Mspl Gases Limited Rep. by Its Senior Manager (Sales) Mr. D. Ramesh Babu Vs. Steel Authority of India Limited Through Its Executive Director (Operations) and ors.

Decided On : Dec-01-2008

Court : Chennai

LAW: Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 14 of the Constitution, Section 1 of second, Article 14, Article 226 of The Constitution of India, Section 18 of the Act, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 153 of Draft, the Net Present Value 4, the Net Present

PERSON: A. Kulasekaran, Oxygen, Law, Law, Principal Law Officer, Principal Law Officer, AL, Oxygen, ini, S. Partap Singh v. State of, E.P. Royappa v. State of T.N.ii, Anr, AIR2004SC1962, Para Nos, Wednesbury, Harminder Singh Arora v. Union, Vijay Narayan, Praxair, Oxygen, Praxair, Jagdeep Dhankar, Nos, Para Nos, Singhara Singh, Taylor, Taylor, Para Nos, G.D. Zalani, Anr, R. Krishnamoorthy, Principal Law Officer, Sadhu Ram, Para Nos, Singh v. Bagun Sumbrui, Harishankar, Habibullah Basha, SAIL, Dasturco, Dasturco, Harpal Singh Chauhan v. State, Anr, AIR2007SC119, AIR2004SC1962, Harminder Singh Arora v. Union, Para Nos, Gases, Oxygen, max, LP Nitrogen, max, max, Gases, Oxygen, Gases, Anr, Oxygen, Rs, Oxygen, Nitrogen, Rs, Seller, SAIL, Sadhu Ram

NORP: J.1, Mandamus, Hazaribagh, Mandamus

ORDINAL: first, second, first, first, first, first, first, fifth, fourth, fourth, fifth, fifth, second, second, second, fifth, fifth, fifth, second, second, first, second, fourth, fourth, fourth, fourth, second, fifth, fifth, second, fifth, second, fourth, first, second, third, third, fourth, third, third, second, second, third, third, fourth, second, first, fifth, fifth, second, second, fifth, second, first, first, first, fifth, second, third, second, second, second, first, first, second, first, fifth, third, fifth, third, second, third, second, third, second, third, second, second, second, fourth, second, fifth, fifth, fourth, third, fifth, fifth, fifth, fifth, 5th, second, fifth, second, third, second, fifth, second, fourth, third, fourth, fifth, fourth, fourth, second, fifth, fourth, fifth, third, first, fifth, first, second, fourth, second, fifth, fifth, fifth, fifth, second, second, third, third, first, second, first, first, first, second, first, second, first, first, fourth, second, fifth, second, third, fifth, second, first, first, fifth, fifth, fifth, second, fifth, second, fifth, fourth, fifth, first, second, first, fifth, fifth, third, fifth, fifth, fifth, fifth, first, second, fifth, fifth, second, fifth, third, third, fourth, third, third, fourth, second, second, second, second, fourth, fourth, fourth, fourth, fourth, second, fourth, fourth, fifth, fifth, fifth, second, fifth, fifth, fifth, fifth, fifth, second, first, first, second, first, third, second, third, first, second, third, fourth, first, first, third, fourth, fourth, fourth, first, first, second, fourth, fourth, second, fifth, fifth, fourth, fifth, fifth, fifth, fourth, second, second, 2nd, second, third, second, third, second, third, second, third, third, fifth, fourth, second, third, fifth, fifth, fifth, fifth, second, third, fifth, third, fifth, third, second, first, second, third, fifth, third, second, third, fifth, fifth, second, third, fifth, second, fifth, fifth, fifth, fifth, second, second, third, fourth, third, third, fourth

ORG: Steel Authority of India, the Government of India, Salem Steel Plant, Salem Steel Plant on Build-Own-Operate, BOO, Nitrogen, Argon, SMS, the Net Present Value, NPV, ASP, BOO, EAF, LF, AOD, SMS, ASP, BOO, ASP, ASP, the Plant Level Tender Committee, ASP, BOO, EAF, LF, AOD, ASP, BOO, M/s. Prag Air, the Techno-Evaluation Committee, Commercial Evaluation Committee, NPV, DGM, Salem Steel, Argon, 11500 NM3, DGM, Salem Steel, 02.02.2008, Corporate Office, ASP, NPV, ASP, ASP, W.P. No, W.P. No, Nitrogen, Argon, W.P. Nos, the Honourable Supreme Court, Delhi Development Authority, UEE Electricals Engineering, the Honourable Supreme Court, Court, Authority of India and Ors, the Honourable Supreme Court, Noble Resources Ltd., the Honourable Supreme Court, State, Directorate of Education, Educomp Datamatics Ltd., Ors, the Honourable Supreme Court, Government, Court, Tata Cellular v. Union of India, the Honourable Supreme Court, State, State, the State Government, State, The High Court, un, Nitrogen, Argon, NPV, NM3/day, CENVAT &amp, Oxygen, HP-Nitrogen &amp, Argon, Net Present Value, NPV, Ramchandra Murarilal Bhattad and Ors, the Honourable Supreme Court, Reliance, State, U.P., Court, Authority, Authority, the Executive Committee, Authority, the Executive Committee, Authority, Centre for Public Interest Litigation v. Union of India, the Honourable Supreme Court, Court, Union of India, the Honourable Supreme Court, ASP, Steel Melting Shop, SMS, ASP, SMS, ASP, ASP, the Executive Directors, the Board of Directors, Board, NPV, ASP, Judicial, Haryana State Agricultural Marketing Board, Ors, Board, Board, the High Court, Board, the Divisional Forest Officer, the Conservator of Forest, Industrial Oxygen Company Ltd., Air Products, AP, M/s. MSPL, Ref, Daturco, SAIL-SSP, Court, Build Own Operate, BOO, Oxygen, Nitrogen, Argon, U.P., AIR 1975, Court, Court, Court, Tata Cellular v. Union of India, Delhi Development Authority, UEE Electricals Engineering, Court, ASP, EAF, LF, AOD, SMS, ASP, the Techno-Evaluation Committee, Commercial Evaluation Committee, Oxygen, Nitrogen, Argon, the Honourable Supreme Court, Delhi Development Authority, UEE Electricals Engineering, Authority of India and Ors, Noble Resources Ltd., Directorate of Education, Educomp Datamatics Ltd., Ors, State, SSP, SAIL-ASP, Durgapur, Argon, BOO, Argon, NM 2, Argon, KG, 825 NM3/hr, Price Bids, Nitrogen, VAT, SSP, SSP, Fixed Facility, the Feed Air Compressor, Fund Air Compressor, Argon, Argon, Argon, Nitrogen, 825 NM3, The Evaluation Criteria, Net Present Value, Net of CENVAT &, TNVAT, Price, CENVAT &amp, Oxygen, HP-Nitrogen &amp, Argon, Net Present Value, NPV, Oxygen, Argon, Argon, Court, Court, Delhi Development Authority, UEE Electricals Engineering, Authority of India and Ors, Court, SSP, Haryana State Agricultural Marketing Board, Ors, NPV

PERCENT: 85%, 15%, 50% to 105%, 99.8%, 50%, 75%, 5%, 10%, 5%, 10%

DATE: 13.03.2007, 13.03.2007, 09.05.2007, 12.07.2007, fifteen years, 13.08.2007, 15.10.2007, 15 years, 10.01.2008, 11.01.2008, 15 years, 16.01.2008,, 18.01.2008, 19.01.2008, 21.01.2008, 15.01.2008, daily, 12.11.2007, 01.02.2008, 13.11.2007, the last date as, 23.02.2008, 2008, 2008, 12.11.2007, 1125, daily, daily, para-11, para-14, days, days, the days, daily, 15) years, 47, 55, 58, 2002, 20 years, 2000)8SCC606, 1995, 34, 13.03.2007, 12.07.2007, 23 months, 24 months, 5, 15.03.2008, 2006, 20th December, 2004, 20th of December 2004, 8th of July 2004, 8th July 2004, October 26, 1970, October 26, 1970, November 28, 1970, October 26, 1970, October 26, 1970, November 3, 1970, 1963, 20.03.2008, 30th January 2008, daily, 13.12.2007, 12.11.2007, 2436, interfere.11, 18 months to 23 months, 10.01.2008, 11.01.2008, daily, 16.01.2008,, 18.01.2008, 19.01.2008, 21.01.2008, 16.01.2008,, 22.01.2008, 15.01.2008, 21.01.2008, daily, 358 days, 7 days, monthly, oxygen per day, 51600, 22500, 11500, day, 19800, fifteen (15) years, days, 7 days of annual, 15) years, 15 years, 18.01.2008

CARDINAL: six, two, one, three, one, 15.10.2007, 1, 3, 14.11.2007.(iv, 2, 3, 4, three, three, 1, 3, three, three, three, 14.01.2008, 1, 3, 14.01.2008, three, 1, 3, 22.01.2008, 16.01.2008, 23.01.2008, 14.01.2008, 21.01.2008, 23.02.2008, 84,000, 9.2, 20.54, 11200, 20, 2, 19600, 35, 1, 3, 23.02.2008, 1, 3, three, 04.02.2008, 22.02.2008, 22.02.2008, 22.02.2008, 22.02.2008.(xi, 23.02.2008, 23.02.2008, 22.03.2008, 31.03.2008, 23.02.2008, three, 31.07.2008, 1, 3, 1, 3, 30.01.2008, 1, 3, 1, 3, 30.01.2008, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1, 3, 31.01.2008, 1, 3, 30.01.2008, 16, 62, four, one, 687-88, 94)94, 1986]3SCR63, 30.01.2008, 2.0, three, three, 14.01.2008, 10, 30.01.2008, 1, 3, 22.02.2008, 30.01.2008, 1, 3, 6426, 2008.4, 39 and 40, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1, 3, 30.01.2008, 30.01.2008, 1, 2, 1, 2, 1, 2, 1, 2, three, fifteen, 69, 13 and 20, 2, 3, 25.10.2007, 5.75, 1, 3, 21, 5, 1, 3, 1, 3, one, three, 14.01.2008, 15.01.2008, 18.01.2008, 16.01.2008, 1, 2, 1, 3, 22.02.2008, 30.01.2008, 1, 3, 2, 20.03.2008, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1900, 1, 3, 1, 3, 2, 3, 12, 15, one, 1972]3SCR629, more than 30, 1, 2, 1, 3, 30.01.2008, 20.03.2008, 20.03.2008, 23.02.2008, Three, 1, 3, 1, 3, three, three, 14.01.2008, 14.01.2008, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1986]3SCR63, 1, 3, 30.01.2008, 1, 2, 22.01.2008, 14.01.2008, 57 to 68, 1, 3, one, 1, 3, two, 99.6, 2, 1200, 2, 2, 250, 5, 22, 1200, 36, 35, two, two, II, 224, 1200, II, 84,000, 120, 73.71, 24, 28,800, 36, 28,125, 24, 20.5, 1, 3, three, one, three, 358, three, fifteen, three, 4.86, 4.86, one, 1, 2, 1, 3, 20.03.2008, 1, 3, 20.03.2008, 20.03.2008, 1, 3, 30.01.2008, 1, 3, 1, 2, 30.01.2008, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1, 1, 3, 1,900, 1, 3, 1, 3, 1, 3, 14.01.2008, 15.01.2008, 16.01.2008, 1, 2, 23.02.2008, three, 1, 3, 1, 2, 1, 3, 1, 3

GPE: L1, New Delhi, W.A., Orissa, W.A., GMGGL, Argon, WP, New Delhi, India, Orissa, Argon, Argon, p.a., Argon, p.a.

TIME: hourly, 24 hours, 24 hours, hourly, 9 and, minutes, hourly, hourly, hourly, 24 hours, 24 hours, hourly, hourly, hourly, hourly, 24 hour

EVENT: NM3/day, NM3/day, NM3 Argon Gas, NM3/hour, US Dollar 9 billion, NM3/day

FAC: 75600 NM3/day, Para No, Para No, Para No, Para No, Para No, Reliance Airport Developers, Reliance Airport

PRODUCT: Consultant, Suppl SCC 512, 3500 NM3/hr, HP Nitrogen, 3500 NM3/hr, HP Nitrogen as 28800, HP Nitrogen

QUANTITY: 24 kg, 22 kg, 7.9 kg

MONEY: 35.35 TPD)11,500