United States Vs. Old Settlers

Decided On : Apr-03-1893

Court : US Supreme Court

LAW: article three of the supplemental Treaty of 1836, article four of the Treaty of 1846, article 4 of the Treaty of 1846, Article 2, Article 3, Article 8, Article 1, Article 8, Article 10, Article 15, Article 11, Article 12, Article 16, Article 17, Article 2, Article 3, Article 4, Article 12, Article of the treaty, Article 1, Article 2, Article 3, Article 4, Article of the Treaty of 1835, Article of the Treaty of 1835, Article 5, Article, Article 6, Article 7, Article 8, Article 9, Article 9, Article 10, Article 11, Article 12, Article of the supplement thereto,, Article 9, Article 11 of the Treaty of 1846, Article of the supplementary, Article of, Article 4 of the Treaty of 1828, Article Treaty, Article 3, Article of the treaty, Article 4 of the Treaty, Article of the Treaty of 1846, Constitution, Constitution, Article two of the Treaty of

GPE: United States, U.S., United States, U.S., United States, U.S., the United States, United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, Arkansas, Arkansas, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, Arkansas, the United States, the States of North Carolina, Tennessee, Georgia, Alabama, the United States, the United States, Washington, Arkansas, United States, Arkansas, Arkansas, the United States, Arkansas, Arkansas, Mississippi, Arkansas, the United States, the United States, Arkansas, the United States, the United States, Arkansas, the United States, the United States, Georgia, the United States, the United States, New Echota, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, The United States, the United States, The United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the Cherokees East, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, The United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, The United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, Maine, United States, United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, United States, The United States, Arkansas, the United States, the United States, Tablequah, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, pp, United States, the United States, the United States, Arkansas, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, MR, the United States, the United States, the United States, Arkansas, the United States, U.S., the United States, United States, Florida, Missouri, the United States, the United States, Spain, the United States, the United States, the United States, Virginia, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States, the United States

DATE: 1893, 1893, 1031, 1032, December 13-14, 1892, April 3, 1893, August 6, 1846, 1846, March 8, 1889, January 23, 1890, February 25, 1889, February-third, August seventh, sixty days, sixty days, 1817, 1819, May 6, 1828, February 14, 1833, 1828, 1833, 1835, 1846, 1828, 1833, 1835, September 30, 1850, 1835, 1835, 1846, 1835, 1836, the fifteenth, 1835, 1846, 1846, 1846, Sept. 30, 1850, 1846, September 5, 1850, the 12th of June, 1838, the 6th day of August, 1846, 1846, 1828, 1833, 1835, September 30, 1850, June 12, 1838, 1846, 1828, June 12, 1838, November 28, 1785, 18, the 26th of December, 1817, 1808, January 9, 1809, 1818, March 10, 1819, 1835, May 28, 1828, twelve months, February 14, 1833, 1828, 1828, December 29, 1835, May 23, 1836, 1828, 1833, 8, 10, one year, one year's, two years west, annually, annual, annually, June, 1833, two years, the same day, May 23, 1836, 1835, December 29, 1835, December 31, 1838, February 27, 1833, 1835, 1837, 1838, June 12, 1838, 97, August, 1838, January, 1840, July, 1839, between the years 1838 and 1846, June 18, 1846, August 3, 1846, 1828, 1833, August 6, 1846, 1828, 1828, 1835, 1835, 1835, 1835, 1835, 1835, 29th December, 1835, 1835, 1835, 1836, the one year's, May, 1838, 1835, 1835, August 8, 1846, August 13, 1846, August 7, 1848, August, 1846, the 8th of August, 1850, 1846, 1835, the year 1835 to 1846, 1848, 1846, 1835, 1846, 1835, 1846, September 5, 1850, June 12, 1838, the 12th day of June, 1838, 1835, year, 1838, June 12, 1838, the one year, 12th June, 1838, June 12, 1838, one year, the one year's, September 30, 1850, the year ending June 30, 1851, fifth day of September, August, August, the year ending June 30th, September 30th, 1850, December 3, 1849, September 30, 1850, one year, June 12, 1838, September 30, 1850, September 30, 1850, 1833, the years 1875, 1876, 1877, 1879,, 1880, 1881, 1882, 1883, 1846, October 25, 1883, 1835, 1842, 1835, 1842, September 22, 1851, the year 1875, August 7, 1882, February 23, 1883, July 2, 1836, 1835, 1836, July 2, 1836, 1836, June 12, 1838, September 22, September 22, 1851, February 9, 1881, another March 29, 1882, September 30, 1850, February 13, 1884, March 3, 1863, February 9, 1885, August 8, 1850, 1883, 1838, June 12, 1838, February 25, 1889, November 30, 1891, January 25, 1892, that day, 1835, 20, 56, September 22, 1851, September 30, 1850, August 8, 1850, February 3, 1883, August 8, 1850, February 3, 1883, 1828, 1833, June 12, 1838, February, 1889, 1846, August 6, 1846, the 12th day of June, 1838, May 6, 1828, August 6, 1846, 105 U. S. 671, 1846, 1851, June 12, 1838, 1846, 1846, May 23, 1828, May, 1824, 1824, 1828, February 25, 1889, 1846, February 3, 1883, August 7, 1882, 1851, 1828, 1835, 1833, December 31, 1838, the years 1842 to 1846, 1842, 1835, June 16, 1843, June, 1846, the 3d of August, 1846, the 6th day of the same month

ORG: U.S. Supreme Court, Old Settlers, the Court of Claims, Congress, Congress, the Cherokee Nation, Cherokees, Congress, the Western Cherokees, Congress, the Western Cherokees, Court, the Court of Claims, the Court of Claims, Wilson, the "Old Settlers, the Western Cherokee Nation, the "Old Settlers, Wilson, Congress, the Court of Claims, the Old Settlers, the 'Old Settlers, Congress, Congress, Congress, the Court of Claims for adjudication, Congress, Court of Claims, the Supreme Court, Supreme Court, SEC, the Western Cherokees, Old Settlers, the State of Arkansas, the Western Cherokee Nation, Page 148 U. S. 430 , the Western Cherokee Nation, the "Old Settlers, Indian Territory, Indian Territory, the Eastern Cherokee Nation, the Western Cherokee Nation, the Eastern Cherokees, the Western Cherokee Nation, the Eastern Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, Eastern, Eastern, Eastern, the Western Cherokees, the Eastern Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, Congress, the Eastern Cherokee Nation, the Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Senate of the United States of, the Eastern Cherokees, the Court of Claims, Cherokees, the White Rivers, White Rivers, Cherokees, the "Old Settlers, the Cherokee Nation of Indians, the Cherokee Nation of Indians, Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Eastern Cherokees, the Western Cherokees of, the "Cherokee Nation of Indians, Cherokees, Cherokees, Senate, Senate, the Cherokee Nation, the council of the, the council of the nation, the Cherokee Nation, Cherokees, the Cherokee Nation, Cherokees, Cherokees, Page 148 U. S. 441 , Senate, the War Department, Senate, Senate, Senate, Senate, Cherokees, Interior, Indian Affairs, the Cherokee Nation, the Cherokee Nation, the Eastern Cherokees, The Eastern Cherokees, Congress, the Indian Territory, Congress, the Indian Territory, the Cherokee Nation, the Western Cherokees, the Eastern Cherokees, Cherokee Nation, Cherokees, Western Cherokees, Senate, the Western Cherokees, Western Cherokees, Senate, the Eastern Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Cherokee Nation of Indians, the Cherokee Nation, the Cherokee Nation, the Cherokee Nation, Cherokees, the Cherokee Nation, the 'Old Settlers, Cherokees, Cherokees, Cherokees, the Old Settlers, Western Cherokees, Page 148 U. S. 447 , the Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, Cherokees, the 'Western Cherokees, Western Cherokees, the Cherokee Nation, the Cherokee Nation, Cherokees, Cherokees, the Eastern Cherokees, the Senate of the United States, Cherokees, The Western Cherokees, 'Old Settlers, the Senate of the United States, Senate, Senate, Senate, Congress, Treasury, the Cherokee Nation of Indians, Congress, Senate, Senate Report 1st Sess, Eastern Cherokees, Congress, Comptroller of the Treasury, Treasury, the Cherokee Nation of Indians, the Cherokee Nation, Senate, the Cherokee Nation, the Western Cherokees, Senate, Cherokees, Senate, the Senate of the United States, the Cherokee Nation of Indians, Treasury, Senate, Eastern, Congress, Treasury, Congress, the Indian Department, Senate, the Senate of fifth September, Cherokees, Senate, Western Cherokees, Indian Affairs, the Indian Department, Old Settlers, Senate, the Senate of the United States, the Eastern Cherokees, Western Cherokees, Western Cherokees, Senate, the 'Old Settlers' Cherokees, Senate, the 'Old Settlers', Congress, the Interior Department, the Western Cherokees, Cherokee Nation, Wilson, the Western Cherokees, Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Cherokee Nation, the "Ridge Party, the Eastern Cherokees, the "Ross Party, Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Eastern Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, the Old Settlers, the Old Settlers, Congress, Page 148 U. S. 458, Interior, Congress, the Cherokee Nation, Congress, Senate, Congress, the Whole Cherokee People Dr. Cr. , Indian Affairs, Eastern, the Western Cherokees, Senate, the Western Cherokees, Senate, Congress, Congress, Congress, the Old Settlers, the Court of Claims, Senate, Congress, Eastern Cherokees, Interior, the Eastern Cherokees, Eastern Cherokees, Eastern Cherokees, Western Cherokees, Eastern, Western Cherokees, Congress, the Court of Claims, the Court of Claims, Nott, Nott, the Eastern Cherokees, the Court of Claims, the Western Cherokees, the Cherokee Nation, the Court of Claims, the Court of Claims, The Court of Claims, the Western Cherokees, the Western Cherokees, Court, the Court of Claims, Court, the Court of Claims, Court, the Court of Claims, Court, the Court of Claims of the, Court, Court, the Court of Claims, the Court of Claims, the Western Cherokees, Court of Claims, Congress, the Court of Claims, The Court of Claims, Congress, Fletcher v. Peck, , Ex Parte McCardle, People v. Draper, N.Y. 545, Congress, the supreme court, Taney, Sanborn, Court, the Superior Court, Congress, Court, Congress, Congress, Congress, Congress, Congress, Page 148 U. S. 468 , Congress, Congress, Congress, the Court of Claims for adjudication, Congress, Congress, Congress, Congress, Congress, Osborn v. Bank of United States, Norwood, Lessee, Congress, The Court of Claims, Congress, Cherokees, the Treaties of 1828 and, the Cherokee Nation of Indians, the Cherokee Nation, Eastern, the Western Cherokees, the Eastern Cherokees, Eastern, the Western Cherokees, Western Cherokees, Senate, the Western Cherokees

CARDINAL: 148, 148, 427, 9, 871, 25, 694, 238, eighteen hundred and eighty-three, eighteen hundred and eighty-two, sixty, 2, one-third, one-third, two-thirds, two-thirds, 9, 556, one-third, one-third, one-third, one-third, 2,495, 295, 2,200, 1/4, 433, 159,572.12, 264,894.09, 500,000.00, 500,000.00, 2,200, 44,000.00, 1/3, 863,653.84, 532,896.96, 8 and 11, one-third, 30,000.00, 9,179.16 1/4, 1/3, 2/3, one-third, 166,666.66 2/3, 1/3, 5, five, 27, 1, two, one, one, one, 156, About one-third, one-third, two-thirds, 7, 195, one, 311, 313, 7, 465, two, 1, 15, one hundred and fifty thousand dollars, three hundred , 478, 3, 488, 13,574,135.14, nearly a million, two, some 2,200, 295, 14,757, 5, 241, 9, 871, 5, one-third, five, 11, 12, thirty-three, five-million, 9, 339, 176, one, 451, 159,572.12, 264,894.09, 18,026, 961,386.68, 61,073.49, 22,212.76, 101,348.31, 500,000.00, 500,880.00, one-third, two, 601, 105.55, one million, five millions, 9, 544, 556, eighteen hundred and forty-six, one hundred and eighty-nine thousand four hundred and twenty-two dollars, eighteen hundred and forty-six, five hundred and thirty-two thousand, eighteen hundred and forty-six, eighteen hundred and forty-six, 18,026, one-third, 18,026, one-third, 18,026, one-third, two hundred thousand, thirty-three cents, one, three hundred and thirty thousand dollars, thirty-five, 22, 433, 302, 328, forty-seventh, 60, 600,000.00, 2,495, 18,026, 961,386.66, 159,572.12, 264,894.09, 8,026, 961,386.66, 101,348.31, 500,000.00, 500,880.00, one-third, 844,244.40 , one-third, one-third, 2,495, 44,352.78, 57,452.78, 5, 522,342.21, 354,583.25, 887,480.15, two, 17,252, 18,026, 2,495, 17,252, 2,495, 133,058.35, One-third, 532,896.90, 17,252, 920,049.16, One-third, 532,896.90, 25, 694, 27, 1, 500,000.00, 1,540,572.27, 159,572.12, 264,894.09, 22,212.76, 16,957, 339,140, one-third, 532,896.90, 148, two, 16,957, 18,026, 2,495, two hundred and twenty-four, eight hundred and thirty-two thousand, 450, two-thirds, one-third, 113.65, 6, 130, 7, 506, 15, 555, 33, 278, 8, 302, 2, 561, 117, 6, 691, two, one, four, two, 6, 264, 738, one, 5, 344, two-thirds, two-thirds

LOC: Mississippi, Mississippi, Mississippi, the Mississippi River, the Arkansas River, the Mississippi River, White, Mississippi, Mississippi, Mississippi, Mississippi, Mississippi, the Mississippi River, the Mississippi River, Mississippi, Mississippi, the Mississippi River, the Mississippi River, Mississippi, Mississippi, Mississippi, Mississippi, the Mississippi River, Mississippi, Mississippi, the Mississippi River, Mississippi, the Mississippi River, the Mississippi River, the Mississippi River, the Western District

PERSON: Bryan, Bryan, Cr, Cr, Ridge, Ross, Articles, Articles 2, John Ross, Ridge, Edmund Burke, William Armstrong, Albion K. Parris, Articles 4, Articles, Articles, Cong, Parris, Journ, Cong, Articles of, John Drennen, Supt, Bryan, Bryan, Rogers, Smith, Cherokees, CHIEF JUSTICE FULLER, Harvey v. United States, JUSTICE BLATCHFORD, Harvey v. United, Justice Nott, 1 Story, Eq, Kilbourn, Penn, Wright, Gordon v. United States, Arredondo, Cohens

WORK_OF_ART: Western Cherokee, Treaty, Western Cherokees, The Cherokee Nation, Such Cherokees, The Treaty of New Echota

NORP: Indians, Indians, Western Cherokee Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Western, Western, Western, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indian, Western, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indian, Western, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indians, §, Spanish, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians, Indians, Indian, Indians

PRODUCT: Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, the 'Treaty of, Cherokee, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee Nation, Cherokee, Cherokee Indians, Cherokee, the "Old Settlers, Cherokee, 9 Wheat, Cherokee, Cherokee, Cherokee

ORDINAL: second, seventh, first, fourth, 4th, 4th, 4th, eleventh, First, ninth, Second, fourth, Third, fourth, fourth, second, first, first, second, tenth, fifteenth, first, eighth, fifth, twelfth, 7th, Second, second, 4th, 15th, 10th, 10th, 12th, 4th, first, third, second, eleventh, fourth, eleventh, eleventh, first, fourth, fourth, 4th, 5th, first, fifth, first, second, first, third, second, fourth, fifth, first, second, fourth

QUANTITY: all 13,610,795.34 acres, 13,610,795.34 acres, 800,000 acres, 800,000 acres, 3,343.41 acres, 7 Stat, 7,000,000 acres, 13,610,795.34 acres, five pounds, the 7,000,000 acres, 800,000 acres, the 800,000 acres, 13,610,795.34 acres, the 7,000,000 acres, eighteen hundred and thirty-five, eighteen hundred and fifty, eighteen hundred and fifty, 3,343.41 acres, 14,000,000 acres, 800,000 acres, 3,343.41 acres, 13,610,795.24 acres, 7,000,000 acres, the 7,000,000 acres, 800,000 acres

MONEY: $5,671,164.72 1/2, 30,000, 532,896.90, 500,000, 500,000, 5,600,000, 500,000, 500,000, 1,540,572.27, 159,572.12, 264,894.09, 600,000, 20, 44,000, 9,179.16, 5,600,000.00, 1,540,572.27, $3,009,038.48 $, 2,590,961.52, 62 1/2 cents, $5,671,164.72 1/2, 30,000, 532,896.90, $866,230.23 1/3, $5,671,164.72 1/2, 166,666.66, 866,230, 1/3 $5,710,343.88 3/4, $4,844,113.65, 330,756.94, 9,179.16, 30,000, $369,936.10 1/4, five hundred thousand dollars, five millions of dollars, five millions of dollars, three hundred thousand dollars, twenty dollars, thirty-three dollars, thirty-three cents, two hundred thousand dollars, fifty thousand dollars, sixty thousand dollars, 10,000, 214,000, one hundred thousand dollars, 5,000,000, five millions of dollars, five millions of dollars, six hundred thousand dollars, three hundred thousand dollars, six hundred thousand dollars, one hundred thousand dollars, four hundred thousand dollars, five hundred thousand dollars, 714,000, 500,000, 214,000, 5,600,000, 600,000, 6,730,000 , sixty thousand dollars, 5,600,000, 1,047,067, 189,422.76, 5,000,000, five million six hundred thousand dollars, 115,000, 2,000, 5,000, 20,000, five millions of dollars, 6,647,067, 5,000,000, 600,000, 1,047,067, 5,600,000.00, 1,540,572.27, 53.33, 18,062.06, 5,600,000, 523,782.18, 189,422.76, 1,047,067, 600,000, 1,047,067, 1,047,067, 600,000, 2,952,196.26, 972,844.78, 172,316.47, 800,528.31, 611, 189,422.76, only $611,105.55, seventy-six cents, ninety cents, 345,583.25, 189,422.76, 189,422.76, $33.33 1/3 cents, $33.33 1/3 cents, 600,856.66, 200,285.33, 330,000, 4,179.26, 421,653.68, 5,000,000.00, 53.33, 1,540,572.27, 53.33, $4,028,653.45 $, 2,532,733.21, 844,244.40, 600,000, 39,300, 13,100.00, 53.33, 133,058.35, $57,452.78 $, 844,244.40, 786,791.62, 786,791.62, $532,896.90 , $887,480.15 $, 421,653.68, 961,386.66, 2,532,733.21, 1,047,067, 53.33, 133,058.35, 920,049.16, 2,532,733.21, 2,399,674.86, 799,891.62, 266,994.72, 2,532,733.21, 53.33, 1,612,684.05, 537,561.35, 4,664.45, 5,600,000.00, 500,000.00, 20, 2,273,608.76, 757,869.58, 224,972.68, 500,000, 500,880, 101,348.31, 22,212.76, 18,062.06, 61,073.49, 20, 339,140, 53.33, 961,386.66, 53.33, 133,058.35, 4,179.26, 4,179.26, 224,972.68, sixty-eight cents, 603,145.58, 4,179.26, 832,297.52, fifty-two cents, 62 1/2 cents, $5,671,164.72 1/2, 30,000, $9,179.63 1/4, 500,000, 500,000, 532,896.90, 4,844, 330,756.94, $9,179.16 1/4, 30,000, $369,936.10 1/4, 500,000

PERCENT: five percent, five percent, five percent, five percent, five percent

FAC: the Second Comptroller and Second Auditor, Fort Gibson

EVENT: the Treaty, Article of the Treaty of sixth day of