Manoj Singh and Dharma Mahato @ Dharam Nath Mahato and ors. Vs. State of West Bengal

Decided On : Sep-15-2006

Court : Kolkata

LAW: Section 302/34, Section 302, Section 302/34, Section 364/34, Section 302/34, the Arms Act, the Investigating Officer, the Arms Act, Section 302/34, Section 302/34/364, the Evidence Act, Section 212 of the Cr., Section 464 of the Cr., Section 302/34, Section 302/34, Section 302/34, Section 302/34, Section 354, Section 364/34, Section 364/34, Section 302, Section 364/34, Section 364/34, Section 364/34, Section 364/34, Section 364/34, Section 364/34, Section 364/34, Section 302/34, Section 364/34, Section 302/34

ORG: P.N. Sinha, Additional Sessions, 13th Court, Alipore in Sessions Trial Case No, IPC, the Trial Court, IPC, CRA No, IPC, IPC, CRA No, IPC, intention.3, First Information Reports, FIR, Aloke Chandra Pandit, FIR, Metiaburuz P.S. Case No, IPC, FIR, Goddess, P.W., Shiv, Dilip Kumar Sarkar (P.W. 5, FIR, Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Metiaburuz P.S., Dilip Kumar Sarkar, Faring,, Moila, Metiaburuz P.S., FCI Godown, Metiaburuz P.S., IPC, Sections 25 and, P.W. 5 Dilip, Trial Court, P.W. 2 Rajendra Singh, P.W., P.W. 5, P.W. 7, P.W. 10 Uttam, P.W., P.W., P.W., P.W. 4, FIR, the Public Prosecutor-in-Charge, FIR, Public, P.W. 7 Binod, P.W., P.W., Kantapukur, M.R. Bangur Hospital, P.W., the Metiaburuz P.S Case No, Ext, O.C. Control Room, Dilip Kumar Sarkar (P.W. 5, Ext, Ext, Magistrate, Kali Temple, Dharam, Dharam, Aloke Pandit, Goddess Durga, T.G. Road, Goddess Durga, Shiv, Court, P.W. 7, WPA, Aloke Pandit (P.W. 1, Shiv, Jadavpur P.S. U.D. Case No, S.P. P.S., Aloke Chandra Pandit, Ext, Sri Pandit, Ashok Chakraborty (P.W., ASI Section Karmakar, Magistrate of Alipore, Metiaburuz P.S. Case No, IPC, Metiaburuz P.S. Case No, Aloke Pandit, Aloke Pandit, Aloke Pandit, I.O., T.G. Road, the M.R. Bangur Hospital, Aloke Pandit, Ext, Belpukur Sarbojonin Durgotsav Committee, Ext, Ext, P.W. 3, P.W. 7, IPC, Metiaburuz P.S. Case Nos, Magistrate at Alipore, P.W. 2, G.D. Entry, Public Prosecutor, FIR, Ext, Metiaburuz P.S., G.D. Entry, Ext, P.W., Court, G.D. Entry, FIR, FIR, Magistrate, FIR, I.O., Magistrate, Ext, FIR, FIR, Magistrate, the Supreme Court, State of Jammu & Kashmir, LJ, the Supreme Court, the First Information Report, Magistrate, FIR, Court, FIR, FIR, State, The Supreme Court, LJ, P.W. 3, P.W. 7, Ext, State, Siva, I.O., Ext, Shiv, Shiv, Shiv, the Trial Court, the 313 Cr, Court, the Court of Appeal, FSL, AIR1995SC1601, Public Prosecutor, FSL, the Supreme Court, FSL, the Supreme Court, FIR, FIR, AIR 1993, SC, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Court, Mahabharata, FIR, FIR, Court, Calcutta Metropolitan Development Authority, FIR, LJ, FIR, FIR, The Supreme Court, Bishna @ Bhiswadeb Mahato, FIR, FIR, FIR, FIR, the Supreme Court, Dhirajbhai Gorakhbhai Nayak, FIR, FIR, the Supreme Court, FIR, the Supreme Court, I.O., Metiaburuz P.S. Case No, P.W. 7, P.W. 1, Moila, Public Prosecutor, Court, P.W. 3, P.W. 7, IPC, IPC, IPC, IPC, IPC, Trial Court, Trial Court, the Trial Court, IPC, Public Prosecutor, IPC, Trial Court, IPC, Trial Court, IPC, Trial Court, IPC, the Trial Court, the Trial Court, the Trial Court, the Trial Court, IPC, Trial Court, Court, Court of Appeal, Sections 385, Court, the Trial Court, the High Court, Court, the Trial Court, Court, Government, Court, the Trial Court, the Trial Court, IPC, IPC, IPC, IPC, IPC, CRA No, the Trial Court, the Trial Court, CRA No, CRA No, the Lower Court Records, the Trial Court, P.S. Datta

NORP: J.1, Rajan, Rajan, Durga, Hindu, P.Ws, Kali, P.Ws, P.Ws, P.Ws, P.Ws, P.Ws, P.Ws, P.Ws, P.Ws, P.Ws, Kali

DATE: 2000, three months, 2.10.98 under Section 302/34, 3.10.98, about 28/30 years, 2nd October, 1998, that day, October, 1998, 3.10.98, the same day, about 30 years later, 3.10.98, that day, 7, 5.10-98, 2006, 1691, 1994, 7, 8, 14, 7, 2nd October, 1998, 2004, 2005, 1037, 2005, 1050, 1983, 1661, 1987, 2006, 2/3 days, 7, 8, 1996, 1999, 7, 7, 8, the year 1998, 30 days

CARDINAL: 302/34, 10,000/-, two, 221, four, 224, two, one, Two, two, 1, 157, 5/6, 5/6, 314, two, one, 4, 5, 5, 364, 27, one, as many as 15, 6, 8, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 15, 2, three, 15, 12, 4, 5, 13, 12, 6, 12, 157, 2.10.98, 5/6, one, 92, 2).11, one, one, 8, 9, three, one, one, one, five, five, two, two, 3, 4.14, 8, two, 2/3, 8, two, 3, 4.16, three, two, only one, two, 2, more than 15, one, 398, One, 3/4, 3/4, 1/2, 3/4, 1/3, 3/4, one, 11, One, 3/4, 3/4, 1', 3, one, one, 1, 1, 15, 3, 8), three, 379, 19.12.96, 379, one, one, five, one, one, five, 12, 4, one, 47, one, two, 3, two, 4, one, 25, 27, 379, 19.12.96, 388, 29.12.96, 92, 1, 3, 8, 10, one, 2.10.98, 1.0, 15, 1, 92, 1, 5/6, one, one, 92, 14, 1.0, 1.0, 3, 15, 11, 3, 851.44, Only two, two, 3, 7, 8, 1469.46, 2/3, 113, 1, 696, 2003CriLJ3723, one, One, three, 8, two, 3 and 4, 3, 379, 19.12.96, 388, 159, 469, 3, 7, 8, 3, 3, 8, three, two, three, three, 3, 3, 7, 8, one, 3, 7, 8, 3, 7, 8, three, 2/3, one, 3, 7, 8, three, three, one, three, 302, 302/34, one, 15, 5, 221, 2 to 5, 224, 221, 224, 2001.61

GPE: R.I., Oria, Babulal, S.P.P.S., Kumar Rajbhar, Kumar Rajbhar, S.P.P.S., Lalbazar, Rahis, R.T., Oria, Oria, R.T., S.P.P.S., S.P., P.S., P.S., Metiabuuz, P.S., Gujarat, Kali, incident.39, Kali, P.C., P.C., Singh v. State of Punjab, Singh v. State of Punjab, Delhi, Rajasthan, Karnataka, Delhi, Bihar, Gujarat, Bhagwan, Rajasthan, Karnataka, Titagarh, N~, P.S., Cr, P.C., Cr, P.C., Cr, J.62

PERSON: Manoj Singh, Dharma Mahato, Dharam Nath Mahato, Rajesh Rai, Dianna Dubey, Dharma, Dubey, Dharma, Dharma, Dharma, Tarak, Rabi, Rajesh Rai, Dilip Sarkar, S.P.P.S. Case, I.O., Kumar Sarkar, Roy @ Rai, Chandra Pandit, Roy Chowdhury, Dilip Kumar Sarkar, Chandra Karmakar, Firoz A. Khan, Kumar Mukherjee, Pran Gopal Bhattacharya, S.K. Saha, Lal Shaw, Rajesh Rai, I.O., S.K. Saha, Chottu Lai Shaw.10, Dharma Mahato, S.P.P.S. Case, Metiaburuz P.S., Dinanath Dubey, Dharma, Manoj Singh, Tarak Singh, Monoj Chowdhury, Exts, Raj an Singh, Aloke Pandit, Accused Dharma, Dharma, Manoj Singh, Manoj Chowdhury, Tarak, Dharma, Dharma, Dharma, Exts, Rajen Singh, Kali, Dharma, Chottu Lal Shaw.19, Roy, rigor mortis, Rajesh Kumar, Roy, ASI Section Karmakar, Dharma Mahato, Dharma, Ajoy Roy Chowdhury, Binod Rajbhar, Chandra Bahadur Sonar, Binod Rajbhar, Binod Rajbhar, Dhananjoy Singh, Dharma, Dharma, Swapan Bagchi, Binod Rajbhar @ Kalia, Madan Singh, Councillor, Sekhar Basu, Counsel, Ramayana, Kazi Safiullah, Dubey, Basu, Ramayana, Basu, I.O., Accused Dharma, Dharma, Mohan Singh, Basu, Councillor, Councillor, Dhananjoy Singh, Safiullah, Ramsinh Bavaji Jadeja v. State, Basu, Kali, Safiullah, Kali, Kali, Kali, Kali, Kali, Kali, Basu, Basu, telephonic message, Basu, Basu, Safiullah, Dharma, Safiullah, Dhanaj Singh @ Shara v. State of Punjab, Basu, Dharma Mahato, Dubey, Dubey, Dhanaj Singh v. State of Punjab, Basu, Basu, Ahmed Ansari, Raja Ram v. State, Bhimappa Jinnappa Naganur, Ahmed Ansari, Raja Ram v. State, S.K. Bose, Ram Udgar Jha v. State of, Name, Basu, Bhimappa Jinnappa Naganur, Dubey, I.O., Exts, Basu, Ajoy Roy Chowdhury, Safiullah, Dharma Mahato, Dharma Mahato, Basu, Dihunath Dubey, Dubey, Dubey, Dharma, Dharma, Dharma, Dharma, Dharma, Dinanath Dubey, Dharma Mahato, witnesses.54, Dharma Mahato, Manoj Singh, Tarak Singh, Manoj Chowdhury, Dharma, Dharma Mahato, Basu, Rajesh Rai, Rajesh Rai, transaction.56, Kazi Safiullah, Rajesh Rai, Rajesh Rai, Roy @ Rajesh Rai, Rajesh Rai, I.O., Rajesh Rai, Rajesh Rai, Rajesh Rai, Roy @ Rajesh Rai, Rajesh Rai, Manoj Singh, Nos

TIME: 11.15 p.m., about 10.30 p.m., 8.30 p.m. to, 6.30 a.m., about 10.30 p.m., about 00.45 hours, 10.25 p.m., the eventful night, about 10 p.m., 3.00 a.m. night, about 10 p.m., night, 9.45 p.m. to 3 a.m., about 10.15 p.m., the night, that night, 30 hours, 24 hours, about 10 p.m., about 10.30 p.m., 10.25 p.m., about 10.30 p.m., about 10/10.30 p.m. P.W. 12, about 10 p.m., about 10.35 p.m., 10 p.m., about 10 p.m., 10/15 minutes, about 10 p.m., 2/3 minutes before 10 p.m., 10 p.m. or 1/2 minutes, night, 10.25 p.m., about 10.35 p.m., about 10 p.m., 10.35 p.m., of few minutes, around 10 p.m., 10.30 p.m., around 10 p.m., 10.50 p.m., 11.15 p.m., that night, 10 p.m. Besides, about 4.45 a.m., 5.15 a.m., about 10 p.m., 30 minutes, 11.15 p.m., that very night, that very night, between 1.15 a.m. to 1.50 a.m.

PRODUCT: P.W. 1, Shiv, P.W. 5, Rajesh, P.W. 1 Aloke, P.W. 1, P.W. 5, P.W. 3 Ajoy Roy Chowdhury, P.W. 11, Rajesh Rai, P.W. 14, P.W. 13, P.W. 9, Rajesh Roy.12, Shiv, Shiv, P.W. 3, Shiv, P.W. 8, P.W. 3, P.W. 8, P.W. 11, Rajesh, Abrasion 1' inch x 1/2' inch, P.W. 12, P.W. 1, P.W. 15, Shiv, KF-95, P.W. 8, P.W. 1 and, P.W. 2, P.W. 1, P.W. 1, P.W. 12, P.W. 12, Dhananjay Singh, P.W. 8, Shiv, Shiv, Shiv, Shiv, Shiv, Shiv, Shiv, P.W. 1, P.W. 1, P.W. 3 and, P.W. 3, P.W. 2, P.W. 7, P.W. 3 and P.W. 8, Shiv, P.W. 8, Shiv, P.W. 8, Shiv, Rajesh, P.W. 9, Rajesh

WORK_OF_ART: S.P.P.S. Case No, Diary No., Metiaburuz P.S. Case No, Metiaburuz P.S. Case No

FAC: Brooklyne FCI Godown, Brooklyne FCI Godown, Brooklyne FCI Godown, Metiaburuz P.S., T.G. Road, the Kali Temple, T.G. Road, Chandra Bahadur Sonar, T.G. Road

ORDINAL: first, 3rd, 10th, 11th, third, second, second, second

QUANTITY: 1' inch, 21/2' inch, 2' inch, 11/2' inch, 6' inches x 4' inches x 1/4'inches.(2, 1' inch, 1' inch, 13/4' inch, 4' inch, 2' inch, 1' inch

LOC: case.27, the T.I. Parade, Metiaburuz P.S.