The Regional Director, Southern Regional Business Centre, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. and Post Retirement Benefit Scheme Trust Rep. by Its Executive Officer, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd., Prbs Section Vs. Union of India (Uoi) Rep. by the Secretary, Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas and the Chairman-cum-managing Director, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. and 68 ors. - Semantic Analysis by spaCy

Decided on: Sep-26-2007

Court: Chennai

LAW: Circular, the Supreme Court.6, the Trust Deed, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Article 226 of the Constitution of India.16, Circular 40, Section 7(2, Section 7(kk, Para 39, Payment of Gratuity Act, Minimum Wages Act, the Provident Funds Act, Article 38, Article 39, Article 41 of the Constitution, Article 42, Article 43, Article 47, Employees Provident Fund Act, Section 12, Section 17, Section 17, Section 17, Section 17, Section 1, Section 17, the P.F. Act, the Provident Funds Act, Rule 2(2, Section 80(c, Section 2, the Income Tax Act, Section 2of, Section 2, theIncome Tax Act, Chapter VI-A under Section 80(c, Section 80(c, Article 226 of Constitution of India, Article 226 of Constitution, the Trust Deed, Section 12, Provident Fund Act, Section 14 of Gratuity Act, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the Trust Deed, the Trust Act, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Section 80(c

PERSON: R. Banumathi, A.K. Sundaram, Actuary, Actuary, Actuary, Item no.8, Writ Petitioners, Naziruddin, Chandrasekaran, Masilamani, Actuary M/s. Mercer Human Resources Consulting, Vibishanan, Masilamani, Head F&A, Chandrasekaran, A.K. Sundaram, Vasudevan, Rs, Masilamani, Nazirudeen, Darshan Engg, Hema Chandra Rao, Anr, Nazirudeen, Supp, West Bengal, Goa, Anr, Goa, Anr, Nazirudeen, Masilamani, Trustees, Nazirudeen, Sadguru Shree Muktajee, Anr, Counsel, Andhra Pradesh, W.A. Nos

NORP: J.1, Mandamus, Unions, Mandamus, Mandamus, Mandamus

ORG: ONGC, Post Retirement and Death, PRBS, Trust, Association of Scientific and Technical Officers, ONGC, PRBS, the Workmen's Compensation Act.3, the Government of India, the Income Tax Department, ONGC, Bombay High Court, PRBS/40, W.P., High Court, PRBS, PRBS, 05.11.1996, ASTO, ONGC, M/s. K.A. Pandit, PRBS, MOU, the Central Working Committee, ASTO, ONGC, M/s. K.A. Pandit, PRBS, MOU, the High Court, the Writ Petitioners, EPS, Writ Petitions before Supreme Court:Employees Pension, ONGC, EPS, Ministry of Labour, Government of India, EPS, ONGC, W.P. No, the Supreme Court of India, ASTO, PRBS, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, W.P. No, ONGC, EPS, the Supreme Court, ONGC, the Ministry of Labour, Government of India, EPS, Government, EPS, ONGC, EPS, ASTO, PRBS, Human Resources Consulting, Central Working Committee of ASTO, ONGC, Central Working Committee of ASTO, PRBS, PRBS, Income Tax Department, MOU, ONGC, ASTO, Board of Directors, ONGC, PRBS, PRBS Trust, ONGC, the Writ Appeals, Judgment.10, PRBS, PRBS, PRBS, EPS, PRBS/40, the Writ Petitioners, the Private Trust, EPS, Circular, PRBS/40, PRBS, PRBS, Employees Pension Fund, the Central Government, ONGC, ONGC, PRBS, EPS, PRBS, Central Government, ONGC, PRBS, ONGC, ASTO, PRBS, the Central Government, PRBS, ONGC, PRBS, the High Court, EPS, PRBS, PRBS, EPS, PRBS, PRBS, PRBS, Principles of Natural Justice, ONGC, ASTO, ASTO, PRBS, MOU, ONGC, ONGC, Counsel for the Provident Fund Scheme, Principles of Natural, Corporation, ONGC, PRBS, Circular, PRBS, the Employees Pension Scheme, the Government of India, MOU, MOU, PRBS, Scientific, PRBS, the Principles of Natural Justice, PRBS/40, ONGC, EPS, ASTO, EPS, ASTO, Principles of Natural Justice, MOU, MOU, PRBS/40, MOU, PRBS, MOU, ONGC, ASTO, PRBS, EPS, ASTO, Court, MOU, ONGC, ASTO, ASTO, MOU, ASTO, MOU, ASTO, ASTO, ASTO, MOU, UCO Bank, Sanwrnal with Oriental Bank of Commerce, MOU, Bank, the Supreme Court, MOU, MOU Circular, MOU, PRBS, PRBS, Management, ASTO, the Payment of Wages Act, the State Government, PRBS, Trust, Board of Trustees, the Central Government, PRBS, Head F & A, ONGC, PRBS, PRBS, the Post Retirement and Death-in-Service Benefit Scheme, AUTHORITY, Chennai, Post Retirement Benefit Scheme, ONGC Self-Contributory Post Retirement and Death-in-Service Superannuation Benefit Scheme, Civil Suit, Rajahmundry, State of Andhra Pradesh, Permanent Injunction, PRBS, Defendants, PRBS, PRBS, the Judgment of Bombay High Court, PRBS, ONGC, p.a, Voluntary Contribution, ONGC, PRBS, the Bombay High Court, Bombay High Court, 05.11.1996, Scheme, Scheme, the Officers Association, Corporation, The Bombay Association, ONGC, the Bombay High Court, the Bombay High Court, ASTO, CWC, ONGC, Actuary K.A. Pandit, MOU, Bombay High Court, Bombay High Court, MOU, MOU, PRBS/40, Central Government, EPS, Joint Committee, ASTO, PRBS, ASTO, ASTO, PRBS, PRBS, LIC, ONGC, ASTO, ONGC, ONGC, ASTO, ONGC Board, ONGC, the Commissioner Income Tax, Board, PRBS, ONGC, PRBS Trust, the Bombay High Court, K.A. Pandit, the Writ Petition, ONGC, EPS, Central Government, EPS, PRBS, EPS, Central Government, EPS, the Supreme Court, ONGC, Central Government, General Public, the Payment of Bonus Act, Employees' State Insurance Act, State, State, State, State, State, State, the Central Government, PRBS, Central Government, PRBS, EPS, Counsel, LLJ 114, the Bombay High Court, Bombay High Court, AIR 1964, v. Union of India, PRBS, EPS, the Employees Provident Fund Act, the Supreme Court, the Central Government, EPS, IFJ, National Ex-servicemen's, Association, Anr., Union of India, Bengal Ingot Co. ltd., v. Regional Provident Fund, Reliance, Regional Provident Fund, Bombay High Court, PRBS, Central Government, PRBS, EPS, PRBS, the Central Government, ASTO, ONGC, EPS, CWC, ASTO, MOU, the Income Tax Department, PRBS, Central Government, PRBS, ONGC, PRBS, EPS, ONGC, Court, MOU, MOU, PRBS, Agreement, PRBS, Annuity Factor, ONGC, PRBS, the 'Fund', ONGC, PRBS, LIC, LIC, LIC, LIC, LIC, LIC, PRBS Trust, Income Tax, PRBS, PRBS, PRBS, ONGC, Central Government, EPS, AIR 2004, OITS Elevator Employees Union v. Union of India and Ors, EPS, the Supreme Court, Provident Fund, Pension Fund, Deposit Linked Insurance Fund, The Supreme Court, Mafatlal Group Staff Association and Ors, Regional Commissioner Provident Fund, the Central Government, PRBS, Board of Trustees, Board of Trustees, The Board of Trustees, ONGC, CWW, Trustees, Court, PRBS Trust, a Public Trust, PRBS Trust, the High Court, Counsel, Shri Anadi Mukta, V.R. Rudani, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Trustees, Gujarat University, University, Trust, Teachers, Trust, Supreme Court, Management, Union of India, Burmah Shell, Gratuity and Provident Fund, the Supreme Court, Provident Fund, the Supreme Court, the Trust Deed, Trust, Court, Trust, Trust, ONGC, ONGC, the Civil Court, Permanent Injunction, ASTO, Court, ONGC Management, CWC, PRBS, PRBS, MOU, PRBS, PRBS

CARDINAL: 40, 16.11.1995, One, 184, 16.11.1995, 39, 39, 499/1999, 490/1999, four, five, three, about 23, 5, 320, 17,107, 128.16, 21654/2000, 31435/2000, two, one, 16.11.1995, 16.11.1995, 40, 16.11.1995, 1, PRBS.18, 16.11.1995, 39, 1995.20, 18.06.1998, 1995.21, 23, 2004)IILLJ490SC, PRBS.27, one, 19,300/-, 1.4.90/16.11.95/, One Hundred, one, 184, 3.2.1998, one, 320, 250, 80, 170, 170, 170, 150, 17,107, 128.16, 39, 490/1999, 4, 27, 3, 214, 176, 38, 39, 39, 16.04.2005, 01, 39, 92.379, 16.11.1995.Rule, 28BB, 18.4, 28BB, one-third, 28BB, 17,107, 31.07.2007, 128.16, 1994)IILLJ382SC, two, four, one, seven, three, 1989)IILLJ324SC, 1, 1, 1981)ILLJ79SC Som, 16, facts.55, 14, two, as many as 21, 8

DATE: 18.06.1998, 23.10.1991, 18.09.1991, 05.02.1991, 1990, 1718/1996, 1718/1996, 03.02.1998, 1995, 1995, 11.11.2003, 16.01.2004, 1995, 01.03.2007, 01.03.2007, 01.04.2007, 21635, 31416, 2771, 2772/2004, 1995, 1995, 16.11.1995, 1995, 1995, 1995, 1995, 18.06.1998, 40, 01.04.1990, 01.04.1990, July 1998, 18.06.1998, 1995, EPS-1995, 18.06.1998, August 1998, 1995, 18.06.1998, monthly, 18.09.1991, nineteen thousand three hundred, the year 2005-2006, nineteen thousand three hundred, April 2005 to March 2006, 1718/1996, 1718/1996, 1996, 03.02.1998, 29.04.1998, 18.06.1998, 1995, 2005, 03.02.1998, 19.07.1998, the financial year 2006-07, last three years, last three years, 2007-08, the financial year 2007-08, next three years, 31.07.2007, 1995, 1995, 1995, 1995, 1995, 1977, 1995, 1995, 1999, 1997, 18.05.2005, 01.03.2007, 1961, 1961, a couple of years, about 25 years to, 50 years, a few years, 28.05.2007, 03.02.1998, 19.07.1998, monthly, first day of the month of implementation.3, First day of the month, annual, every year, annual, 1961, 15 years, 15 years, 1961, guar- years, Clause15 years, 1961, 100/-Rs, less years, 1995, 1995, monthly, every three years, long years, less years, long years, 23.10.1991, 01.03.2007, 2771, 2772, 2004

WORK_OF_ART: Benefit Scheme, a Memorandum of Understanding, the Writ Petitioners, Principles of Natural, the Writ Petition, SC, Justness and Fairness, 'The Act

GPE: Bombay, Bombay, Bombay, W.P.M.P. Nos, W.A., justice.12, Bombay, that:(i, Dehradun, Singh, Single, Ganga, Trust.53, Counsel, India, India, Rajahmundry, New Delhi, Uniform

PERCENT: between 2% to 11%, 8%, 2.00% to, 11.00%, 50%, 82%, 10%, more than 40%

PRODUCT: Para 1 - (c, Benefits, Para 10, Voluntary Retirement Scheme

TIME: 1608.33 p.m.

FAC: Bombay High Court.33

EVENT: P.F. Act, I.T. Act, the I.T. Act