Allergan Inc Vs. Milment Oftho Industries and ors.

Decided On : Nov-06-1997

Court : Kolkata

LAW: Rajdhani LR 263

PERSON: Allergan Inc, OCULAR, Eric D. Donnenfeld, A.K. Ghosh, A. K. Ghosh, A. K. Ghosh, Eurway Int, Sheraton Corpn, Sheraton Motels, Tnd., Vitamins L. D.'s, Goodwill, Muller, Trego, Hunt, B.C. Srinivas Shetty, N.R. Dongre v. Whirlpool Corporation, J. N. Nichols, FSR, Stanard v. REAY, Chippy, Buckley J., Chippy, Lordships, N. R. Dongre v. Whirlpool Corpn, J. N. Nichols, F. Hoffman - La, A. G. v., Vitamins L. D.'s, mark I956(1)RPC I, Lloyd-Jacob J., Santen, AR Surgery News, Eric Donnenfeld, Ciprofloxacin, Eric D Donnenfeld, Arun Ghosh, Ghosh, 234).33, Roshan Lal Duggar, Cor, S. C. Ghosh, J., Baskin Robbins Ice-cream, Samperil Aktiergesell, Hindusthan Pencils Pvt, Samrat Pharmaceulicals, Devendra Kumar Jain

GPE: India, India, Australia, South Africa, Australia, Bolivia, Equador, Mexico, Peru, South Africa, Canada, the United States of America, India, US, US, USA, US, US, US, US, USA, Bombay, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, Canada, India, India, Bombay, India, England, America, Allergan, the United States, Allergan, Allergan, France, Italy, U.K., Greece, Brazil, Australia, South Africa, Allergan, Australia, Brazil, France, Greece, Italy, South Africa, the United Kingdom, Canada, Spain, Tokyo, Osaka, Japan, India, Norfloxacin, Canada, India, L.D., India, India, Delhi

ORDINAL: first, first, 30th, first, first, first, second, first, second, third, First, Second, Thirdly, first, first, 30th, first, first, first

NORP: Indian, Indian, Canadian, Pseudomonas, Indian, Indians, Indian

ORG: Court, FLOX, the Commissioner of Food & Drug, Control Administration, the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, Allergan India Ltd., Nicholas Pirmal Ltd., the Drug Controller, Learned, Court, Black & Ghosh, the Trade & Merchandise Marks Act, Black & Ghosh, Black & Ghosh, Court, Learned, Others Court, Cie v. Pavilion Properties, Amway Corporation, RFC 82.'Still, Levassor v. Panhard Motor Co. Ltd., Orkin Exterminating Co., v. Pest Co., McCain Foods, IRC, AC 217, AC 7, ITC, Rose & Thistle, Calvin Klein Inc., International Apparels, Conagra Inc., McCain Foods (Supra, Indian Pharmaceutical, Trade Marks, Consolidated Foods Corporation, Brandon & Co., Satellite Television, Court, Rose & Thistle, DDSA Pharmaceuticals, the Trade Mark Authorities, Court, an American Corporation, Court, Court, SCRIP, the US FDA, Offoxacin, Santen/Daiichi, SCRIP, the appellant:'The US FDA, ofloxacin, Daiichi, The Leading Medical Newspaper for Opthalmologists', read:'The Food & Drug Administration, Ocuflox, Daiichi Pharmaceuti-cals Co. Ltd., Santen Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd., American Journal of Opthalmology, AJO, World, Opthalmic, AJO, Ref: Journal, OCULAR TISSUES & FLUIDS, SUPERIOR TO OFLOXACIN & NORFLOXACIN Review, Ofloxacin, Ofloxacin, the Physicians Desk Reference, the Red Book, USP Dictionary, Opthalmic Drug, American Drug Index, International Drug Directory of Swiss Pharmaceutical Society, Congra Inc., McCain Foods (Supra, Century, DB)).34, Astra -IDL Ltd., TTK Pharma Ltd., Ruston & Hornby Ltd., Zamindara Engineering Co., East End Hosiery Pvt. Ltd., Agarwal Textile Mills, appellant.36, American Cyanamid Co., Ethicon Ltd., AIR, Century Electronics Ltd., CUS Enterprises Ltd., Gutman & Anr, Fleet Street Reports, Synthetic Mouders, Astra-IDL Ltd., TTK Pharma Ltd., India Stationery Products, Court, Court, Learned, date.46, xerox, Court

DATE: 9th Sept, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, the period January to August, 1996, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, between January and August, 1996, 1993, 26th July, 1993, 25th August, 1993, Sept. 1993, Oct. 1993, 15th Nov. 1994, 29th Dec. 1994, January, 1995, June, 1995, July, January, 1995, 1958, early 1996, Dec. 1996, 18th Dec. 1996, 29th January, every three months, 1993, 1993, more than 2 years, between 1993 December, 1996, 29th December, 1994, 1958, 27th January, 1997, 1967, 1974, 1901, 1964, 1985, 1956, 1993, 1901, 1896, 1994, 1995, 1995, 1967, Three weeks later, the 3 short weeks, today, '18, 1994, '19, 1972, the last two decades, '21, 1992, 23rd February, 1993, December, 1992, '24, 26th March, 1993, 17th August, 1993, the end of the year, '25, 15th October, 1993, November, 1993, 1992, 1995, the years 1995 and 1996, 1994 and 1996, 1997, 1996, 1996, 1995, October, 1993, as early as 15th October, 1993, 15th November, 1994, 29th November, 1994, 1975, November, 1994, 1992, 1983, 1976, 1980, 1994, 18th December, 1996, 4 weeks

LOC: Europe, South America

CARDINAL: 5960034, 1, 1, 4., 1, 1996.5, 1997.7, 1, 1, 1, about 4, 5, 3, two, 581, 18, 5, 433, 1, 1, 23, 193 231, 1981]128ITR294(SC, 515, 83, 133.14, 19, 1996)5SCC714, one, one, one, two, One, 27, eight, seven, 1989;23, 527, 112, 345, 79, 606, 29, time.30, 1, 32, two, 233, 1970]2SCR222, two, 1, 302, 545

MONEY: 1,51,000, 7,064,472, 14,344,010, 10,974,869, $ 0.3 million, $ 2.6 million, US$ 2.7 million, $ 2.1 million, $ 1.9 million

FAC: the Fourth Schedule, Fleet Street Reports 1

QUANTITY: 1 am

PERCENT: 0.3%, 91.9%

PRODUCT: Calcutta