Dr.K.C.Bajaj and ors. Vs Uoi and anr.

Decided On : Aug-16-2010

Court : Delhi

LAW: the Full Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal, a Division Bench, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, the Division Bench, the Civil Appeal, Article 141.7, the Rule 7(D, Article 14."17, Article 136 of the Constitution, Article 136 of the Constitution, Article 142 of the Constitution of India, Rule 33, Article 136 of Constitution of India before Supreme Court, Article 136 of Constitution of India before Supreme Court, Section 19, Administrative Tribunals Act

CARDINAL: 1, 15, 01.01.1996, 272, 14, 12.09.2008, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, 18.05.2002, 01.01.1996, 11, 709, 37, 49, 33, 9(21)(a)(1, 1, 1960=100, 1.1.1996, 01.01.1996, 130, two, two, 73, 1, 153, 686.16, 12, One, two, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, 50%of, 1616.25, 30/33, 31.07.1987(b, 32, 2860.60, 61, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, 3, three, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 20.3.19996, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 7.6.1999, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 24.11.97, 27.5.98, 14.7.98, 7.6.1999, two, 1.1.1996, 11.9.2001, 7.6.1999, 1.1.1996, 1999.[Emphasis, 1.1.1996, 11.9.2001, 11.9.2001, 22, 11.09.2001, one, 8, 2, 1.7.1991, 27.5.1998i, 50, 419, 7.6.1999, 22400, 5600, 28000, 7.6.1999, 11.9.2001, 22400, 11,200, 1.1.1996, 7.6.1999, 11.9.2001."24, 01.01.1996, 19.10.1999, 07.04.1998).(ii, 7.6.1999, 11.9.2001, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 18.5.2002, 11.9.2001.(iv, 11.9.2001, 17.12.1998, 01.01.1996, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 12, 1.1.1996, 7.6.1999, 1.1.1996, 7.6.1999, 7.6.1999, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, three, 7.6.1999, 7.6.1999, 7.6.1999, 1.1.1996, 7.6.1999, 7.6.1999, 7.6.1999, 7.6.1999, 4, 683, 11.9.2001, 01.01.1986, 01.01.1996, 07.06.1999, 07.06.1999, 600, 29,500, 29,500/-.2, 01.01.1986, 01.01.1986, 01.01.1996, 5., 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 3.1, 31.12.1995.(b, pre-1996, 1.1.1996, 20.3.1996.(iii, 1.1.1996, 2/1/87-, 30,000, 1.1.1996, 6, 30.9.97, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 7, 17.12.1998, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 5, 30,000, 49, 1275/-, 3, 6, 7, 01.01.1996, 1, 7, 3, 1972)Step 4, 5, 01.01.1996, 1, 2, 3, 4, two, 01.01.1986, 17.12.1998:-, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 1.1.1996, 17.12.1998, Rs.2000-100-2700, 29.10.1999, Rs.2000-100-2700, 01.01.1996, 29.10.1999.15, 2001.16, 18.05.2002, 29.10.1999, 17.12.1998, one, 29.10.1999, 31.12.1965, 02.11.1987, 01.01.1996, 25, 27.05.1998, 01.01.1996, 1, 20-3-1996, II, 07.06.1999, 1, 1, 07.06.1999, 17.12.1998, 07.06.1999, 11.09.2001, 1, 11.09.2001, 11.09.2001, 11, 709, 11.09.2001, 07.06.1999, 7, 7, 1, 1, 1, 7, 1, 1, 7, 1, 32, 07.06.1999, 13, 1, three, 7, 22,400, 22,400, 7, 7, 1, 7, 7-6-1999."34, 11.09.2001, 1, 7, 11, 7, 1, 1, 1, 7, 1, two, 22,400, 23,450, 29,313, 14,656, 14,656, 11,200, 7, 7, 7, 7, 7, 29, 11, 07.06.1999, 07.06.1999, 17.12.1998, 17.12.1998, 29.10.2009, one, 12, 29.10.1999, 16, 45, 36, 4, 7.6.1999, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, one, 01.01.1996, 01.01.1996, two, 01.01.1996, 34, 17.12.1998, 07.06.1999, 11.09.2001, 17.12.1998, 17.12.1998.50, 29.10.2009

PERSON: Railways, Principal Bench, G.D.Hoonka, Retd, Gargs Case, B.J. Akkara, Retd, K.C.Gargs, B.J. Akkaras, Shivpada Ghosh, Ghoshs, Akkaras, K.G. Garg, Akkaras, K.C. Gargs, Akkaras, Ghoshs, Prashant Bhushan, Cadre, Revised Pay) Rules, Bhushan, Bhushan, Gargs, K.C.Gargs, Akkaras, Lal Beri v., Bhushan, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, K.C.Gargs, K.C.Gargs, S.P.S. Vains, Retd, Bajajs, W.P.(C, Rs.1900+Rs.500(NPA, Bajaj, Bajaj, Shanti Sen, Shanti Sen, Shanti Sen, Sen, Sen, Sen, Rs.2861/-"20, Circular, Deptt, corrigenda, R.K.Upadhyay, Akkaras, R.K. Upadhyay, Ranks, Fitment Weightage, K.C.Gargs, K.C. Garg v. Union, K.C.Gargs, S.L.P., Akkaras, K.C. Gargs, Akkaras, Akkaras, post-1996, Akkaras, Akkaras, K.C. Gargs, Akkaras, anb, Rs, Emphasis Supplied, Emphasis Supplied)10, Pre 01.01.1986 retireesStep, Rs.2,000/-, Principal Bench, Writ Petition(s, that:-, G.D.Hoonka, Principal Bench, B.J.Akkara, Retd, Akkaras, Akkaras, Shib Pada Ghosh v. Union, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkara, Shib Pada Ghoshs, Calcutta Bench, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Prashant Bhushan, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, K.C.Bajaj, that:-, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Vainss, Brigader, Vainss, Vains, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Akkaras, Principal Bench

ORG: the Directorate of Health Services, Maulana Azad Medical College, Employees State Insurance Corporation, Tribunal, Non Practicing Allowance, 5th Central Pay Commission, Government, 01.01.1996, the Government of India, 5th Pay Commission, Court, K.C. Garg & Ors, v. Union of India & Ors, Jabalpur High Court, Union of India & Ors, SLP, the Government of India, Government of India & Ors, Tribunal, us.4, Tribunal, 01.01.1996, Tribunal, OA No, Tribunal, Tribunal, Bench, the Honble Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Honble Supreme Court, the Fundamental Rules, the Fundamental Rules Pay, Government, the Central Civil Service, NPA, the Government Doctors, the Central Health Services Officers, 5th CPC, Government, The 5th Pay Commission, Government, Government, 5th Pay Commission, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, the Central Health Services, the Central Health Services Officers, the Supreme Court, D.S.Nakara & Ors, v. Union of India AIR 1983, Supreme Court, Hoonkas, SLP, Court, Court, Pension Rules and Fundamental Rules, Court, Civil Appeals No.1972/2003, the Union of India, the Union of India, Central Administrative Tribunal, the Supreme Court, Amrit, the Apex Court, Government, Court, the Supreme Court, K.I. Shepherd and Ors, v. Union of India & Ors, AIR, Supreme Court, Court, Court, Ministry of Defence, The Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Union of India, Major Generals, the "Fixation of a cut-off date, the Supreme Court, CPC, Fixation of Pension, 5th CPC, Rs.12930, CPC, the Pay and Accounts Officer, Railway Board, Ministry of Railway, Dearness, CPC, Rs.3232.5, CPC, Non-Practicing Allowance, the Supreme Court, B.J.Akkaras, the Apex Court, Fourth Central Pay Commission, Armed Force Officers, Ministry Circular, the Fifth Central Pay Commission, Pensioners The Ministry, Circular, the Armed Forces, DP &, The Ministry, Armed Force, The Ministry by Circular, Armed Forces, Armed Forces, Commissioned, Clause 2.1, pre-1.1.96, Ministry, the Ministry on the following, Circular, Circular, Ministry of Defence, Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, the Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Defence Letter No, Circular, the Controller General of Defence Accounts, Circular, the Controller of Defence Accounts.iii, Rank Pay, Court, the Union of India, the Apex Court, the Supreme Court, Delhi High Court, PPO, Rank, PPO, PPO, Circular, the Supreme Court, 01.01.1996, D.S.Nakaras, Reliance, Court, Defence Ministry Circular, The Apex Court, Circular, Circular, Circular, Circular, the Delhi High Court, Defence Service Medical Officers, Circular, Circular, Respondents, the Apex Court, Rank Pay and NPA, Circular, Apex Court, the Fifth Central Pay Commission, Circular, Circular, Circular, Circular, Circular, The Apex Court, the Apex Court, post 01.01.1996 retirees, "29, Court, Civil Appeal, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, the Delhi High Court, the High Court, the Union of India, Court, the Apex Court, State, Maharashtra v. Digambar, State, the State Government, the High Court, Court, State, Court, State, High Court, Court, State, State, Court, State, S.L.P., State, State, Court, the High Court, State, State, State, Defence Ministry, State, the Supreme Court, 01.01.1996.ii, the Supreme Court, Tribunal, the Supreme Court, K.C.Gargs, Pre-1996, the Supreme Court, Court, Hoonkas, the Apex Court, Tribunal, costs.(MOOL CHAND GARG, Mool Chand Garg, Non-Practising Allowance, Non-Practising Allowance, Non-Practising Allowance, Central Government, Fifth Central Pay Commission, CPC, 5th CPC, the Third CPC, CPC, The Fourth CPC, Cabinet, Emphasis, 5th CPC, The Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Government of India, Ministry, Central Health Service, Non Practicing Allowance @, The Non Practicing Allowance, Emphasis, 5th CPC, that:-, Fourth Central Pay Commission, 5th CPC, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Government of India, 5th CPC, the Fifth Central Pay Commission -- Revision, Government, Fifth Central Pay Commission, the Central civil Services (Pension) Rules, Railway, All India Services, the Indian Civil Service, Ministry of Defence, Armed Forces, Disability Pension, Railway, Railway, All India Service.4.1, Department, O.M. No, the Department of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare Office, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Government of India, the Fifth Central Pay Commission -- Revision, Government, Fifth Central Pay Commission, Department, Liberalised Pension Rules, Railway, All India Services, Government, Government, Fifth Central Pay Commission, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Government of India, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Government of India, CCS, Office Memoranda, Department, the Central Government, Central Civil Service, the Fundamental Rules, Government, Non practicing Allowance, the Medical Office, Fundamental Rules, Government, cadre:(ii, Central Civil Service, Department of Pension and Pensioner Welfare's, Consolidated Pension, CPC, Pension Department's, O.M. No, Consolidated Pension, CPC, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, vide office memorandum, Vth CPC Revision, Departments/Ministries, Non-Practising Allowance, the Department of Expenditure, O.M., 01.01.1996 Existing Pension, 01.01.1996 Stage I: Pension, Rs.1,000/- Dearness, Consolidated, Rs.8000/-, the Central Government, Central Health Service, the Central Administrative Tribunal, CAT, CAT, Court, Nos.7322, K.C. Garg & Ors v Union of India & Ors, Court, 5th CPC, the Central Government, Court, 5th CPC, N.P.A., Court, the Central Government, Petitions for Special Leave to Appeal, K.C.Gargs, Railway Board, Government of India, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Original Application, CAT, CAT, the Madhya Pradesh High Court, G.D.Hoonka, Union of India a Division Bench of, Madhya Pradesh High Court, the High Court, Union of India, Court, Central Health Services, Court, K.C.Gargs, Central Government, CAT, Court, K.C.Gargs, CAT, Ministry of Defence, Ministry of Defence, 5th CPC, CPC, Ministry of Defence, Ministry of Defence, DP &, Ministry of Defence, Ministries of Defence and Personnel, Public Grievance, Pension, Ministry of Defence, Dental, Army Medical Corps, Army Dental Corps, Veterinary Corps, Ministry of Defence, High Courts, Supreme, the Supreme Court, post 01.01.1996 retirees, K.C. Garg, G.D. Hoonkas, Court, Madhya Pradesh High Court, Court, Union of India, the Ministry of Defence.31, the Ministry of Defence, the Supreme Court, Court, Emphasis, Court, Court, Ministrys, Court, Court, the High Court, State, State, State, Defence Ministry, State, Supreme Court, under:-I. Stepping, Supreme Court, Court, Supreme Court, Court, post 01.01.1996 retirees, CAT, CAT, CAT, CAT, Supreme Court, K.C. Garg, Court, Supreme Court, CAT, CAT, t6he Supreme Court, CAT, CAT, Supreme Court, Supreme Court, Supreme Court, Fundamental Rules, Central Civil Service, 5th CPC, Railway Board, Government of India.43, CAT, Supreme Court, S.P.S Vains v Union of India, Supreme Court, K.C. Garg and Hoonkas, Supreme Court, Supreme Court, K.C.Gargs, IV).46, the Supreme Court, 5th CPC, the Ministry of Defence, Brigadier, Major General, Major General, anomaly, Ministry of Defence, Major General, Special Army Instructions 2, Special Instruction, Major General, Brigadier, Major Generals, the Supreme Court, Major General, Court, K.C. Garg, G.D. Hoonkas, Court, Madhya Pradesh High Court, the Supreme Court, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Ministry of Defence, CAT, Supreme Court, Supreme Court, CAT

GPE: Delhi, New Delhi, OA, W.P.(C)2539/2003, OA, O.A., India, India, India, New Delhi, pensions.27, K.C. Gargs, NPA:-"52.16, CCS, New Delhi, India, Jabalpur, K.C. Gargs, New Delhi, worded.27, K.C. Gargs, K.C. Gargs, K.C. Gargs, K.C. Gargs, supra).III, S.P.S., Vainss, New Delhi

DATE: 1927/2006, C.W.P. 7322/2001, 2006, 2295/2007, 1972, monthly, Rule 7(D, 1997, 1510, April 7, 1998, April 7, 1998, 29.10.1999, between pre and, between the post 1996, pre 1996, 18.05.2002, between pre and post 1996, 1975, 1988, 2008, between pre and post 1996, 8973/2004, January 1,1996, 33 years, only 30 years, 31 years 11 months 23 days, half year, 1.1.1986, 30.10.1987, 33 years, the last 10 months, 24.11.1997, 27.5.1998, 24.11.1997, pre 1996, pre 1996, 1510, 3.2.1998, the last 10 months, 33 years, 1.1.1986, 1.1.1986, 7th June, 1999, 1.1.1986, 7th June, 11.9.2001, 29.10.1999, 1845/2002, 833/2002, 24.11.1997, 22400, 2001, 22400, 14,000/- per month, 11.09.2001, 11.09.2001, 11.9.2001, 29.10.1999, 7322/2001, 11.09.2001, 29.10.1999, the last 10 months, 33 years, 33 years, 1996, 1.1.1986, 1986, the last 10 months, the last 10 months, 33 years, 33 years, 33 years, 1996, 1996, 7600, 22400-525- 24500, 22400, the 1996, pre 1996, pre-1996, pre 1996, the pre 1996, 1995, 29.10.1999, 01.01.1986, pre-1996, AUGUST 16, 2010, decades, around 27 years, 28 years of age.2, the 20th March, 1998, 27.07.1997, pre-1996, pre-1996, 31.12.1995, 1972, 31.12.1995, 1510, 14.4.1987, monthly, 10.02.1998, pre-1986, 27.10.1997, pre-1986, 1950, 1972, 1972, pre-1986, 10 months, pre-1986, 1.1.1986, 1.1.1986, 1.1.1986, 30.07.1997, 01.01.1986, 01.01.1986, 1972, October 27, 19972, 1,275 per month, 1st January, 1996, 1st January, 1996, 1972, monthly, 5, 30.07.1997, 1510, 1510, 01.01.1986, 29.10.1999, pre-1996, December 17, 1998, 1/1/1986, 1/1/1986, 1/1/1986, 29.10.1999, 27.10.1997, Rs.10,000/-, 29.10.1999, the year 1996, 7826, 7878, 15.01.1999, 15.01.1999, the year 1996, the year 1996, 1985, 29.10.1999, 30.09.1987, 33 years, the last ten months, pre 1996, pre 1996, 1510, the year 1996, between pre and, 11.09.2001, 2006, 1999, the last 10 months, 33 years, 33 years, pre-1996, 1986, pre-1986, 33 years, pre-1996, 1996, 7300-100-7600, 11-9-2001, 1999, the 1996, between pre and, 2001, 1996, 1-1996, pre-1996, 1999, 33 years, the year 1998, 5863, 1996, pre-1996, 1996, pre-1996, 11-9-2001, 29.10.1999, 29.10.1999, 12.09.2008, 29.10.1999, 1997, 2008, between pre and post 01.01.1996, 36, 01.01.1006, between pre and post 01.01.1996, 29.10.1999, 35, 29.10.1999

PERCENT: less than 50%, 50%, 50%, 25%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 25%, less than 50%, 25%, less than 50%, 25%, 25%, 96%, 50%, 25%, 25%, 50%, 25%, 111% and, 96%, 50%, less than 50%, 50%, 50%, less than 50%, less than 50%, up to 50%, 25%, 96%, 40%, 25%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, less than 50%, 50%, 50%, 40%, 50%, 50%, the 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, more than 50%, less than 50%, up to 50%, 25 to 40%, about 27%, 16%, 25%, 25%, less than 50%, 148%, 11%, 96%, 40%, 1250/- to 50% and 30%, less than 50%, less than 30%, 50%, up to 50%, less than 50%, 50%, 148%, 11%, 96%, 40%, 50 %, 25%, 50%, 148%, 11%, 96%, 40%, 50 %, 25%, less than 50%, 50%/30%, 50%, 25%, 50%, 50%, 50%, less than 50%, 25%, 50%, 111% and, 96%, less than 50%, 50%, less than 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, less than 50%, less than 50%, 50%, less than 50%, 25%, 50%, more than 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%

NORP: Hoonkas, Rules, Hoonkas, Rs.7346.6, Hoonkas, Hoonkas, J.1, Rs.8000, Rs.8000

PRODUCT: The Kolkata Bench, the Kolkata Bench, Rs.8081.25, Circulars, Rs.4,000/-Thus, the Jabalpur Bench, Calcutta Bench, the Full Bench

ORDINAL: first, second, 5th, 5th, 4th, 5th, 4th, 5th, 5th, first, second, third, 5th, Third, first, 4th, first, first, second, third, 5th

MONEY: one Dr.K.C.Garg, 50 per cent, 40 per cent, 50 per cent, 40 per cent

TIME: 1275/- p.m.

WORK_OF_ART: Basic Pay, Subject: Implementation of Government's, Pension, Subject: Implementation of Government of India, Calcutta Bench

QUANTITY: 7300-100-7600, 7300-100-, 01.01.1986 retirees

LOC: Central Railway, Nakara

FAC: Shib Pada Ghoshs