Union of India (Uoi) and ors. Vs. Major General Arun Roye, Avsm, Vsm and ors.

Decided On : Oct-12-2007

Court : Kolkata

LAW: Section 27, the Army Act, Serial 11, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 226 or Article 227 of the Constitution...., Constitution, Article 14, the Societies Registration Act, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Article 12, Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 14, Article 14 nor, Article, Article 14, Article 12, Article 14, Constitutional, Section 433A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 246(2, Constitution, the Article 14 of the Constitution of India, hereinbelow:.Article 14, Article 14, Article 14, Article 14, SLR 44, Section 27, the Army Act

PERSON: Biswanath Somadder, J.1, Sankar Roy Chowdhury.(iii, order.(vi, General.(viii, Arun Roye, Looks, N.D.C., Award, Nagendra Nath Bora, Anr, A.S. Sangwan v. Union, Satur, Bhandari, Ladder, Bhandari, Satur, Serial Nos, Y.K. Mehta, I.O., Satur, N.D.C., Lidder, E.R.E. Petitioner, Comparative Merit, Satur, Lidder, Lidder, N.D.C., N.D.C., Counsel, A.C.R.s, Articles 14, Khalid Mujib Sehravardi, Anr, Anr, Raghava Rajgopalachari).He, Branch, Generals, Nagendra Nath Bora, Anr, A.S. Sangwan v. Union of India, Anr, Scheduled Caste, Maneka Gandhi's, Onkar Lal Bajaj, Anr, Paragraphs 27, Anr, Raghava Rajgopalachari, Chandra Ghose

CARDINAL: two, One, two, 1, 1, 2000.3, 25, 5, 6, 7, one, two, two, 698, three, 39, 227, at least two, 364, 10, 12, 12(c, 1995]2SCR532, 559, 1997)IILLJ352SC, 15/16, 9, 2, 24, 588, 3-5, 205, 4, 228, 4, 202, 698-701, 39, 1, 7, 6, 2, 392, 1, 2, 206, 9.22, One, 2000.24, two, 2, two, two, 5, 1966, two, 1999/39, 2001/41.(ii, 07/97-06/98, two, 01.06.2000, 31.3.2000, 1, 2003/43, 7s, two, 206, 290, 7s, 609, 1968, 2003/43, 14.3.2002, fourteen months.(xv, 14.3.2002, 2, 235, 2, 4, 289, two, 1999-, 632, 981, 981of, 234, 1968, 10, 14.3.2002, 6, 7, 6, 7, 632, 981, II, 16, six, 1999.33, 2000.35, 1981)ILLJ103SC, 1980CriLJ1440, 2002]SUPP5SCR605, 2004)192CTR(SC)492, one, 10, 9, 2003.7, 2002.40, 1958]1SCR1240, 17, 1957]1SCR98, 1995]2SCR532, 18, 559, 2, two, one, 1997)IILLJ352SC, 12, 13, thirteen, two, 9(Nine, 4(four, 8, 45, 487, 16, 16, two, 1980CriLJ1440, 2, two, one, two, 2002]SUPP5SCR605, 36, two, one, 48, 2004)192CTR(SC)492, 9, 10:.While, 50, 364, 12

DATE: 25th April, 2006, 25155, 2005, 2965, 2006, 2255, 2006, the year 1996, 7th April, 1998, 28th December, 1999, ' January, 2000, 7th April, 1998, 1st January, 2000, the month of April, 2000, the month of October, 2000, the year 2001.(vii, the month of April, 2001.(viii, the month of April, 2000, the month of April, January, 2000, the month of April, 29th March, 2005, 14th March, 2002, 2nd February, 2006, 8th February, 2006, 24th February, 2006, 29th April, 2006, 25.4.2006, October, 1998, the year, October, 1998, October, 1999, the year 1996, January, 1997, 1997, January, 1998, 1967, October, 1999, the year 2000, 6th March,, 2006, 12th February, 2007.(v, the year 1996, the year 1997, the year 1998, N.D.C. 1999, the year 1999, 1996, 25th April, 2006, 6th December, 1995, the year 1998, the year 2000, 7th April, 1998, 7th April, 1998, 7th April, 1998, 7th April, 1998, 14th January, 2000, 1st January, 2000, 2965, 2006, 2001, April, 2001, December, 2005, December, 1995, 1967, June, 1996, 10th January, 2007, 1967, October, 1996, N.D.C. 1997/37, October, 1997, October, 1997, 1967, N.D.C. 1998/38, 7th April, 1998, June, 1997, 24, 34, 12, 17, July, 1998, 1967, October, 1998, 1st, 2nd, 1999, N.D.C. 2000/40, 1967, October, 1996, N.D.C. 1997/37, October, 1997, 2nd, N.D.C. 1998-99, '1st, 1995, N.D.C. 1996/36, 1998, N.D.C. 1999/39, N.D.C. 1997, 1967, 1996, 1997, N.D.C. 1998/38, 2000, 1999, 1967, N.D.C. 2000/40, September, 1999, the two years, October, 1999, Dec., 1999, May, 2000, 1998, 1999, October, 1999, 1967, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1997-98, 1998-99, January, 2000, 4 months, 1997-98, 1998-99, December, 1999, February, 2000, 2000, January, 2002, May, 2002, May, 2000, October, 2000, July, 2000, April, August 2000, 1999, September, 2000, September, 2000, August, 2000, November, 2000, 1967, U.S.A. 1996, 1998, 2000, 07 November, 2000, 1997-99, September, 1999, February, 2001, September, 2001, 2001, 7th January, 2002, N.D.C. 2000, May/June, 1998-1999, 1967, April, 2001, 1967, October, 1998, N.D.C. 1999, 14th March, 2002, N.D.C. 2000, 1967, N.D.C. 2000, 1996, N.D.C. 1997/37, 1997, 1967, October, 1999, 2000, earlier than October, 1999, 14th March, 2002, 1967, N.D.C. 1997, 1996, 1996, 14th March, 2002, 1998, 1999, 1967, 1967, 1998, N.D.C. 1999, 1999, N.D.C. 2000, fourteen months, 14th March, 2002, 28th February, 2005, 2nd February, 2006, 1967, 2255, 2006, N.D.C. 1999, N.D.C. 2000, N.D.C. 1999, 1997, 1997-1999, 1997-1999, 1999, April, 2000, August, 2000, February, 2001, years 1985, Ors.)1972 SLR 44, 2006, 6th December, 1995, June, 1996, the period July, 1996 - June, 1997, October, 1997, 18th December, 2001, 10th January, 2007, 1967, N.D.C. 1997, 1996, N.D.C. 1998 in the year 1997, September, 1999, the two years, July, 1996-June, 1997 and, July, 1997-June, 1998, October, 1999, between December, 1999, May, 2000, 19th December, 2002, 19th December, 1992, 30th December, 2002, 10th January, Quarter, 21st April, 2005, 28th January, 2005, 21st April, 2005, 19th December, 11, 12, 13, 11.5.1993, 1980, 1964, 1964, the year 1990-91, 1954, 16, 1978, 1972, 6th December, 1995, June, 1996, October, 1997, 10th January, 2007, 1967, 1997, 1967, 1999, October 1998, 18th December, 2002, October, 1998, 1999, 1967, 18th December, 2001, 12c, 2965 of 2006, 25th April, 2006, 2005, 2255, 2006, N.D.C. 1999 for 2000, N.D.C. 1999, 1997-1999, 1999, 1997-1999.61, April, 2000, April, 2001, August, 2000, February, 2001, 25th April, 2006, the years 1985 to 2000, the year 2000, 2255, 2006

ORG: the Hon'ble First Court, Union of India and Ors, Army, inter alia, the Hon'ble First Court, G.O.C., Bengal Area, the Hon'ble First Court, Military/Defence Attache, the U.S.A. as M/DA, Army, the Hon'ble First Court, Army Headquarters, the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, the National Defence College, N.D.C., Confidential Reports, Extra-Regimental Appointment', Major General, N.D.C., N.D.C., the Hon'ble First Court, Major General, Major General, the Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., Major General, Branch, the Central Government, Army, the Special Selection Board, the Hon'ble First Court's, the Special Selection Board, Lieutenant General, Special Selection Board, N.D.C., N.D.C., COAS, the Special Selection Board, Lieutenant General, the Hon'ble First Court, the appellants Union of India and Ors, The Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., N.D.C., The Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., the Hon'ble First Court, the Adverse Career Certificate, the Adverse Career Certificate, the Hon'ble First Court, Major General, Adverse Career Certificate, the Adverse Career Certificate, N.D.C., the Union of India, N.D.C., and4th, the Brigadiers/Colonels, each Arm/Service, the Special Selection Board, N.D.C., Special Selection Board, MED, the Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., Adverse Career Certificate, the Hon'ble First Court, M/DA, Certificate, M/DA, N.D.C, the Union of India, the Hon'ble First Court, the Union of India, the Union of India, SRO, the Union of India, RO, SRO, the Union of India, RO, SRO, the Union of India, the Union of India, the Union of India, N.D.C., Adverse Career Certificate, the Union of India, the Defence Services Regulations, the Central Government, the Union of India, the Hon'ble First Court, the Union of India, Confidential Reports, the Union of India, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Hills Division and Appeals, Dewan v. Union of India, Counsel for Union of India, the Hon'ble First Court, the Writ Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Supp, Rajasthan v. Sriram Verma, Counsel for Union of India, Advocate for Union of India, N.D.C., Major General, Army, a Selection Committee, IO, Army, SRO, National Defence College, Union of India, Court, N.D.C., the Chiefs of Staff Committee (COSC, Numeric, High Commissions/Embassies, the Channel of Reporting, Army, Navy, Air Force, Army, Lieutenant Generals, Army M/, Learned Senior Counsel, Union of India, N.D.C., the Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., Brigadier K.S. Sindhu, Major General, N.D.C., Qualitative Requirement, Looks' for N.D.C, N.D.C., N.D.C.25, Major General, M/DA to, N.D.C., Army, N.D.C., AVSM, Operation Vijay, Army, N.D.C., Extra Regimental Employment, M/DA, Union of India, the Hon'ble First Court, Army, N.D.C., the Ministry of Defence.(viii, Blank, M/DA, Union of India, N.D.C., Army, Non-Promotability', N.D.C., N.D.C., the Northern Command, Army, inter alia, Overall Profile, Army, N.D.C., M/DA, N.D.C., Promotability, M/DA, N.D.C., N.D.C., Major General, First Review, N.D.C., Army, New Qualitative Requirement, Army, N.D.C., N.D.C., Complaint/Redressal, Naidu, YSM, YSM, VSM, M/DA, Naidu, Army, the Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., Union of India, the Adverse Career Certificate, Union of India, N.D.C., Major General, Additional Solicitor General, the Hon'ble First Court, Additional Solicitor General, Government of India, the Hon'ble First Court, the Additional Solicitor General, the Hon'ble First Court, Union of India, N.D.C., N.D.C., the Union of India, Adverse Career Certificate, N.D.C., N.D.C., N.D.C.29, Brigadier K.S. Sindhu, Brigadier, the Union of India, N.D.C., the Union of India, N.D.C., the Union of India, the Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, the Central Government, Lieutenant General, this Court of Appeal, the Hon'ble First Court, Extra Regimental Employment', the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, the M/DA's, Extra Regimental Employment', N.D.C., N.D.C., M/DA, the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., Major General, the Hon'ble First Court, Major General, the Hon'ble First Court, Major General, Major General, Lieutenant General, Army, the Hon'ble First Court, Major General, the Hon'ble First Court, Maru Ram v. Union of India and Ors, Onkarlal Bajaj and, Ors, v. Union of India, Commercial Tax, Union of India, this Hon'ble Court, the Adverse Career Certificate, Army, SRO, the Chiefs of Staff Committee (COSC, High Commissions/Embassies, navy, Government of India, Brigadier K.S. Sindhu's, N.D.C., Brigadier Sindhu, Army, Extra Regimental Employment', Army Officers, Army, Branch, Branch, Army, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Hills Division and Appeals, Counsel of Union of India, the High Court, the High Court, the High Court, Court, New Prakash Transport Co. Ltd., New Suwarna Transport Co. Ltd., Court, Tribunal, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Union of India, Dewan v. Union of India, the Indian Armed Forces, Lieutenant General, Army, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Lieutenant General, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, a Court of Enquiry, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Central Government, the Selection Board, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Army, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, petitioner.43, the Union of India, Supp, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Armed Forces, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, inter alia, Union of India, the Union of India, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Union of India, The Supreme Court, the Union of India, The Supreme Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Government, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Central Government, Court, the Directorate of Military Farms, the Union of India, State, Rajasthan v. Sriram Verma, the Rajasthan Administrative Service, Rajasthan Administrative Services Rules, the Rajasthan Civil Services Appellate, the Rajasthan High Court, the State of Rajasthan, the Rajasthan High Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Court, Government, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, AIR 1981, SC, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Corporation, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Government, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, inter alia, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, AIR 1974, Article, Ajay Hasia's, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, AIR 1978, SC, Ajay Hasia's, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Courts, State, State, Maru Ram v. Union of India and Ors, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Parliament, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Ors, v. Union of India, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Government of India, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, inter alia, State, Government, Government, Court, eschew, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Government, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Commercial Tax, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, inter alia, State, State, State, State, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Government of Assam, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the State of Assam, Government, Government, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Government, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble First Court, Additional Solicitor General, the Hon'ble First Court, M/DA, navy, High Commissions/Embassies, Bench, N.D.C., Union of India, N.D.C., Government of India, Brigadier K.S. Sindhu's, the Union of India, Brigadier K.S. Sindhu's, Clauses 10, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Government of India, Counsel for Union of India, the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, Umon of India, the Hon'ble First Court, W.P. No, the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, Bench, N.D.C., the Hon'ble First Court, N.D.C., Major General, The Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, Major General, Major General, the Hon'ble First Court, the Hon'ble First Court, The Hon'ble First Court, Major General

GPE: U.S.A., USA, U.S.A., USA.(v, A.C.R., C.R., service.4, U.S.A., U.S.A., U.S.A., U.S.A., USA, IO, A.C.R., A.C.R., IO, IO, U.S.A., A.C.R., India, I.P.S., India, Anr.)14, U.S.A., U.S.A., A.C.R., U.S.A., C.R., U.S.A., U.S.A., C.R., C.R., Embassy, C.R., U.S.A., USA, India, India, Brig, U.S.A., India, C.R., India, Jammu, C.R., U.S.A., U.S.A., C.R., C.R., U.S.A., U.S.A., U.S.A., A.C.R., India, U.S.A., U.S.A., Assam Rifles, U.S.A., A.C.R., A.C.R., A.C.R., U.S.A., U.S.A., U.S.A., C.R., C.R., India, United States of America, I.P.S., Counsel, the State of Rajasthan, United States of America, reporting.54, U.S.A., U.S.A., USA, A.C.R.

ORDINAL: first, second, second, second, first, 1st, 2nd, first, 2nd, first, third, fourth, first, second, second, second, first, first, first, first, first, second, first, first, First, 7th, 7th, First, first, first, second, first, 7th, 7th

PERCENT: N.D.C. 2000.(vi

NORP: Shortlist, Indian, Hon'ble, Bannari, Bannari

WORK_OF_ART: Officers for N.D.C;v, 'Look' for N.D.C.(ix, 'Look', 'Ati Vishisht Seva Medal' (, 'Look', 'Look' for N.D.C, 'Look' for N.D.C.b, 'Look' for, 'Look' for NDC, 'Look', 'Look' for

EVENT: Serial 16, Pokharan-II

LOC: Kashmir

PRODUCT: Bench, hereinbelow:.The, the Rule 28B(11)(b, Constitutional, Bench

FAC: Assam Rifles, the Ajay Hasia's, Constitutional, Constitutional, the Ajay Hasia's