Union of India Vs. Glaxo India Ltd. and anr.

Decided On : Mar-30-2011

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Betamethasone 17, the Essential Commodities Act, Para 7(2)(a, the Essential Commodities Act, Section 6, Section 6, Para 27, Paras 12, Paras 3, Para 12

ORG: Drug Prices, the Central Government, Glaxo India Ltd., the Drug Prices Equalization Account, DPEA, The Respondent-Company, Betamethasone Alcohol, B.V., Betamethasone di Sodium Phosphate, B.P., the Respondent-Company, The Central Government, The Central Government, Government, the Central Government, The Respondent-Company, the High Court, the High Court, the High Court, the High Court, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, Order, the Respondent-Company, the High Court, the High Court, Court, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Delhi High Court, the Central Government, the "Murthy Committee, Committee, the High Court, the Central Government, Bulk Drugs, S. Name Declared, Vide Vide Vide Notification, Betamethasone, Betamethasone, D-Sodium Phosphate Pursuant, the Union of India, DPEA, Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the High Court, the Central Government, DPEA, the High Court, the Union of India, the High Court, The High Court, the Central Government, the Division Bench, the High Court, the Central Government, Court, The High Court, the Union of India, Division Bench, the High Court, the Appellant - Union of India11, Additional Solicitor General Shri, the High Court, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the High Court, the Murthy Committee, the Respondent-Company, Court, Union of India v. Cyanamide India Ltd., the Union of India, the Delhi High Court, the Murthy Committee, the Review Petition, the Respondent-Company, the Review Petition, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the Review Petition, the Respondent-Company, the High Court, the Respondent-Company, DPEA, the Respondent-Company, Court, Court, Concap Capacitators, Court, Government, DPEA, the Respondent-Company, DPEA, the Central Government, DPEA, the Central Government, Cyanamide, the Respondent- Company, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company's, Government, the Respondent-Company, Murthy Committee, the High Court, the Murthy Committee, the Respondent-Company, Committee, Committee, Committee, the Division Bench, the High Court, Committee, the High Court, the Central Government, the Review Petition, the Respondent-Company, Government, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, DPEA, the Respondent- Company, DPEA, the Central Government, DPEA, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the Respondent-Company, the Respondent-Company, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the High Court, the Central Government, the Bureau of Indian Standards, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the High Court, The First Judgment of the Delhi High Court19, Additional Solicitor General, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Division Bench, the Central Government, Order, The High Court, the High Court, the Central Government, the Review Petition, the Murthy Committee, the Murthy Committee, the High Court, The Murthy Committee, the Respondent-Company, Committee, Parliament, the Murthy Committee, The High Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, Court, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the High Court, The High Court, the Central Government, the Delhi High Court, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the Central Government, The Central Government, Respondent Company, the Respondent-Company, Review Petition, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, DPEA, the Central Government, The Respondent-Company, the High Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, The High Court, Respondents, inter alia, the High Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, The High Court, the Respondent- Company, The Central Government, Government, the Judgment of Delhi High Court, the Respondent-Company, the High Court, Court, the Central Government, the Respondent Company, the Respondent- Company, DPEA, the Respondent-Company, the High Court, The Central Government, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the Central Government, Drug Prices Equalization Account, DPEA, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Delhi High Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government under Drugs, the Government of India, Ministry of Petroleum, Chemicals and, Fertilizers (Department of Chemicals, Phosphate, Central Government, Table, the Bulk Drug Maximum, Betamethasone Alcohol, Betamethasone, the Central Government, the Government of India No, Government, the Respondent-Company, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, Third New International Dictionary, `the State of being superseded, Advanced Law Lexicon, Court, State, Titaghur Paper Mills Company Ltd., AIR 1980, Orissa Sales Tax Act, Court, Titaghur, AIR 1945 Oudh214, L.J. 372, the Sugar (Movement Control, the Sugar (Movement Control) Order, AIR 1955 NUC, DPEA, Government, this Court in Cyanamide's, Government, the Central Government, the High Court, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, Court, the Respondent-Company, Court, the Respondent-Company, Court, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, Court, the Central Government, Court, Central Government, Court, Court, the Murthy Committee, the High Court, the Respondent-Company, the Respondent-Company, the Murthy Committee, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Murthy Committee, the Respondent-Company, the Central Government, the Respondent-Company, the Delhi High Court, First Schedule, Government, Government, the Drug Prices Equalisation Account, Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, Drug Prices Equalisation Account, DPEA, the Central Government, First Schedule, DPEA, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, DPEA, The Respondent-Company, the Respondent-Company, The Respondent-Company, the High Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, the High Court, Court, the Respondent-Company, the Respondent-Company, DPEA, DPEA, DPEA, the Central Government, Government, Colguhoun, Brooks, AC 493, Phillips India Ltd., Labour Court, visceribus, Coke, Punjab Beverages Pvt. Ltd., the High Court, Central Government, the High Court, the High Court, DPEA, Central Government, Equalisation Account, Betamethasone, 25th August, Rs.23.62, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court, Industrial Costs, the High Court, S.No.17, Ministry, Hon'ble High Court, Betamathasone, Sd./-(J.L., the High Court, Court, DPEA, DPEA, DPEA, Emphasis, the Central Government, DPEA, the Central Government, DPEA, the Central Government, The Central Government, DPEA, the Central Government, the High Court, the High Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, the High Court, the Central Government

DATE: 02.01.1989, 1970, 1970, 1979, 1970, 1979, 12.05.1981, 12.05.1981, 1981, 27.08.1981, 12.05.1981, 12.05.1981, 13.05.1982, 12.05.1981, 20.11.1986, 12.05.1981, 31.08.1987, 1981, 12.10.1988, 02.01.1989, 1989, 1970, 12.05.1981, 20.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 1970, 113.34, the period 12.05.1981 to 25.08.1987, 18.06.1990, 18.06.1990 and 16.11.1990, 1990, 1981, 1979, 19.10.2001, 1981, 02.01.1989, 12.05.1981, 1979, 1979, 02.01.1989, 1979, C.W.P. 1551 of 1981, 1990, 1980-81, 1984-85, 12.05.1981, 1987, 2.1.1989, 1987, 20.11.1986, 20.11.1986, 12.05.1981, Para 7(2)(a, 1979, 2.1.1989, 1979, 1997, 2007, 2009, Para 7(2)(a, 1979, 1979, 1979, Para 7(2)(a, 1987, 1979, 1987, 1979, 12.05.1981, 1981, 5 years from 1981 to 1985, 1981, 1985, 1986, 1986, 12.5.1981, 02.01.1989, 12.5.1981, 1986, between 1981 and, 1984-85, 1986-87, the year 1986, 16.11.1990, 20.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 1979, 1979, 1979, 1987, 16.11.1990, 25.08.1987, 1987, 16.11.1990, 02.01.1989, 02.01.1989, 18, 1981, 1986, 20-11- 1986, ten days, ten days, ten days, annual, 15 days, two weeks, 1979, 2.1.1989, 20.11.1986, 26.11.1986, 1980-81, 85, the later years, 26.11.1986, the year 1981, 2.1.1989, the year 1981 to 1985, 12.5.1981, 2.1.1989, 26.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 1979, 1979, 1970, 1979, 12.05.1981, 23.06.1981, 29.06.1981, 1970, 12.05.1981, 1551 of 1981, a later date, 01.07.1981, 12.05.1981, 20.11.1986, 31.08.1987, 20.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 1987, 12.05.1981, 18.06.1990, 31.08.1987, 18.06.1990 and 16.11.1990, 2170 of 1990, 1955, 1970, 1979, Para 17, 12.05.1981, 21.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 1987, 1987, the 12th May, 1981, the 12th May, 1981, 02.01.1989, 12.05.1981, 02.01.1989, 1989, 26.11.1986, from 12th day of May, 1981, 1293, December 29, 1977, December 29, 1977, 1987, 12th day of May, 1981, 1979, 1963, 1959, November, 1959, 1959, 27th July, 1959, 2769, 20.11.1986, 1979, fifteen days, 1979, 12, 13, 1986, 20.11.1986, 20.11.1986, 20.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 1989, 20.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 20.11.1986, 02.01.1989, the period 12.05.1981 to 25.08.1987, 20.11.1986, 35, 1979, 1979, 1979, 1979, 1979, Para 17, 1979, the month of June, 1990, November, 1990, 20.11.1986, 02.01.1989, 12.05.1981, 20.11.1986, 1979, 1979, 1979, 1979, 1889, 1985, 1978, 1979, 12.05.1981, 16th November, 1990, the 17th September, 1990, 1987, 12th May, 1981, 30th June, 1981, May, 1981, 12th May, 1981, 12th May, 1981 to, 30th June, 1981, the 20th September, 1990, the 9th August, 1990, 25th August, 1987, 1979, 1979, 18.06.1990 and 16.11.1990, 20.11.1986, 1979, 1979, 1979

CARDINAL: 20.11.1986.ii, 71.21, three, 3(2, 4, 1979.5, three, 6, 20.11.1986, three, 20.11.1986, 12.05.81, 20.11.86, 1, 127.70 144.19, 17, 225.00, 135.00 144.58, 66.35, 71.21, 7(2)(a, 1551, 1981.9, two, 2, 720, 2.1.1989, 12, 5, 536, 8, 10, 1987.Submissions, 20.11.1986, 15, 71.21, 17, 71.21, 20.11.1986, 19, 26-11-1986, 18, 20-11-1986, 18, 20-11-1986, 3, 20-11-1986, 71.21, 15 to 19, 20.11.1986, 20.3.1989, 3 to 17, 5, 14, three, 01.07.1981, three, 1, 3, three, 20.11.1986, 66.35, 71.21, 24, three, three, three, three, 12.05.1981.26, 1, 3, 17, 1, 3, 3, 2, 144.192, 136.503, 144.58"Phosphate27, 28, one, 29, 1, 30, 27, 3,4,5,6,7,9,12,13,14,15, 16, 27, 13, one, 3, 02.01.1989, 7, 1, 2, 17, two, 1, 2, two, 38, 20.11.1986, 17(2, 3, 7(2)(a)was, 7(2)(a, formulations.40, 14, 3, 15, one, 2, 20.11.1986, 43, 8, 8, 5, two, 18, 6, 3 to 9, 17, 3, 17, 10 and 11, 7(2, 7(2)(b, 1979.46, 17

GPE: B.A., Delhi, Delhi, Delhi, Mafatlal, Delhi, Titaghur, Titaghur Mills, R.S., Para-7, DPEA.39, Rs.33.53

FAC: Schedule II, the Official Gazette

PRODUCT: Para 3(i, Para 3(1, Para 7(2)(a, Para 7(2, Shri, Para 14, Para 15, Para 7(2)(a, Para 17, Para 7(2)(a, Para 7, Para 14, Para 17, Para 17, Para 3, Para 7(2, Para 3, Para 3, Para 27, Cyanamide, Cyanamide, Para 8, Para 9, Para 10, Para 15, Para 17, Para 7, Para 7(2)(a, Para 17, Para 7(2)(a, Para 7(2)(a

ORDINAL: First, first, first, second, second, first, Secondly, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, second, first, first, 6th, second, first, firstly, first, Secondly, first, third, second, second, 16th, Firstly

LOC: the Central Govt, the Central Govt, the Central Govt, Central Govt, the Central Govt

PERSON: Notification Notification, Parag P. Tripathi, R.N. Tandon, Swanstone Multiplex Cinema, T.R. Andhyarujina, S. Ganesh, Order, Order, Order, Order, Schedule, the Gazette Notification, Webster, P. Ramanathan Aiyar's, Orissa, Court, Kaul, Syeda Mustafa, Mohamed Gouse, Behari Lal v. Government, Drugs, Murthy Committee.34, Bulk, Shri, Andhyarujina, Herschell, Suresh Chand, others.(a

MONEY: 105.85, 122.00, 136.58

NORP: Statute