FCS, Grade-A, the Department of Personnel and Training, DOPT, OM, Respondents, DOPT OM, Counsel for the Respondents, OM, FCS, IndiaMinistry of Personnel, Public Grievances, Scientific, Departments-Date, the Fifth Central Pay Commission, Department, Department, FCS, FCS, FCS, the Selection Committee/Assessment Board, the Selection Committee/Assessment Board, the Government of India, FCS, Scientists under FCS, Departmental Screening Committee, Departmental Review Committee, Salient, DSC, DRC, FCS, DRC, DSC, Scientist &, Scientist &, the Grade of Scientist &, Scientist &, the Grade of Scientist &, DSC, Scientist &, DSC, FCS, Government, Government, the Ministry as Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, FCS, Scientist Grade &, Government, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, DSC, DRC, Scientist &, Scientist &#, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, DRC, Scientist &, FCS, the Scientist &, the Grade &, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientists is Scientist &, FCS, Scientist &, the Scientist &, Tribunal, the Grade of Scientist &, the Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, O.M., Natural/Agricultural Sciences, FCS, FCS, Natural Science, Scientist &, Geography, Natural Science, FCS, the Scientist &, Promotion under FCS, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, FCS, DSC, Scientist &, DSC, DSC, DRC, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist &, DSC, DSC, DRC, Scientist &, Scientist &, Scientist, Tribunal, FCS, Respondents, Respondents, FCS, Respondents, Respondents, FCS, Respondents, Committee/Board, The Original Application, Respondents, Bench, Departments, FCS, Committees, DSC, DRC

DATE: 1985, 2296/2009, 09.11.1998, 14.10.1999, 1st January or, 1st July, 01.05.2006, 30.05.2011, 01.06.2011, 11.07.2011, 2296/2009, 6864/2011, six months to six years, 09.11.1998, years, 2296/2009, 04.08.2010., 9.11.1998, 1st January and 1st July, 17.7.2002, 9.11.1998, year-before, January and 1st, July, 1st January and 1st July, five years, Number of years, one year, at least 5 years, a year i.e. before 1st January and 1st July, one year, 1.6.1989, 5 years, 1.7.1999, 5 years, 1.1.2010, four years, 2006-07, 2007-08, 2008-09, 2009-10, 2006, July 2002, July 2008, Applicant No.2, five years, the year 2001, the year 2006, 6 years, 16.10.1989, 5 years, five years, 1.1.2001, 1.1.2002, five years residency period, three years, 2006-07, 2007-08, 2008-09, December, 2009, about 10 years, 1999, 2003, the years from 2000 to 2003, 6.9.2009, 31.12.2009, three years, 6.9.2009, 26.02.1990, four years, 10 months, 5 years, 6 years, 11 months, 5 years, 5 years, 6 months, 5 years, 2000, 2000, the year 2000, 1.7.1999, 10.1.1998, 12.12.2000 to 28.2.2005, 1.3.2005, 20.02.2007, 09.05.2006, 09.05.2006, 14, five years, 1.7.1999, five years, 1.7.2000, 1.7.2001, 1.7.2002, 1.7.2003, 1.7.2010, July, 2010, 1.7.1999, 5 years 7 months, 1.7.1999, 1.7.2000, 1.7.2001, 1.7.2002, 1.7.2003, 1.7.1999, the earlier years, 1st January or 1st July, months, 1st January or 1st July, a period of, three months, a period of, three months

MONEY: 8220;(a, 100 marks, 8216;Outstanding&#8217, 80 marks, 60 marks, 8216;Good&#8217, 40 marks, 8216;Average&#8217, 0 marks, 8216;Poor&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;G&#8217, 8216;G&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;C&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;G&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;C&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;G&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;B&#8217, 8216;C&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;D&#8217, 8216;E&#8217, 8216;G&#8217, 8216;G&#8217, 8216;G&#8217, 8220;14

GPE: OA, OA, OA, OA, S.K., no.4, OA, OA, Grades, OA, Grades, OA, OA, OA

WORK_OF_ART: Flexible Complementing Scheme (FCS, the Paper Book, the Flexible Complementing Scheme (FCS

FAC: the Gazette Notification

LOC: Scientist, Scientist

NORP: Scientists, Scientists, Scientists, Scientists, Geography

ORDINAL: 4th, 4th, 01.01.1995

PERCENT: 60%, 60%, 70%, 70%

PRODUCT: Scientist F to Scientist G   &nbsp